From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
- The wordA rule of holding back: in art, the principle that expression should stop short of its extreme.
- In The RenaissanceThe law of restraint "keeps passion always below that degree of intensity at which it must necessarily be transitory" (WIN §38).
- In this editionThe edition has no note on the phrase.
- A place to readWIN §38.
Meaning
Restraint comes through French from the Latin restringere, to bind back. A law of restraint is a rule that binds expression back from its full force. Pater does not mean a law imposed on the artist from outside, as a censor restrains, but a law of the art itself, the condition on which it achieves what it aims at. The phrase belongs with the essay's other words for the self-limitation of sculpture: its renunciation of colour and background (WIN §34; see Plastic art), its motion "ever kept in reserve" (WIN §39; see Reserve).
Use in the book
The phrase stands in the thirty-eighth paragraph, which explains how Greek sculpture achieves its breadth. Works produced under the law of type and abstraction "are really characterised by Hellenic generality or breadth" (WIN §38; see Breadth of humanity). "In every direction it is a law of restraint. It keeps passion always below that degree of intensity at which it must necessarily be transitory, never winding up the features to one note of anger, or desire, or surprise" (WIN §38). The reasoning can be read as compact: intense passion is passing by nature; a statue is permanent; therefore a statue that shows intense passion shows a moment as if it were an eternity, and falsifies both. Restraint is the condition of permanence.
Pater then gives the opposite cases. "In some of the feebler allegorical designs of the middle age, we find isolated qualities portrayed as by so many masks; its religious art has familiarised us with faces fixed immovably into blank types of placid reverie" (WIN §38; see Grotesque). "Men and women, again, in the hurry of life, often wear the sharp impress of one absorbing motive, from which it is said death sets their features free" (WIN §38). The examples are not of excess but of fixity. The mask, the fixed face of reverie and the face stamped by one motive all fail the law in the same way: each is given over to a single note. The last example is the most striking, for it makes death, as "it is said", the restorer of the face's balance; the dead face, freed from its absorbing motive, can be read as having the repose that Greek sculpture gives to the living. Pater ranges all such instances "under the grotesque" (WIN §38; see Grotesque). Restraint is thus not coldness. Under it passion is still allowed "to play lightly over the surface" (WIN §38; see Impassivity); what it forbids is the one note held too long.
The phrase can be read against the book's most famous sentence. The Conclusion makes it success in life to burn always "with this hard, gem-like flame, to maintain this ecstasy" (CON §5; see Hard, gem-like flame), and seems to praise the very intensity the law of restraint forbids. The two are less opposed than they look. The flame of the Conclusion is a way of perceiving, not a passion fixed on one object; in the Conclusion "it might even be said" that "our failure is to form habits" (CON §5), which is the grotesque of the thirty-eighth paragraph, the one absorbing motive, in the life of the mind. The law of restraint and the gem-like flame can both be read as refusals to let a single note become a mask.
Places to read
The paragraph in which the phrase occurs, with WIN §34, on the self-limitation of sculpture, and WIN §39, on its reserve, in the order of the book.
- WIN §34Sculpture renounces the attributes of its material that do not forward its motive, holds colour only by convention, and gains more than it loses by this limitation.
- WIN §38In every direction Greek sculpture works by a law of restraint, keeping passion below the intensity at which it must be transitory.
- WIN §39In the best Greek sculpture motion is ever kept in reserve, and the actions it permits are simple and few.