Beauty, pleasure and the senses

Subtle and curious grace

subtle and curious grace; subtle, subtler, subtlest, subtlety; curious

The grace born of curiosity in union with the desire of beauty: finely woven, searching, and wrought with care

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordA grace that is fine-spun and carefully wrought, and that carries the inquisitiveness of the mind that made it.
  • In The RenaissanceCuriosity and the desire of beauty are "the two elementary forces in Leonardo's genius; curiosity often in conflict with the desire of beauty, but generating, in union with it, a type of subtle and curious grace" (LEO §16).
  • In this editionThe edition has no note on the phrase.
  • A place to readLEO §16, with LEO §22.

Meaning

Grace, the Latin gratia, is favour, and so the charm that seems given rather than earned, the ease that hides its effort (see Abstract grace). Pater's two adjectives pull against that ease. "Subtle", the Latin subtilis, finely woven, is the quality of a thread or a mind drawn thin (see Meditative subtlety). "Curious" keeps both of its Latin senses: curiosus is careful, taking pains, and so elaborately wrought, and it is also inquisitive, eager to know (see Curiosity). A subtle and curious grace is therefore a grace of effort: fine where ordinary grace is easy, searching where ordinary grace is content, and wrought with the care that ordinary grace conceals.

Use in the book

The phrase ends a paragraph of a single sentence, that names the two forces of his genius and their relation (LEO §16; see Elementary forces). The forces are in conflict "often", and the essay will show the cost of conflict: curiosity alone is the German's case, who "with all that curious science … would have thought nothing more was needed" (LEO §21), and it tends to take Leonardo too far below the outside of things (LEO §20; see Desire of beauty). In union they generate something, and what they generate is not a work but "a type": a kind of grace that recurs through the work and can be recognised.

The phrase joins the two forces in its two adjectives, and the essay's uses of "curious" and "subtle" can be read as the description of that grace in its parts. "Curious" is first the word of care and craft: Leonardo wastes days "in curious tricks of design" (LEO §10), paints flowers "with such curious felicity" that writers credit him with favourites (LEO §18), and is "so curious in observation, curious in invention" (LEO §19; see Sound its stops). It is also the word of strangeness: his sketches of chance people are "full of a curious beauty, that remote beauty" (LEO §11; see Remote beauty), his harp is shaped "in some curious likeness to a horse's skull" (LEO §14), and to those around him he seemed a magician "possessed of curious secrets and a hidden knowledge" (LEO §13). "Subtle" belongs to the finest operations of nature and of art: the art of "tracking the sources of expression to their subtlest retreats" (LEO §10), "the subtler forces of nature" and the "subtlety of operation" that makes matter spiritual (LEO §23; see Spiritual), the train of sentiment "subtle and vague as a piece of music" (LEO §25), and the "subtle expression" that, by the legend, mimes and flute-players kept on La Gioconda's face (LEO §30; see Portraiture).

The essay shows the grace before it analyses it, in the drawings. "This curious beauty is seen above all in his drawings, and in these chiefly in the abstract grace of the bounding lines" (LEO §22; see Abstract grace), and the examples it lists are of the curious kind: the contour of a young man's hair, the poise of a slave's arm above his head (see Poise), the curves of a child's head "following the little skull within, thin and fine as some sea-shell worn by the wind" (LEO §22). Each is grace found by inquiry. The draughtsman who follows the skull under the skin is curious in the anatomist's way, and the line that results is subtle in the weaver's way, "thin and fine". The grace is the trace of the search.

Places to read

Every paragraph of the Leonardo essay in which "subtle", "subtler", "subtlest", "subtlety" or "curious" occurs, in the order of the book.

  1. LEO §10Leonardo learned to track expression to its subtlest retreats, and wasted days in curious tricks of design.
  2. LEO §11His sketches of chance people are full of a curious beauty.
  3. LEO §13To his contemporaries he seemed a magician possessed of curious secrets.
  4. LEO §14His harp of silver was shaped in some curious likeness to a horse's skull.
  5. LEO §16Curiosity and the desire of beauty generate a type of subtle and curious grace.
  6. LEO §18He paints flowers with curious felicity.
  7. LEO §19To sound a character's stops suited one so curious in observation, curious in invention.
  8. LEO §21The German would have thought that curious science was enough.
  9. LEO §22This curious beauty is seen above all in the abstract grace of his drawings.
  10. LEO §23His faces make one aware of the subtler forces of nature and the subtlety of operation which constitutes them spiritual.
  11. LEO §25The ostensible subject starts a train of sentiment subtle and vague as a piece of music.
  12. LEO §30By the legend, mimes and flute-players protracted the subtle expression on La Gioconda's face.

Elsewhere in Pater

The two forces return in the essay first printed as "Romanticism" (1876) and reprinted as the Postscript to Appreciations (1889), where the addition of curiosity to the desire of beauty constitutes the romantic temper (see Strangeness). The grace of the Leonardo essay can be read as that temper's first portrait.