Art and its materials

Gothic manner

Gothic manner; old French Gothic; Gothic

The medieval style of France, strong and often rude, which took on Italian grace in its last phase

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordThe style of the later middle ages in the north, in building above all, and by extension in carving, painting and poetry.
  • In The Renaissance"In the middle of the sixteenth century, when the spirit of the Renaissance was everywhere, and people had begun to look back with distaste on the works of the middle age, the old Gothic manner had still one chance more, in borrowing something from the rival which was about to supplant it" (BEL §1).
  • In this editionThe note at BEL §1 says that the Loire châteaux "bring Italian-derived ornament and planning into a French tradition of towers, roofs and emphatic vertical lines".
  • A place to readBEL §§1–4.

Meaning

"Gothic" first meant belonging to the Goths, and Italian writers of the Renaissance used it as a reproach for the architecture of the centuries before their own, as barbarous; by Pater's time the word had lost the reproach and become the name of a style, the pointed architecture of the north and the art that went with it. A "manner" is a way of working, a style as the habit of a time or a hand. The Gothic manner is the medieval way of making things, and in Pater it carries both its strength and its roughness.

Use in the book

The Du Bellay essay opens with the Gothic manner at the end of its life. When people had begun to look back on medieval work "with distaste", the old manner "had still one chance more, in borrowing something from the rival which was about to supplant it" (BEL §1; see Borrowed interest). The result was "a new and peculiar phase of taste with qualities and a charm of its own, blending the somewhat attenuated grace of Italian ornament with the general outlines of northern design" (BEL §1). The outline is Gothic, the ornament Italian, and the blend is French. Pater's example is the Château de Gaillon, "a Gothic donjon veiled faintly by a surface of dainty Italian traceries" (BEL §1; see Donjon), and he draws the conclusion that the Renaissance in France is "the finest and subtlest phase of the middle age itself" (BEL §1; see Saint Martin's summer). The Gothic manner is not replaced by the Renaissance; the Renaissance is its last phase.

The second paragraph shows the manner at its best and its worst. French work had always had a daintiness of hand, characteristic "too of a hundred French Gothic carvings and traceries" (BEL §2; see Daintiness), and in the Gothic cathedrals and the chansons de geste the ponderous mass becomes graceful, "although below both alike there is a fund of mere Gothic strength, or heaviness" (BEL §2; see Chanson de geste). Gothic, in the essay, is the ground under the refinement, a strength that can be felt in the carving and a heaviness that the carving lightens.

The third paragraph says how deep the change went, and the answer is that it did not go deep. Ronsard accepted "that influx of Renaissance taste, which, leaving the buildings, the language, the art, the poetry of France, at bottom, what they were, old French Gothic still, gilds their surfaces with a strange, delightful, foreign aspect passing over all that northern land, in itself neither deeper nor more permanent than a chance effect of light" (BEL §3). The sentence can be read as the essay's most exact statement of its view. The Renaissance in France is a light on a Gothic surface: delightful, foreign and passing. In poetry the old French chanson, "like the old northern Gothic ornament", was "often, in its essence, something rude and formless" until Ronsard gave it structure (BEL §4; see Pindaric ode). Gothic is the rude form that the Pleiad refines.

Elsewhere in the book the word has a gentler sense. Botticelli's Birth of Venus has draperies "powdered all over in the Gothic manner with a quaint conceit of daisies" (BOT §8; see Quaint conceit), and there the Gothic manner is a decorative habit, the medieval love of small pattern lingering in a pagan picture. In the first essay it is at the foot of "that early Gothic tower, which the next generation raised to grace the precincts of Abelard's school", that Michelet sees in thought "a terrible assembly" of all that came of Abelard's teaching (FRE §4; see Scholastic philosophy). The Gothic is present at both ends of the book's Renaissance, in Abelard's Paris and in the France of the Pleiad, and the book's view of the Renaissance as an effort of the middle age itself can be read in the word's survival.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "Gothic" occurs, in the order of the book.

  1. FRE §4At the foot of the early Gothic tower by Abelard's school Michelet sees a terrible assembly.
  2. BOT §8The Venus's draperies are powdered all over in the Gothic manner with a quaint conceit of daisies.
  3. BEL §1The old Gothic manner had one chance more, in borrowing something from the rival about to supplant it.
  4. BEL §2Below the Gothic cathedrals and chansons de geste is a fund of mere Gothic strength, or heaviness.
  5. BEL §3Renaissance taste left the buildings and poetry of France old French Gothic still, gilding their surfaces.
  6. BEL §4The old French chanson, like the old northern Gothic ornament, was often rude and formless.

In this edition

The notes at BEL §1 describe Gaillon, the château of Cardinal Georges d'Amboise, as "an early site of Italianate ornament in France", and say that the Loire châteaux "bring Italian-derived ornament and planning into a French tradition of towers, roofs and emphatic vertical lines".

Pater's sources

Pater's own note at BEL §2, which was first printed in the third edition of 1888, reads: "The purely artistic aspects of this subject have been interpreted, in a work of great taste and learning, by Mrs. Mark Pattison.—The Renaissance of Art in France." Emilia Pattison, the art historian later known as Lady Dilke, published The Renaissance of Art in France in two volumes in 1879.1

Source note

1. Mrs. Mark Pattison [Emilia Francis Strong, later Lady Dilke], The Renaissance of Art in France, 2 vols. (London, 1879).