Art and its materials

Limits of material

the true limits of their material; material

The bounds that an art's material sets, which the best workmen keep and so find new effects within

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordThe bounds within which a material can be worked well, what it allows and what it refuses.
  • In The RenaissanceThe Italian painters on glass in France kept within the true limits of their material and got from it "quite a new order of effects" (BEL §1).
  • In this editionThe edition has no note on the phrase.
  • A place to readBEL §1, with GIO §1.

Meaning

The material of an art is what it is made of, glass, marble, clay, colour, sound, words, and each has its own nature: glass transmits light, marble takes a fine edge, clay can be glazed. Its limits are the things it cannot do, or cannot do well. "True" limits are the real ones, as against the limits that habit or timidity impose, and to keep within them is to work with the material and not against it.

Use in the book

The phrase comes in the first paragraph of the Du Bellay essay, in its account of the Italian painters who came to France and worked on glass. "Taking it up where the middle age had left it, they found their whole work among the last subtleties of colour and line; and keeping within the true limits of their material, they got quite a new order of effects from it, and felt their way to refinements on colour never dreamed of by those older workmen, the glass-painters of Chartres or Le Mans" (BEL §1). The sentence makes the limits the source of the novelty. The painters did not escape the medieval art of glass; they took it up where it was left and kept within its bounds, and the new order of effects came from inside those bounds. The essay can be read as making this the pattern of the whole French Renaissance: a native art, kept within its own nature, refined to effects never dreamed of before (BEL §1; see Renaissance in France).

The book had already made the same point about sculpture. In the della Robbia essay the special limitation of sculpture "results from the material, and other necessary conditions, of all sculptured work" (ROB §6; see Special limitation), and the three great styles are three ways of meeting it; Luca's terra cotta transfers "to a different material the principles of his sculpture" (ROB §2; see Homely art), and Luca himself became desirous "to realise the spirit and manner of that sculpture, in a humbler material" (ROB §12). The limitation is not regretted. It is what each style answers, and the answer is its art.

The Giorgione essay turns the observation into a doctrine. The sensuous material of each art "brings with it a special phase or quality of beauty, untranslatable into the forms of any other" (GIO §1; see Sensuous material), and each art has "its own special responsibilities to its material" (GIO §1; see Responsibilities to its material). It is in its special mode of handling its given material that each art may pass into the condition of another (GIO §3; see Mode of handling). The glass-painters of the Du Bellay essay can be read as the doctrine's first example: they found new effects not by borrowing from another art but by keeping to their own.

The Winckelmann essay applies it to the arts' rank. One form of art, "by the very limitations of its material, may be more adequate than another for the expression of any one phase of that development" (WIN §32; see Development), the development of the mind itself, and sculpture, "a perfect medium of expression for one peculiar motive of the imaginative intellect", "renounces all those attributes of its material which do not forward that motive" (WIN §34; see Plastic art); it is excluded "by the proper limitation of its material from the development of exquisite situations" (WIN §37). There the limits of material decide what an art can say, and the Greek sculptor's renunciation is the same discipline as the French glass-painter's. In every case the word "limits" carries no complaint. A material's limits are its nature, and the book's best workmen are those who know it.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "material" names the medium of an art, in the order of the book.

  1. ROB §2Luca's terra cotta transfers to a different material the principles of his sculpture.
  2. ROB §6The limitation of sculpture results from the material and other necessary conditions of all sculptured work.
  3. ROB §12Luca desires to realise the spirit and manner of marble sculpture in a humbler material.
  4. GIO §1Each art's sensuous material brings its own phase of beauty, and each art has its responsibilities to its material.
  5. GIO §3In its special mode of handling its given material each art may pass into the condition of another.
  6. BEL §1Keeping within the true limits of their material, the painters on glass got a new order of effects from it.
  7. WIN §32One art, by the very limitations of its material, may be more adequate than another for a phase of the spirit.
  8. WIN §33The spirituality that only lurks about architecture takes up, in sculpture, the whole given material.
  9. WIN §34Sculpture renounces all those attributes of its material which do not forward its motive.
  10. WIN §37Sculpture is excluded by the proper limitation of its material from the development of exquisite situations.