Criticism and method

Art-casuistry

art-casuistry, art-casuistries; casuistical

The case-by-case study of what each art can and cannot do, which Pater asks criticism to build into a system

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordCasuistry applied to the arts: the reasoning from particular cases about the powers and limits of each art.
  • In The Renaissance"To such a philosophy of the variations of the beautiful, Lessing's analysis of the spheres of sculpture and poetry, in the Laocoon, was an important contribution. But a true appreciation of these things is possible only in the light of a whole system of such art-casuistries" (GIO §2).
  • In this editionThe note at GIO §2 says that Lessing's Laocoön (1766) "distinguishes arts that arrange bodies in space from poetry, which unfolds signs in time", and that "Pater extends the problem to what different arts can learn from each other".
  • A place to readGIO §§1–2.

Meaning

Casuistry, from the Latin casus, a case, is the reasoning of moral theology about particular cases of conscience: whether this act, in these circumstances, is a sin. The Jesuit casuists of the seventeenth century made it an elaborate science, and the French mathematician and religious writer Blaise Pascal's Provincial Letters (1656–57) made the word a byword for subtlety in excuse.1 Pater takes the word back to its first sense and moves it to the arts. An art-casuistry is a reasoned judgement on a case: what this art, with this material, can rightly attempt. Pater's compound keeps a trace of the confessional, as if each art had its own conscience and its own duties.

Use in the book

The word comes in the second paragraph of the Giorgione essay, after the first has laid down its principle. Popular criticism errs in treating poetry, music and painting as "translations into different languages of one and the same fixed quantity of imaginative thought" (GIO §1). Against it stands "the opposite principle—that the sensuous material of each art brings with it a special phase or quality of beauty, untranslatable into the forms of any other" (GIO §1; see Sensuous material). Each art therefore "has its own special mode of reaching the imagination, its own special responsibilities to its material" (GIO §1; see Special limitation). The duties of each art are its responsibilities, and one of the functions of æsthetic criticism is "to estimate the degree in which a given work of art fulfils its responsibilities to its special material" (GIO §1). Casuistry is the natural word for such judgements.

The German critic and dramatist Gotthold Ephraim Lessing is the precedent. His Laokoon argued that painting and sculpture, which arrange bodies side by side in space, and poetry, which sets actions one after another in time, have different objects, and that a poet who describes like a painter or a painter who tells a story like a poet mistakes his art.2 Pater calls it "an important contribution" to "a philosophy of the variations of the beautiful", and asks for more: "a true appreciation of these things is possible only in the light of a whole system of such art-casuistries" (GIO §2). Lessing worked out one case, sculpture and poetry; Pater wants all of them. The essay's examples follow at once: painting is "the art in the criticism of which this truth most needs enforcing", because popular judgement makes every picture a poem (GIO §2; see Literary interest).

The adjective returns near the end of the essay, of a case the Renaissance had argued. Giorgione's master stroke with mirrors, armour and still water, "by which all the sides of a solid image are exhibited at once", settles "that casuistical question whether painting can present an object as completely as sculpture" (GIO §20; see Casuistical question). The question is the old Renaissance debate about the rank of the arts, which the Leonardo essay also recalls (LEO §21; see Casuistical question). Pater's word turns a quarrel about precedence into a question of means. The casuist does not ask which art is nobler but what each can do; and the essay's own answer, that all the arts strive toward the condition of music (GIO §5; see Condition of music), may be taken as the conclusion the system of art-casuistries was built to reach.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "art-casuistries" or "casuistical" occurs, with the paragraph that lays down the principle, in the order of the book.

  1. GIO §1The sensuous material of each art brings with it a special phase of beauty, untranslatable into any other.
  2. GIO §2Lessing's Laocoon was an important contribution, but a true appreciation is possible only in a whole system of art-casuistries.
  3. GIO §20Giorgione's mirrors and armour settle the casuistical question whether painting can present an object as completely as sculpture.

Source note

1. Blaise Pascal, Les Provinciales (1656–57), letters 5–10.

2. Gotthold Ephraim Lessing, Laokoon, oder über die Grenzen der Mahlerey und Poesie (Berlin, 1766), chapters 16–18.