Philosophy
The Press Release and the Real Kid
When Charmides borrows a definition, he starts to wonder whether its author understands it either.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesCritias introduces Charmides as a philosopher and poet. The young man who actually speaks is still forming his own opinions, and he’s willing to admit it.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Advance billingCritias introduces his ward as a philosopher and says that Charmides shares other people’s high opinion of his poetry.
- His own voiceCharmides jokes with Socrates about getting the charm, then admits he does not know how to answer a question about his temperance.
- A borrowed definitionCharmides repeats a definition he has heard, and Socrates suspects that it came from Critias.
- A question in a jokeCharmides wonders whether the man who supplied the definition understands it himself.
The portrait of Charmides arrives well before the person does. Critias tells Socrates that his ward is “a philosopher and, in other people’s opinion as well as his own, quite the poet,” which is the kind of line you’d find in a press release or a glowing letter of recommendation. Notice the little detail tucked inside it. The boy shares other people’s high opinion of his poetry, so at least on that front he’s already signed on to the publicity. Advance billing like that is a burden as much as a gift, since every word the boy speaks will now be measured against it.
Then we hear his actual voice, and it’s not the voice of the press release. First he asks whether Socrates knows a remedy. Then we hear him ask “So what is it?” and offer to copy the charm down. When Socrates teases him about whether he’ll copy it with permission or without, he laughs and says, “If I persuade you, Socrates,” and when asked whether he knows who Socrates is, he answers that he’d be doing him an injustice if he didn’t. That’s a quick, polite and playful kid with excellent social instincts, which tells us something the word “philosopher” never could. Plato gives him real charm in these little exchanges, the easy confidence of someone who is used to being liked.
When the real questions start, the voice gets more careful. He handles the trap about whether he’s temperate with real tact, refusing to boast or to contradict his guardian and ending with an honest “So I don’t know what answer to give you.” Asked what temperance is, he at first “hung back, and was not at all willing to answer,” and when he does answer, he offers quietness, then modesty, both drawn from how a well-raised boy is supposed to behave. These are cautious, sensible answers from a young man who knows the rules of good conduct, but they’re not the bold flights you’d expect from the poet-philosopher of the advertisement. There’s nothing wrong with them as a teenager’s answers, and they show he pays attention to how people actually behave.
Then the borrowed opinion arrives, and it confirms the worst suspicion about the press release. His third definition, that temperance is doing one’s own business, is something he once heard someone say, and Socrates guesses at once that it came from Critias or some other clever man. If Socrates has guessed right, the “philosopher” has a definition on loan from the very guardian who wrote the portrait. It’s a little like spotting a parent’s turn of phrase in a student’s application essay. Borrowing isn’t a crime, since everyone starts that way, but it punctures the portrait.
And then comes the line that rescues him from his own press release. Socrates asks what doing one’s own business could possibly mean, and Charmides answers, “By Zeus, I don’t know,” adding, “But perhaps there is nothing to stop even the man who said it from not knowing what he meant,” and then he laughs slyly and looks across at Critias. It’s a joke, and a way of passing the blame, but it’s also the most philosophical sentence the boy speaks in the whole dialogue, because it suggests that the author of a definition might not understand it himself. It’s also a rather daring thing to say about your guardian in front of a crowd.
Critias takes over the argument and says the phrase means doing good things. But that answer gives way to a new one about knowledge, and eventually Socrates catches Critias trying to cover his confusion in front of the crowd. The boy, with one sly line, has anticipated the dialogue’s central theme, the difference between knowing something and only thinking you know it, and has aimed it at the right person, so the joke is closer to real philosophy than anything in the press release. The kid who couldn’t define temperance has, in one aside, spotted the problem the grown-ups will spend the rest of the afternoon tripping over.
What the actual voice gives us, then, is a richer and more interesting person than the portrait promised. He’s tactful, witty and honest about not knowing, still forming his own opinions and capable of genuine insight, which he delivers here as a joke at his guardian’s expense. The portrait called him accomplished, while the voice shows promise, which is a better thing to have at his age and a much better place for a conversation to start. It’s a more honest portrait than any guardian could write.
My verdict is that the gap between Critias’ introduction and the boy’s voice is the gap between reputation and person, and Plato lets the voice correct the press release in both directions. It counts against him where he falls back on a borrowed opinion, and in his favor where his honesty and wit show through. “Philosopher” was premature, but the sly laugh at 162b shows something better than a finished philosopher, a young man who has just glimpsed the question the rest of the dialogue will chase. That’s the real reason to keep listening to him.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author think Charmides’ third definition of temperance weakens Critias’ flattering portrait of him?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When does borrowing another person’s idea become a weakness, and when can it be a legitimate stage in learning to think independently?→
- Why might admitting ignorance be better evidence of philosophical promise than confidently offering a definition?→
- How does Charmides’ humor change the force of his criticism of Critias, and would the same insight seem different if stated seriously?→