Religion, myth and the sacred

Conventional orthodoxy

conventional orthodoxy; conventional, conventionalism

Dante's received theology, which Botticelli would not accept

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordA conventional orthodoxy is right belief held by custom and agreement rather than by personal conviction.
  • In The RenaissanceBotticelli "is far enough from accepting the conventional orthodoxy of Dante" (BOT §5).
  • In this editionThe note at BOT §6 says that Pater "turns a category that Dante judges severely into a place from which a painter can observe human uncertainty sympathetically".
  • A place to readBOT §5, with CON §5.

Meaning

Conventio is a coming together, an assembly or an agreement; the conventional is what is settled by agreement, and by Pater's day the word also meant what is merely customary, unoriginal. Orthodoxy is right opinion (see Orthodoxy). The phrase sets the two together so that each qualifies the other: the opinion is right by the agreement of others, not by the holder's own sight.

Use in the book

The phrase opens the fifth paragraph of the Botticelli essay, which turns from likeness to difference. Botticelli resembles Dante in his visionariness (BOT §4; see Visionary painter), "But he is far enough from accepting the conventional orthodoxy of Dante" (BOT §5), which, referring all human action to the formula of purgatory, heaven and hell, leaves "an insoluble element of prose in the depths of Dante's poetry" (BOT §5; see Insoluble element of prose). "Conventional" is a sharp word for the author of the Divine Comedy. Pater does not deny Dante's genius; he says that its conventional orthodoxy leaves a residue of prose in the poetry (see Insoluble element of prose).

The difference is made concrete in the next paragraph. "So just what Dante scorns as unworthy alike of heaven and hell, Botticelli accepts" (BOT §6; see Middle world). The conventional orthodoxy has places for the saved and the damned and contempt for those who are neither; Botticelli's sympathy goes to those very people (see Sympathy). His heterodoxy, in Pater's telling, is not a rival creed. It is the Palmieri fantasy that he "may well" have let pass "across him" (BOT §5; see Alexandrian philosophy), a sentiment rather than a doctrine.

The word "conventional" recurs through the book, and almost always as a limit. Vasari's second edition changed his image of Leonardo "into something fainter and more conventional" (LEO §2); a sacred subject is often Leonardo's pretext "for a kind of work which carries one altogether beyond the range of its conventional associations" (LEO §25); the old criticism of Michelangelo's sonnets was "conventional criticism" (MIC §10); the medieval treatment of the Creation of Man "became almost conventional, handed on from artist to artist" (MIC §18). The Conclusion makes the principle general: "The theory or idea or system which requires of us the sacrifice of any part of this experience, in consideration of some interest into which we cannot enter, or some abstract theory we have not identified with ourselves, or of what is only conventional, has no real claim upon us" (CON §5).

The phrase can be read as the Conclusion's principle applied to Dante. A belief held by convention is one "we have not identified with ourselves", and it leaves its residue of prose. Pater asks of a poet what he asks of a reader: not that he believe less, but that what he believes be his own. The neighbouring warning against "a facile orthodoxy" (CON §5; see Orthodoxy) makes the same point from the other side. Only in sculpture does Pater accept the conventional without complaint, where the Tuscan sculptors' "system of conventionalism as skilful and subtle as that of the Greeks" (ROB §11; see Conventionalism) and the Greek colour "more or less conventional" (WIN §34) are the discipline of a medium, not the surrender of a mind.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "conventional" or "conventionalism" occurs, in the order of the book.

  1. BOT §5Botticelli is far from accepting the conventional orthodoxy of Dante.
  2. ROB §11The Tuscan sculptors join repose to expression by a system of conventionalism as subtle as the Greeks'.
  3. MIC §10The older, conventional criticism assumed that the sonnets were addressed to Vittoria Colonna.
  4. MIC §18The medieval treatment of the Creation of Man became almost conventional, handed on from artist to artist.
  5. LEO §2Vasari's second edition changed his image of Leonardo into something fainter and more conventional.
  6. LEO §25A sacred subject is often merely Leonardo's pretext for work that carries one beyond the range of its conventional associations.
  7. WIN §34The colour of Greek sculpture has always been more or less conventional.
  8. CON §5What is only conventional has no real claim upon us.
  9. C73 §6In 1873, what is only conventional has no real claim upon us; the same sentence speaks of "some abstract morality" where the later text has "some abstract theory".

In this edition

The edition has no note on the phrase. The note at BOT §6, on "make great refusals", calls it "An echo of the anonymous figure associated with the 'great refusal' in Inferno III", and says that "Pater turns a category that Dante judges severely into a place from which a painter can observe human uncertainty sympathetically".