Criticism and method

Finite image

the finite image

The visible form of a Greek statue, in which the spiritual meaning is wholly present and nothing points beyond

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordAn image with limits, complete in itself, as against a sign that points to something beyond it.
  • In The RenaissanceBefore the Venus of Melos, "in no sense a symbol", the mind rests in the finite image and loses nothing of what it means (WIN §28).
  • In this editionThe note at WIN §28 says that with the Venus of Melos Pater "supplies his own example of an ideal in which meaning seems to reside entirely in the visible figure".
  • A place to readWIN §§27–29.

Meaning

Finite, from the Latin finitus, bounded, is what has limits: the opposite of the infinite of theology and of Romantic longing. An image is finite when it is wholly there, contained in its outline, and asks for no completion from outside. Pater uses the phrase in an argument that comes, in its broad lines, from Hegel's lectures on aesthetics.

Use in the book

The phrase is the hinge of a contrast between two kinds of art. On one side is the Coronation of the Virgin by the Florentine friar and painter Fra Angelico (about 1395–1455), a fresco in a friar's cell of the convent of San Marco, in which all that is outward is only "the symbol or type of a really inexpressible world" (WIN §27; see Symbol), and the many-headed gods of the East, "at best overcharged symbols" (WIN §27; see Mystic). "Such forms of art, then, are inadequate to the matter they clothe; they remain ever below its level" (WIN §27). On the other side is the Venus of Melos, "in no sense a symbol" (WIN §28; see Symbol), before which the mind "begins and ends with the finite image, yet loses no part of the spiritual motive" (WIN §28), since that motive saturates the form instead of hanging on it like an allegory's meaning (WIN §28; see Allegorical interpretation).

The finite image is thus not a lesser thing than the symbol but a fuller one. The symbol fails because it must point beyond itself; the statue succeeds because it need not. The phrase can be read as Pater's answer to the religious art the book has admired, Angelico's and Botticelli's: they reach toward a world they cannot show, while the Greek sculptor shows all that he means. The next paragraph names the art that results, an ideal art in which the thought does not "outstrip" its sensible embodiment (WIN §29; see Ideal art).

The rest of the twenty-eighth paragraph says why the finite image was possible, and why it could not last. "The Greek mind had advanced to a particular stage of self-reflexion, but was careful not to pass beyond it" (WIN §28). In the East humanity is still confused with the life of the animal and vegetable world; in Greece the "lordship of the soul" is recognised and gives divinity to the human body (WIN §28; see Lordship of the soul). "But just there Greek thought finds its happy limit; it has not yet become too inward; the mind has not yet learned to boast its independence of the flesh" (WIN §28). The finite image depends on that pause, on a mind that has mastered the body without despising it. The paragraph ends with the warning that the train of reflexion "must end in defiance of form, of all that is outward, in an exaggerated idealism", though "that end is still distant" (WIN §28; see Idealise). The essay's history of the arts, sculpture for the Greeks, painting for the middle age, music and poetry for the modern world (WIN §52; see Correspondence), follows from it: the finite image belongs to one moment of the mind, and the moment passed.

The example is Pater's own, and it is late. The Venus of Melos was found in 1820, more than fifty years after Winckelmann's death, and the most famous Greek figure of Pater's day stands at the centre of an essay on a critic who never saw it. The anachronism can be read as Pater's way of continuing Winckelmann's work rather than reporting it.

Places to read

The paragraphs of the Winckelmann essay that set the finite image of Greek art against the symbol, in the order of the book.

  1. WIN §27Angelico's Coronation, like the gods of the East, is a symbol of a world it cannot express.
  2. WIN §28The Venus of Melos is no symbol: the mind begins and ends with the finite image.
  3. WIN §29This ideal art, in which the thought does not outstrip its sensible embodiment, needed a perfect animal nature.

Pater's sources

The essay quotes Hegel three times, on Winckelmann, on the Greek plastic character and on the religious spirit that "smiled through its tears" (WIN §§2, 41, 46), and borrows his comparison of Egyptian art to Memnon (WIN §32); and the contrast of the finite image with the symbol follows Hegel's lectures on aesthetics. There classical art is the art in which the idea has found the shape adequate to it, the human form, and symbolic art, the art of the East, is the art in which the idea is still indeterminate and the shape only alludes to it.1 Pater's "overcharged symbols" of the East (WIN §27) and his finite image of Greece can be read as Hegel's symbolic and classical forms in English, and his "exaggerated inwardness" of the middle age (WIN §27) as Hegel's romantic form seen from the side of its loss.

Source note

1. G. W. F. Hegel, Vorlesungen über die Ästhetik, ed. H. G. Hotho (Berlin, 1835–38), part II, sections 1–2, on the symbolic and the classical art forms.