From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
- The wordThe differences between the arts that remain when every comparison has been made: differences of kind, not of degree.
- In The Renaissance"A just apprehension of the ultimate differences of the arts is the beginning of æsthetic criticism" (GIO §3).
- In this editionThe note at GIO §2 says that Lessing's Laocoön "distinguishes arts that arrange bodies in space from poetry, which unfolds signs in time", and that "Pater extends the problem to what different arts can learn from each other".
- A place to readGIO §§1, 3.
Meaning
"Ultimate", from the Latin ultimus, last, describes what comes at the end of an analysis and cannot be analysed further. The ultimate differences of the arts are the ones that are left when everything the arts share has been set aside: not that one art is better or more developed than another, but that each is of a different kind, as sight differs from hearing.
Use in the book
The phrase stands in the third paragraph of the Giorgione essay, in the concessive clause that restates the first two before the essay turns. "But although each art has thus its own specific order of impressions, and an untranslatable charm, while a just apprehension of the ultimate differences of the arts is the beginning of æsthetic criticism; yet …" (GIO §3; see Anders-streben). The first paragraph had given the ground of the differences. Because art addresses "the 'imaginative reason' through the senses, there are differences of kind in æsthetic beauty, corresponding to the differences in kind of the gifts of sense themselves" (GIO §1; see Imaginative reason). The arts differ ultimately because the senses do. Painting is for the eye and music for the ear, and no development of either will make it the other.
"Just apprehension" is a careful phrase, and the essay returns to it. The Venetian painters had "that old Venetian clearness or justice, in the apprehension of the essential limitations of the pictorial art" (GIO §12; see Pictorial design). The justice that criticism must learn, the Venetian school had "instinctively" (GIO §11; see Venetian school). The ultimate differences are the critic's beginning, and the painter's practice: to know them is to know what one's art can and cannot do.
The Winckelmann essay had grounded the differences of the arts elsewhere, and the two grounds can be set side by side. There, in a series that follows Hegel's,1 the arts are "ranged in a series" answering to the "developments in the human mind itself" (WIN §32; see Development). "Different attitudes of the imagination have a native affinity with different types of sensuous form, so that they combine together, with completeness and ease" (WIN §32). The differences are historical: each art suits a stage of the mind, architecture the earliest, sculpture the Greek, while painting, music and poetry are "the special arts of the romantic and modern ages" (WIN §33; see Romantic arts). In the Giorgione essay the differences are sensory and permanent; no history ranks them. The change can be read as the measure of what the later essay owes to the earlier and of where it parts from it. The Winckelmann essay ranks the arts by what they express; the Giorgione essay distinguishes them by what they are made of, and ranks them only by how nearly each approaches the condition of music (see Musical law).
Places to read
The paragraph in which "ultimate differences of the arts" occurs, with GIO §1 and WIN §§32–33, in the order of the book.
- GIO §1There are differences of kind in æsthetic beauty, corresponding to the differences in kind of the gifts of sense.
- GIO §3A just apprehension of the ultimate differences of the arts is the beginning of æsthetic criticism.
- WIN §32The arts may be ranged in a series corresponding to a series of developments in the human mind.
- WIN §33Painting, music and poetry are the special arts of the romantic and modern ages.
Source note
1. G. W. F. Hegel, Vorlesungen über die Ästhetik, part III: architecture, sculpture, and the romantic arts (die romantischen Künste), painting, music and poetry.