From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
- The wordA sense of fate is the feeling that human lives are ruled by a necessity beyond choice, and in a story the art that makes that necessity felt.
- In The RenaissanceThe two cups of Amis and Amile heighten "That sense of fate, which hangs so much of the shaping of human life on trivial objects, like Othello's strawberry handkerchief" (FRE §10).
- In this editionThe note at FRE §10 recalls Othello's handkerchief and sets the cups against it.
- A place to readFRE §10, the last two sentences, with WIN §53.
Meaning
"Fate" is the Latin fatum, what has been spoken, the decree of the gods. The sense of fate is less a belief than a feeling, and in literature an effect: the reader feels that what happens had to happen. Pater locates it in an unexpected place, in small objects on which great things turn.
Use in the book
The phrase closes Pater's account of the two cups in Amis and Amile. The cups, alike as the friends are, cross and recross in the narrative and serve the heroes almost like living things (FRE §10; see Handiwork). "That sense of fate, which hangs so much of the shaping of human life on trivial objects, like Othello's strawberry handkerchief, is thereby heightened" (FRE §10). In Shakespeare's tragedy a handkerchief spotted with strawberries, Othello's first gift to Desdemona, dropped, picked up and passed to Iago, becomes the proof of a false charge and the cause of her death.1 Pater sets the medieval cups beside it as the same device: fate works through things.
The comparison is pointed, as the note at FRE §10 observes, since the cups and the handkerchief work in opposite directions. The handkerchief destroys a marriage by a false likeness of guilt; the cups save a friendship by a true likeness of origin, and it is by the cup that Amile knows his leprous comrade at the gate (FRE §12; see Inward similitude). Fate in Amis and Amile can be read as providential, and the story's strangest turns, the angel's command and the children's return to life, as fate's work too. The phrase can be read as joining the two senses Pater gives the cups: they are objects of beauty, enjoyed for themselves, and objects of fate, on which lives hang.
The word comes once more, in the plural, in the Du Bellay essay, where French must be the medium of what Du Bellay calls le discours fatal des choses mondaines (BEL §11; see Le discours fatal des choses mondaines). The idea returns in the last paragraph of the Winckelmann essay in a modern form. For us necessity is no longer a "mythological personage" to be fought but "a magic web woven through and through us" (WIN §53; see Necessity; Magic web), and the question is whether art can give the spirit "an equivalent for the sense of freedom" within it (WIN §53). The book moves from a fate that hangs on a cup to a necessity woven through and through us; the sense of fate becomes, at the end, the condition modern art must meet.
Places to read
The one paragraph in which the phrase occurs, with the paragraph where men's fates are named and the paragraph on modern necessity.
- FRE §10The cups heighten that sense of fate which hangs so much of human life on trivial objects, like Othello's handkerchief.
- BEL §11French must be Du Bellay's medium for the discourse about affairs which decides men's fates.
- WIN §53For us necessity is not a mythological personage without us but a magic web woven through us.
In this edition
The note at FRE §10 identifies the handkerchief as the one "Iago uses to make Othello suspect Desdemona's fidelity", and observes that "The cups have an opposite function in the French story".
Source note
1. Shakespeare, Othello 3.3.