History, culture and the Renaissance

New catholicism

new catholicism; Catholic revival

The Catholic revival of the sixteenth century, which took the place of the Renaissance and opposed art more than the Reformation did

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordThe renewed Catholicism of the later sixteenth century: the reform and revival of the Church in answer to the Protestant Reformation.
  • In The Renaissance"The 'new catholicism' had taken the place of the Renaissance" (MIC §16).
  • In this editionThe note at MIC §16 says that "The circle of Filippo Neri met in Rome in Michelangelo's later years. The Congregation of the Oratory received formal papal approval in 1575, after the artist's death."
  • A place to readMIC §16.

Meaning

Historians call the movement the Catholic Reformation or the Counter-Reformation: the reform of the Church's discipline, the founding of new orders, the Jesuits in 1540, Filippo Neri's Oratory in Rome, and the definition of doctrine at the Council of Trent (1545–1563). Its spirit was devout, ascetic and, in matters of art, watchful: the council's decree on images, in its last session, required that sacred pictures avoid anything profane or indecent.1

Use in the book

The phrase's chief passage is the middle of the sixteenth paragraph of the Michelangelo essay, which describes the world of his old age: "The world had changed around him. The 'new catholicism' had taken the place of the Renaissance. The spirit of the Roman Church had changed: in the vast world's cathedral which his skill had helped to raise for it, it looked stronger than ever. Some of the first members of the Oratory were among his intimate associates. They were of a spirit as unlike as possible from that of Lorenzo, or Savonarola even. The opposition of the Reformation to art has been often enlarged upon; far greater was that of the Catholic revival" (MIC §16).

Pater's quotation marks mark "new catholicism" as a current phrase, not his own. The passage is built on contrasts. The new Catholicism "had taken the place of the Renaissance": the two are rivals, and the second has won. The cathedral is the sharpest irony: St Peter's, whose dome Michelangelo designed, made the Church look "stronger than ever", and the strength was turned against the spirit of the art that built it. Some of the first Oratorians, Neri's companions, were "among his intimate associates", and yet of a spirit unlike Lorenzo's humanism and even Savonarola's reforming fire. The last sentence makes the claim that gives the passage its force: Protestant iconoclasm is the familiar enemy of art, but the opposition of the Catholic revival was "far greater".

The claim can be read in the light of the Council's decree on images and of the censures that followed: in January 1564, a month before Michelangelo's death, some of the nudes of the Last Judgment were ordered covered, and the draperies were painted afterwards by his friend Daniele da Volterra.2 Pater does not tell the story, but his sentence holds it: the art of the unveiled human form had no place in the new piety.

The next sentences give the consequence. fixed "in a frozen orthodoxy", the Roman Church "had passed beyond him" (MIC §16; see Frozen orthodoxy); he had fallen back on a divine ideal above the creeds (see Divine ideal), and lingered on as "a revenant" (see Revenant). Vittoria Colonna, "an ardent neo-catholic" (MIC §10; see Neo-catholic), had belonged to the hopeful beginning of the movement; Michelangelo outlived its hope.

The two revivals frame Pater's Renaissance: the "revival" of the twelfth century with which the book opens (FRE §1; see Revival of classical antiquity), and the Catholic revival, at the latest point of its Italian story, that undid much of what the first had made.

Places to read

Both phrases occur in one paragraph.

  1. MIC §16The new catholicism had taken the place of the Renaissance; the opposition of the Catholic revival to art was greater than that of the Reformation.

In this edition

The note at MIC §16 says: "The circle of Filippo Neri met in Rome in Michelangelo's later years. The Congregation of the Oratory received formal papal approval in 1575, after the artist's death. Pater is writing about its early associates."

Source note

1. Council of Trent, session XXV (3–4 December 1563), On the Invocation, Veneration and Relics of Saints, and on Sacred Images.

2. Vatican Museums, The Last Judgement; the decision is dated 21 January 1564.