Criticism and method

Abstract theory

abstract theory

A theory is literally a viewing, from the Greek theōria, and an abstract one is drawn away, abstractus, from the things it views: a general account held apart from the cases it is meant to explain.

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Meaning

Attested: abstract theory (WIN §9; CON §5). A theory is literally a viewing, from the Greek theōria, and an abstract one is drawn away, abstractus, from the things it views: a general account held apart from the cases it is meant to explain. The phrase comes twice, at the two places in the book where a mind is shown turning from theory to what it can see. In the Winckelmann essay the scholar who has handled the words of Greek poetry meets its life in the antiquities, and Pater finds there his native tendency to escape from abstract theory to intuition (WIN §9; see Realisation; Sight and touch). In the Conclusion the turn becomes a rule. Any theory, idea or system that asks of us the sacrifice of part of our experience, in consideration of "some abstract theory we have not identified with ourselves", has no real claim upon us (CON §5; see Conventional orthodoxy). The qualification is the point. Pater does not reject theory, which in the same paragraph is allowed its use as one of the "instruments of criticism" (CON §5; see Instruments of criticism); he rejects the theory that has not become part of the person who holds it. The 1873 text had "some abstract morality" (C73 §6; see Abstract morality), a phrase the revision replaced with "some abstract theory", and the change can be read as moving the sentence from ethics to method.