Art and its materials

Visible circumstance

visible circumstance; circumstance, circumstances

The things of the world in which the scene clothes the painter's mood

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordVisible circumstance is the seen detail of a scene, its setting, objects and gestures, in which a feeling can be embodied.
  • In The RenaissanceThe mood the scene awakes in the visionary is one "which it clothes, that all may share it, with visible circumstance" (BOT §4).
  • In this editionThe note at BOT §4 says that "'Exponent' here means the visible expression of something inward".
  • A place to readBOT §4, with BOT §3.

Meaning

The Latin circumstantia is what stands around. Rhetoric used the word for the attendant facts of an act, who did it, where, when, how and why, and law and history kept that sense: the circumstances of a deed are its setting. "Visible" turns the word to painting. Visible circumstances are the things a picture can show around its figures, the lawns, pools and reeds, the light, the shell and the falling roses.

Use in the book

The phrase ends the sentence that sets out Pater's theory of the visionary. The scene comes to the painter with all its reality and awakes in him a mood "which it clothes, that all may share it, with visible circumstance" (BOT §4; see Mood).

The figure is of clothing. The mood is a body of feeling, private and invisible, and visible circumstance is the dress that lets it go out among others. "That all may share it" gives the clothing a purpose: art is the means by which one person's mood becomes common. The circumstances need not be those the scene first offered. The visionary rejects some data, isolates others and combines them anew (BOT §4; see Data), so that the clothing is made to the mood's measure out of the world's cloth.

The paragraph before shows the same freedom in practice. In the illustration of the Centaurs, "forgetful of the actual circumstances of their appearance, Botticelli has gone off with delight on the thought of the Centaurs themselves" (BOT §3; see Painter's vision). Dante gave the circumstances, a river of blood and grim archers; Botticelli forgot them and gave the Centaurs others, the woodland, baby faces and tiny bows. The actual circumstances belong to the text, the visible circumstances to the painter.

The word "circumstance" occurs in sixteen paragraphs of the book, most often for the conditions of a life or an age. Pater can say of Pico that "his own story is a sort of analogue or visible equivalent" of his writings (PIC §5), and the phrase is close kin to "visible circumstance": in both, an inward thing has a visible counterpart. The Botticelli phrase can be read as the general form of that idea for art. A mood without circumstance cannot be shared; circumstance without a mood is the dramatic painter's transcription (see Dramatic painter). The picture lives where the two are joined, and Pater's word for the joint is "clothes".

Places to read

Both paragraphs of the Botticelli essay in which "circumstance" or "circumstances" occurs, in the order of the book; the word occurs in sixteen paragraphs in all.

  1. BOT §3Forgetful of the actual circumstances of their appearance, Botticelli goes off with delight on the Centaurs themselves.
  2. BOT §4The scene clothes the mood it awakes in the visionary, that all may share it, with visible circumstance.

In this edition

The note at BOT §4 says that "'Exponent' here means the visible expression of something inward. Pater's contrast between transcription and vision prepares his reading of the same melancholy expression in markedly different subjects."