Philosophy

What Can a Doctor Promise?

Socrates asks whether a doctor always knows when a treatment helps. Knowing the craft still leaves a physician with hard judgments about a particular patient.

Suppose a treatment usually works. The word usually helps explain why Critias’ definition asks too much of a competent doctor.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • What the doctor knowsSocrates asks whether a physician must always know when a treatment helps. Critias concedes that a physician may sometimes be unsure.
  • Experience leaves room for doubtThe first Hippocratic aphorism says that opportunity passes quickly and judgment is hard. It puts uncertainty inside the practice of medicine.
  • Care and recovery can come apartIn the Rhetoric, Aristotle says that a physician can treat someone well even when recovery is impossible. That lets us judge the care and the result separately.
  • A limit worth recognizingCritias’ account makes uncertainty about the result into uncertainty about temperance. Socrates’ refusal to begin his own doctoring without inquiry offers another way to think about care.

Charmides 158e, 163e–164a, 164a–d · Hippocratic Aphorisms 1.1 · Aristotle, Rhetoric 1.1 (1355b) · Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics 3.3 (1112b)

There’s a word you want a doctor to mean when she says a treatment usually works. It’s usually. Socrates’ question to Critias is what a competent person can know when a particular case is still in doubt. A doctor who makes a patient healthy does something beneficial, Critias agrees, and in doing so acts temperately by his definition. Socrates then asks, “Now must a doctor also know when his treatment is beneficial and when it is not?” The question puts a lot of weight on what a doctor can be expected to know.

One possibility is a doctor who has no idea what he’s doing and tries remedies at random. Critias could fairly ask what earns him the name of doctor in the first place. But consider a physician who understands the illness, chooses the treatment carefully and still has to wait to see whether it helps this patient. She can have good reasons for her choice and be candid about its chances. That is the doctor who means the word usually.

The first Hippocratic aphorism puts those limits right at the beginning of its account of medicine. Life is short, the craft takes a long time to learn, the opportunity passes quickly, experiment can be risky and judgment is difficult. The author also asks the physician to attend to what the patient and the people around him can do. There’s a whole situation to judge, and the skill the aphorism asks of a doctor includes understanding that situation while it’s still changing.

In the Rhetoric, Aristotle brings in medicine to explain what a craft can do. A physician can promote recovery as far as a case allows. Good treatment is possible even for a patient who will never recover. The comparison is with an orator, who can find the means of persuading an audience without being able to promise that the audience will be persuaded. In both cases it makes sense to ask what someone did well while the result is still in doubt.

That kind of uncertainty is enough to put pressure on Critias’ account. After treatment, Socrates says, a doctor may have acted beneficially or harmfully. The doctor still “does not know himself — how he has acted.” He has put the doctor himself on the receiving end of the verb for knowing. The phrasing matters because Critias is about to make knowing oneself the center of the argument. Here the doctor is unsure how to describe what he did in terms of its benefit or harm.

But consider what the doctor can already tell you. She can explain what she observed, why she chose this treatment and how she carried it out. Sometimes she has to wait to find out how the patient responds. Even later it can be hard to tell how much a treatment helped. On the reading Socrates is testing, Critias’ definition makes the verdict about temperance wait for the verdict about benefit. It leaves us with no way to credit the care that went into a decision while the outcome remains uncertain.

Aristotle makes room for that kind of care in his account of deliberation. He contrasts spelling, where the answer is already settled, with medicine, where what we do can produce different results, and with navigation, where judgment often matters. You deliberate when you can do something about a case and the way forward is still uncertain. The uncertainty is part of what makes the deliberation worth doing. A person can take responsibility for deciding even when the decision comes with no guarantee.

My verdict is that Socrates needs only a competent doctor who can’t promise a result. That makes the question a better test of the definition. If temperance has something to do with the care we take when we act, a person can exercise it while still unsure how things will go. Think of Socrates with Charmides at the start. He refuses to set about his “doctoring without looking into things.” The modest promise he can make is to look into the case with the boy. That is something he can actually do.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author focus on a competent doctor whose treatment may still fail?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.