From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Meaning
Attested: casuistical question (GIO §20). Among the instantaneous motions that the master reproduces is "some momentary conjunction of mirrors and polished armour and still water, by which all the sides of a solid image are exhibited at once, solving that casuistical question whether painting can present an object as completely as sculpture" (GIO §20; see Instantaneous motion). The question was the Renaissance paragone, the comparison of the arts, and the note at GIO §20 says that "The combination of reflected views allows one painted surface to show multiple aspects of a body, a feat often claimed for sculpture". Vasari tells the story behind Pater's sentence. When sculptors argued that their art showed a figure from every side while painting showed only one, Giorgione painted a man with his back turned, his front reflected in clear water at his feet, one side in a burnished cuirass and the other in a mirror, so that a single picture showed him all round.1 "Casuistical" carries Pater's earlier compound: the question is one of the "art-casuistries" that a true criticism must work through (GIO §2; see Art-casuistry). The Leonardo essay had recalled the same dispute, "that debate on the question whether sculpture or painting is the nobler art" (LEO §21). Giorgione answers it with painting's own means, reflection and light.
Source note
1. Giorgio Vasari, Le vite (1568), Life of Giorgione.