From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
- The wordThe law that music obeys and the other arts strive after, taken as a measure of all art.
- In The Renaissance"Therefore, although each art has its incommunicable element, its untranslatable order of impressions, its unique mode of reaching the 'imaginative reason,' yet the arts may be represented as continually struggling after the law or principle of music, to a condition which music alone completely realises; and one of the chief functions of æsthetic criticism, dealing with the products of art, new or old, is to estimate the degree in which each of those products approaches, in this sense, to musical law" (GIO §10).
- In this editionThe Key Words entry on music says that in this essay "music is the art in which form and subject are most fully at one".
- A place to readGIO §10.
Meaning
A law, in the language of the arts, is a principle that governs a practice, as the laws of perspective govern a drawing or the laws of harmony a composition. Pater's musical law is not a rule of composition but a condition: the law that music obeys by its nature, the complete union of form and matter, set up as the measure toward which every other art is moving.
Use in the book
The phrase closes the tenth paragraph, which turns the doctrine of the essay into a method. The paragraph has said that music "most completely realises this artistic ideal, this perfect identification of matter and form" (GIO §10; see Artistic ideal), and draws the conclusion in a short sentence: "In music, then, rather than in poetry, is to be found the true type or measure of perfected art" (GIO §10). The long sentence that follows makes the measure the critic's tool. The arts "may be represented as continually struggling after the law or principle of music", and one of the chief functions of criticism is "to estimate the degree in which each of those products approaches, in this sense, to musical law" (GIO §10).
The sentence is built on a concession. Each art keeps "its incommunicable element, its untranslatable order of impressions, its unique mode of reaching the 'imaginative reason'" (GIO §10; see Incommunicable faculty; Order of impressions; Imaginative reason). The law does not abolish the differences of the arts, which the first paragraph made "the beginning of all true æsthetic criticism" (GIO §1; see Sensuous material). It gives the differences a common direction. "May be represented" and "in this sense" keep the claim modest: the struggle after music is a way of seeing the arts, offered as a measure, not a history of what they have done.
"Rather than in poetry" is pointed. Hegel's ranking of the arts put poetry at the top: in his lectures on aesthetics poetry is the universal art, the most spiritual and least bound to matter, and the series of the arts rises to it.1 Pater's measure can be read as reversing that order. Poetry ranks high in Hegel because it is least sensuous; music ranks highest in Pater because in it sense and meaning cannot be told apart. The Winckelmann essay, written ten years earlier, had followed Hegel in ranging the arts in a series (WIN §32; see Ultimate differences of the arts); the Giorgione essay sets a new measure beside it.
The law is applied at once. The next paragraph opens with the Venetian painters, by whom the limitations of painting were "so unerringly though instinctively apprehended" (GIO §11; see Venetian school), and Giorgione is "typical of that aspiration of all the arts towards music" (GIO §12; see Condition of music). The twenty-first paragraph names the law again, "the law or condition of music" to which all art like this is aspiring (GIO §21; see Condition of music). Between the tenth paragraph and the twenty-first the law has passed from theory to the school that obeys it.
Places to read
Every paragraph in which Pater speaks of the law of music, in the order of the book.
- GIO §4All the arts in common aspire towards the principle of music.
- GIO §10The arts may be represented as struggling after the law or principle of music; criticism estimates how far each approaches musical law.
- GIO §21All art like that of Giorgione's school is aspiring to the law or condition of music.
Source note
1. G. W. F. Hegel, Vorlesungen über die Ästhetik, part III, section 3, chapter 3, introduction, where poetry is called the universal art.