From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
- The wordOrthodoxy is right belief, the doctrine a church holds true; a frozen orthodoxy is a belief that has hardened and can no longer move or be discussed.
- In The Renaissance"But in thus fixing itself in a frozen orthodoxy, the Roman Church had passed beyond him, and he was a stranger to it" (MIC §16).
- In this editionThe note at MIC §16 says that "The Congregation of the Oratory received formal papal approval in 1575, after the artist's death".
- A place to readMIC §16.
Meaning
Orthodoxy, from the Greek orthos, straight, and doxa, opinion, is the Church's settled teaching (see Orthodoxy). Pater's adjective sets it in a physical image: a liquid that freezes keeps its shape and can no longer flow.
Use in the book
The phrase's chief passage is in the sixteenth paragraph of the Michelangelo essay, which describes the world of his old age: "The 'new catholicism' had taken the place of the Renaissance" (MIC §16; see New catholicism). The essay sets the Catholic revival above the Reformation as an enemy of art (MIC §16; see New catholicism), and goes on: "But in thus fixing itself in a frozen orthodoxy, the Roman Church had passed beyond him, and he was a stranger to it. In earlier days, when its beliefs had been in a fluid state, he too might have been drawn into the controversy" (MIC §16).
The image works by its opposite. "Frozen" stands against "fluid": in Michelangelo's youth the Church's beliefs moved, and a thoughtful man might hope to change them, as Savonarola sought to spiritualise "the papal sovereignty" and Pico to adjust "the dreams of Plato and Homer with the words of Christ" (MIC §16; see Spiritualise; Artistic reconciliation). Those adjustments, the essay says, were no longer possible. The reconciliations of Pico and the reforms of Savonarola belonged to the fluid state; the frozen orthodoxy admits neither.
The sentence is careful about who has moved. "The Roman Church had passed beyond him": it is the Church that has gone on, and Michelangelo who is left behind, "a stranger to it". The essay does not make him a rebel. He had long since fallen back on a divine ideal above the creeds (MIC §16; see Divine ideal), and the frozen Church could even console him, as a stately foreign city consoles a traveller "just because with those fortunes he has nothing to do" (MIC §16). He lingers on "a revenant, as the French say, a ghost out of another age" (MIC §16; see Revenant).
"Frozen" has two other places in the book, and both carry the same opposition of the fixed to the living. The Greek sculptor purged from the individual all that "is apt to look like a frozen thing if one arrests it" (ROB §7; see Allgemeinheit), the passing gesture that sculpture would congeal. At the Renaissance, "in the midst of a frozen world, the buried fire of ancient art rose up from under the soil" (WIN §9; see Buried fire). The frozen world of the Winckelmann sentence is the medieval one, thawed by the classical revival; the frozen orthodoxy of the Michelangelo essay is the Church after the revival, set again.
Pater does not name the Council of Trent, which sat in three periods between 1545 and 1563, defined the doctrines the Reformation had questioned and closed the debates that had been open in Michelangelo's youth; Michelangelo died in February 1564, ten weeks after it ended.1 The frozen orthodoxy can be read as its work.
The phrase can be read as marking the end of Pater's Renaissance. The first essay defines a movement in which "the things of the intellect and the imagination" were loved "for their own sake" (FRE §1; see Renaissance), and its Italian essays are full of the free play of beliefs in a fluid state: Pico's Platonism, the heresy suspected in the picture for Palmieri that Pater gives to Botticelli (BOT §5), Leonardo's science (LEO §13). The frozen orthodoxy is the condition in which that play stops, and Michelangelo, outliving it, shows what remains: a private faith, a divine ideal above creeds, and the art in which it had been expressed.
Places to read
Every paragraph in which "frozen" occurs, in the order of the book.
- ROB §7The Greek sculptor purged from the individual all that is apt to look like a frozen thing if one arrests it.
- MIC §16In fixing itself in a frozen orthodoxy the Roman Church had passed beyond Michelangelo, and he was a stranger to it.
- WIN §9At the Renaissance, in the midst of a frozen world, the buried fire of ancient art rose up from under the soil.
In this edition
The note at MIC §16 says that "The circle of Filippo Neri met in Rome in Michelangelo's later years. The Congregation of the Oratory received formal papal approval in 1575, after the artist's death. Pater is writing about its early associates."
Source note
1. The Council of Trent held its last session on 4 December 1563; Michelangelo died in Rome on 18 February 1564.