Religion, myth and the sacred

Antinomianism

antinomianism; antinomian

Revolt against the moral law in the medieval Renaissance

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordAntinomianism, from the Greek for "against the law", is the doctrine that the faithful are freed by grace from the moral law; by extension, any revolt against binding rules.
  • In The Renaissance"One of the strongest characteristics" of the medieval Renaissance "was its antinomianism, its spirit of rebellion and revolt against the moral and religious ideas of the time" (FRE §32). Its forms are many: a love that "became sometimes a strange idolatry, a strange rival religion", the Albigensians, the Franciscans, Joachim of Flora, and Aucassin's choice of hell, "perhaps the most famous expression" of the spirit (FRE §32). In the Winckelmann essay Greek religion too has "its antinomian mysticism" (WIN §26).
  • In this editionThe note at FRE §32 gives the derivation and says that Pater "extends it to a disposition of imaginative and emotional revolt".
  • A place to readFRE §32, the whole paragraph.

Meaning

The word joins the Greek anti, "against", to nomos, "law". It came into use in the Reformation, apparently from Martin Luther himself, who gave it to the teaching of his Wittenberg colleague Johann Agricola that the law had no place in the preaching of the Gospel; the "antinomians" were those who held that faith set the Christian free of the moral law.1 By Pater's time the word served for any rejection of moral rule, and he uses it so, for a temper of mind rather than a theology.

Use in the book

The word comes in the most daring paragraph of the first essay. "One of the strongest characteristics of that outbreak of the reason and the imagination, of that assertion of the liberty of the heart, in the middle age, which I have termed a medieval Renaissance, was its antinomianism, its spirit of rebellion and revolt against the moral and religious ideas of the time" (FRE §32; see Liberty of the heart; Medieval Renaissance). Pater names its sources and its object together: the search after pleasure, beauty and the worship of the body carried people "beyond the bounds of the Christian ideal", and their love became "a strange rival religion" (FRE §32; see Worship of the body; Idolatry). Its image is pagan: the return of Venus from her hiding in the Venusberg, and of the old gods going about the earth in disguise (FRE §32; see Venusberg).

Pater then sets the element against a reading of history. Ignored by the writers of the "Age of Faith", it is what makes the Romantic writers' middle age "so suggestive and exciting" (FRE §32; see Age of Faith; Romantic school). It is "found alike in the history of Abelard and the legend of Tannhäuser". It tinges the Albigensian movement, makes the Franciscan order with its "illumination" "justly suspect" from the point of view of religious authority, and influences the thoughts of "those obscure prophetical writers, like Joachim of Flora", dreamers of an age "in which law shall have passed away" (FRE §32; see Albigensian movement; Franciscan order; Dispensation; Spirit of freedom). The last phrase is antinomianism in its first sense, the passing away of law.

Pater finds "perhaps the most famous expression" of the spirit in Aucassin's answer when he is threatened with hell if he makes Nicolette his mistress. "A creature wholly of affection and the senses", he sees on the way to paradise only "a feeble and worn-out company of aged priests", and is ready to go to hell with "the good scholars", the fine horsemen and the courteous ladies with "two or three chevaliers apiece", all gay "in their gold, and silver, and beautiful furs—'the vair and the grey'" (FRE §32; see Chevalier; Vair). Pater calls the claim "sinister" in the same paragraph. In the next he grants that in the tale "the note of defiance, of the opposition of one system to another, is sometimes harsh", and ends with a story "in which the harmony of human interests is still entire" (FRE §33). The essay can be read as recording the rebellion as a fact of the period, without taking its side.

The adjective comes back once. Greek religion "too has its mendicants, its purifications, its antinomian mysticism, its garments offered to the gods, its statues worn with kissing" (WIN §26; see Addolorata), among the "wild or melancholy" notes of the medieval church that Greek polytheism anticipated. The pagan world, too, can be read as having its revolt against its own law.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which the noun or the adjective occurs, in the order of the book.

  1. FRE §32The antinomianism of the medieval Renaissance: love as a rival religion, the return of Venus, the Albigensians, the Franciscans, Joachim of Flora, and Aucassin's choice of hell.
  2. WIN §26Greek religion too has its antinomian mysticism.

In this edition

The note at FRE §32 gives the derivation "From Greek words for 'against' and 'law'", explains that "In theology the term concerns freedom from the binding force of a moral or religious law", and observes that Pater "extends it to a disposition of imaginative and emotional revolt". The notes in the same paragraph identify Joachim of Fiore, "a medieval Calabrian abbot", and his third age of the Spirit, and gloss "the vair and the grey" as furs.

Source note

1. Luther's disputations against the Antinomians at Wittenberg, 1537–1540, directed at Johann Agricola, and his open letter Wider die Antinomer (Against the Antinomians), 1539; the Encyclopædia Britannica (11th ed., 1911), "Antinomians", calls it "a term apparently coined by Luther to stigmatize Johannes Agricola".