Criticism and method

Abstract

abstract, abstracting, abstracted

To draw off the general from the particular: the critic's reproach and the sculptor's method

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordWhat is drawn away from particular things and considered apart from them; as a verb, to draw off and keep only part of a thing.
  • In The RenaissanceThe Greek sculptors sought "to abstract and express only what is structural and permanent" (ROB §7).
  • In this editionThe note at ROB §7 says that Pater's "point concerns the removal of transient particulars so that a figure can present a broadly recognizable type".
  • A place to readROB §7, with WIN §37 and PRE §1.

Meaning

The Latin abstrahere is to drag away, and its participle abstractus, "drawn off", gave the schoolmen their term for the mind's act of considering a form apart from the matter it is found in, the universal apart from the individual. English kept both halves of that history. The adjective means general, theoretical, removed from experience; the verb means to draw off, to separate, to keep one part and leave the rest. Pater uses both, and the book turns on the difference between them.

Use in the book

The adjective opens the book as a reproach. Writers on art have tried "to define beauty in the abstract", and the true student of æsthetics defines it "not in the most abstract but in the most concrete terms possible" (PRE §1; see Concrete terms); the critic has "no need to trouble himself with the abstract question what beauty is in itself" (PRE §2), and what matters is not "a correct abstract definition of beauty for the intellect" but a temperament (PRE §4; see Abstractness; Temperament). The book closes the same way. A theory that asks the sacrifice of experience to "some abstract theory we have not identified with ourselves" has "no real claim upon us" (CON §5); in 1873 the phrase was "some abstract morality" (C73 §6; see Abstract morality).

Between these ends, in the essays on sculpture, the verb changes sides. The law of the Greek sculptors "prompted them constantly to seek the type in the individual, to abstract and express only what is structural and permanent" (ROB §7; see Allgemeinheit), and the Winckelmann essay repeats the law: sculpture presents its types "not by accumulation of detail, but by abstracting from it" (WIN §37). Sculpture itself is "the abstract art" (ROB §13), the art in which the personal quality of intimité is "rarest of all" (see Imaginative order).

Abstraction of this kind is still something seen. Botticelli's Madonnas have faces whose "abstract lines" have little nobleness (BOT §7; see Abject); after death, "it is said", "only the abstract lines remain, in a great indifference" (MIC §19; see Abstract line); Leonardo's beauty is seen above all in his drawings, and in these chiefly "in the abstract grace of the bounding lines" (LEO §22). The masters of the Venetian school keep of their Alpine background "certain abstracted elements only, of cool colour and tranquillising line" (GIO §6), and Japanese fan-painting gives "first, only abstract colour" (GIO §2). In each case the abstract is a line or a colour held apart from the rest of the thing, and it remains a matter for the eye.

The danger comes when abstraction leaves the senses altogether. Pico della Mirandola, the Florentine Platonist, after the change that came over him, seems to feel "the chilling touch of the abstract and disembodied beauty Platonists profess to long for" (PIC §11; see Disembodied beauty), and Johann Joachim Winckelmann, the eighteenth-century German historian of ancient art, "living in a world of exquisite but abstract and colourless form", could hardly have conceived of the art of the modern world (WIN §45). The same paragraph sees in the Greek gods themselves a premonition of the medieval spectres: "Those abstracted gods" seem, in a phrase Pater quotes, "ready to melt out their essence fine into the winds" (WIN §45; see Essence).

The word can be read as the book's measure of the general. The critic must not abstract, because his material is the particular impression; the sculptor must, because stone cannot hold the passing moment (see Allgemeinheit). The two demands meet in one rule: an abstraction is good while it is a selection made within the visible, and bad when it leaves the visible behind for a definition.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which the adjective "abstract" or the verb "to abstract" occurs, in the order of the book; abstraction and abstractness have their own entries.

  1. PRE §1Writers have tried to define beauty in the abstract; the true student defines it in the most concrete terms possible.
  2. PRE §2The critic need not trouble himself with the abstract question what beauty is in itself.
  3. PRE §4What matters is not a correct abstract definition of beauty but a certain kind of temperament.
  4. FRE §3Abelard and Heloïse meet to refine on the nature of abstract ideas; Abelard knew the exact value of every abstract thought.
  5. PIC §11The chilling touch of abstract and disembodied beauty seems already upon Pico.
  6. BOT §3Line and colour are the medium of abstract painting.
  7. BOT §7The abstract lines of the Madonna's face have little nobleness.
  8. ROB §7The Greek sculptors abstract and express only what is structural and permanent.
  9. ROB §13The personal quality of intimité is rarest of all in the abstract art of sculpture.
  10. MIC §14Michelangelo presses on to the abstract form of beauty about which the Platonists reason.
  11. MIC §18The medieval treatment of the Creation of Man came to have an almost independent and abstract existence of its own.
  12. MIC §19After death, it is said, only the abstract lines of a face remain.
  13. LEO §22Leonardo's curious beauty is seen above all in the abstract grace of the bounding lines of his drawings.
  14. GIO §2In the pictorial temperament all ideas however abstract float up as visible scene; Japanese fan-painting gives first only abstract colour.
  15. GIO §6The essay's abstract language becomes clear by examples; the Venetian masters keep certain abstracted elements only of their Alpine background.
  16. WIN §2Goethe speaks of Winckelmann as of an abstract type of culture.
  17. WIN §9Winckelmann's native tendency was to escape from abstract theory to intuition.
  18. WIN §33At first sight sculpture seems more real than the faint, abstract world of poetry or painting.
  19. WIN §37Sculpture presents its types not by accumulation of detail but by abstracting from it.
  20. WIN §45Winckelmann lived in a world of abstract and colourless form; the abstracted gods seem ready to melt out their essence.
  21. CON §5A theory that asks the sacrifice of experience to some abstract theory has no real claim upon us.
  22. C73 §6In 1873, some abstract morality has no real claim upon us.

In this edition

The note at ROB §7 glosses Allgemeinheit as "Universality", and says that Pater's "point concerns the removal of transient particulars so that a figure can present a broadly recognizable type".