From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
Meaning
Surprise, from the French surprendre, to take unawares, was first a military word for a sudden attack and came to mean the feeling of being caught by the unexpected. Pleasure is the book's central term for the effect of beauty (see Pleasure). Joined by "with", the two make a compound effect: not pleasure followed by surprise, nor surprise softened into pleasure, but both at once.
Use in the book
The phrase stands in the definition of the Michelangelesque that closes the first paragraph of the Michelangelo essay (MIC §1; see Michelangelesque; Energy of conception), and it summarises the two sentences before. The first gives surprise: that true works of art "shall excite or surprise us is indispensable". The second gives pleasure: that they "shall give pleasure and exert a charm over us is indispensable too" (MIC §1; see Blossoming of the aloe). Both are "indispensable", and the phrase "pleasure with surprise" holds them in one breath.
The phrase stands beside "sweetness and strength" in a pair of pairs, and the two match. Strength surprises; sweetness pleases. A work that only surprises is strange and no more, and a work that only pleases may be merely pretty; Michelangelo's has both. The order is worth noting: pleasure comes first in the phrase, though surprise comes first in the argument. The essay is written against critics who see only strength, and so it puts pleasure, the neglected term, in front.
The book uses "surprise" in two ways. Most often people are surprised: Fauriel at the refinement of a thirteenth-century tale (FRE §22), children at the whiteness of a ceiling (BOT §7), we who come "with some surprise" on the neglected works of the earlier fifteenth-century sculptors (ROB §1). In four places, the Michelangelo sentence among them, surprise is a quality or effect of art or nature. Leonardo seeks "to satisfy a boundless curiosity by her perpetual surprises", the surprises of nature (LEO §17; see Curiosity); the Pleiad's grace of fancy has nearly all its pleasure "in the surprise at the happy and dexterous way in which a thing slight in itself is handled" (BEL §28); and Greek sculpture keeps passion low, "never winding up the features to one note of anger, or desire, or surprise" (WIN §38; see Law of restraint).
Set side by side, the places make a scale. Greek sculpture excludes surprise, because surprise is a passing state and the Greek ideal is repose (see Expectancy and reception). The Pleiad's grace of fancy has nearly all its pleasure in surprise, the light delight in a slight thing deftly turned. Michelangelo stands between: his art surprises, by its energy and strangeness, and pleases, by a sweetness recovered "touch by touch". The Romantic doctrine that beauty needs strangeness, which Pater would put in a formula in his essay "Romanticism" (1876), later the Postscript to Appreciations (see Strangeness), is here held in balance with its classical opposite.
Places to read
The paragraphs in which surprise is a quality or effect of art or nature, in the order of the book; the ten uses, in nine paragraphs, in which persons are surprised (FRE §22; BOT §7; ROB §1; LEO §§12, 25, 33; GIO §22; BEL §9; WIN §5, twice there), and the "not surprising" of WIN §20, are not listed.
- MIC §1True works of art must excite or surprise us; the true type of the Michelangelesque is pleasure with surprise.
- LEO §17Leonardo seeks to satisfy a boundless curiosity by nature's perpetual surprises.
- BEL §28Nearly all the pleasure of the Pleiad's grace of fancy is in the surprise at the dexterous handling of a slight thing.
- WIN §38Greek sculpture never winds up the features to one note of anger, or desire, or surprise.