Philosophy
Too Shy to Ask for Bread
In the Odyssey, a man needs bread. In Plato’s Laches, grown men need a teacher. Homer’s advice helps in both cases.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesThe modesty that makes Charmides seem well brought up can also keep him from asking for help. By the end of the dialogue, he’s willing to say what he needs.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The hungry manSocrates quotes Homer to show how modesty can hurt someone who needs to ask for food. That gives him a counterexample to Charmides’ claim that modesty and temperance are the same.
- Grown men go back to schoolSocrates quotes the same line in the Laches when he and the other men need a teacher. They may have to risk looking foolish in order to learn.
- The philosopher’s hungerIn the Symposium, Diotima tells how Poverty went begging and became the mother of Love. Love keeps seeking wisdom because he knows what it is to lack it.
- Charmides asks for helpAt the end of the dialogue, Charmides says he needs the charm and wants Socrates to keep giving it to him. His willingness to ask gives Homer’s advice a second life.
Charmides 158c, 158c–d, 160d–e, 160e–161b, 164c–d, 175e–176a, 176a–c · Odyssey 17.345–352 · Laches 201a, 201b · Symposium 203b–d, 204a–b
The refutation of Charmides’ second definition turns on one hungry man. Socrates gets the boy to agree that temperance is good. Then he asks if the boy believes Homer is right to say, “Modesty is no good thing to be present with a man in need.” Charmides says, “I do,” and the definition is in trouble. If modesty is sometimes bad for the person who feels it, how can it be the same thing as a virtue that makes its possessor good? The inhibition that looks so charming on a well-raised boy turns into a problem the moment the person feeling it needs something from somebody else.
It’s worth asking why the same feeling flips from charming to harmful. Modesty can hold you back from putting yourself forward, from asking, claiming, insisting and taking up space. For a teenager surrounded by admirers, holding back can look lovely. But a hungry stranger standing silently at the edge of the room may go home without bread. We know modern versions of him. Think of the student too embarrassed to ask a question who stays lost all semester.
So what has gone wrong when a feeling people praise ends up doing harm? One possibility is a glitch in the wiring. But the beggar’s modesty is doing a familiar job, warning him that he’s about to look small in front of other people. Maybe the feeling just shows up in the wrong place, the way an umbrella is great in a storm and silly indoors. That’s closer, though it makes need sound like a rare and unlucky situation. Plato gives us reason to think it’s more familiar than that.
The clue is that Plato quotes the same line in another dialogue, and there the needy man wants something besides bread. At the end of the Laches, two fathers and two generals have been unable to settle what courage is. Socrates proposes finding a teacher for themselves as well as for the boys. If anybody laughs at grown men going back to school, they can answer with Homer. The bread they need is understanding, and the modesty that might hold them back is the embarrassment of looking like you don’t know something at an age when you’re supposed to.
On that reading, need is a familiar condition, especially where the most important things are concerned. In the Symposium, Socrates tells Diotima’s story of Eros as the child of Poverty, who came begging after the gods had dined, and Resource, who passed on his knack for getting things. Eros lives between wisdom and ignorance and keeps going after wisdom. The philosopher resembles that beggar. The person who would rather look wise than become wise can stay hungry for life without even noticing it.
Charmides is the needy man of this dialogue, and by the end he does something like what Telemachus advises in Homer. Earlier he blushes and can’t bring himself to say whether he has temperance. Claiming it would sound like boasting, and denying it would make Critias look like a liar. But once the inquiry has failed to settle what temperance is, he says, “I think I very much need the charm,” and adds that “nothing stops me from being charmed by you every day, until you say it’s enough.” Critias soon gives him an order to do it. Charmides has already asked. That’s the beggar walking up to the table.
Modesty, then, needs a guide. A blush can tell you that you might look foolish. It can’t tell you what you’re going to miss if you keep quiet. You have to recognize that you’re in need, and recognizing your own need is a form of self-knowledge. Critias will put a related idea on the table when he proposes that temperance is knowing yourself. You can’t set your modesty aside for the right reason until you’ve admitted to yourself that you’re hungry. That admission can be the hardest part, as anyone who has watched a friend refuse help can tell you.
My verdict is that Homer’s hungry man shows modesty to be a feeling that needs a pilot, and that the pilot is the honest recognition of what you lack. The Laches shows how embarrassment can keep a person from admitting a hunger for understanding. When Charmides asks to be charmed every day, he shows how a modest person can learn to ask. It’s one of the finest things he does in the dialogue.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does Homer’s claim about modesty and a needy person undermine Charmides’ second definition of temperance?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If modesty warns us that we may look foolish but not what silence may cost us, what kind of reflection should guide whether we speak or hold back?→
- Why might admitting a need for understanding be harder for someone who is expected to appear knowledgeable?→
- Does Charmides’ request for continued help demonstrate temperance, self-knowledge, or something else? What in the article supports your interpretation?→