Philosophy

Does Good Breeding Prove Anything?

Socrates hears a good answer and says it does Charmides’ family credit. When Charmides later asks whether it matters who first said something, he gives Socrates a reason to look past the pedigree.

Praise can set a high standard for Charmides. It can also make the room expect a good answer before he has given one. The dialogue puts those expectations to the test.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Family praise reaches the answerSocrates praises both sides of Charmides’ family, then says that the boy’s careful response to a difficult question did his breeding credit.
  • A compliment can tilt a judgmentCalling an answer worthy of the family can invite a young person to live up to it. It can also make listeners overlook weaknesses they would notice in someone else.
  • What a father can pass onIn the Meno and Protagoras, Socrates asks whether prominent Athenians could pass their own excellence to their sons, even when they gave them outstanding teachers.
  • An answer stands on its ownWhen Charmides asks why it matters who first offered a definition, Socrates agrees that they should test whether it is true. The exchange gives them a standard anyone in the room can answer to.

Charmides 157b–e, 157e–158c, 158c–d, 161b–c · Meno 93a–d, 94a–e · Protagoras 319e–320b · Xenophon, Hellenica 2.4.19 · Theaetetus 149a

Two moments in quick succession put breeding squarely on the table. First Socrates praises the boy’s family in grand style, a house celebrated by Anacreon and Solon on one side and a famously handsome uncle on the other, concluding, “Born of such people, you are likely to be first in everything.” Then, when Charmides answers the question about his temperance by explaining why he is reluctant to boast or contradict his guardian, Socrates says he “gave an answer that did his breeding credit,” and the Greek can be read as “not ignobly.” The word belongs to the same family as the word for “wellborn” in the Thracian doctor’s warning. Even the boy’s answer gets graded on a scale of birth, as if a teacher wrote “worthy of your family” in the margin of an essay instead of “well argued.”

The overlap is familiar in English. A noble person can be someone with a rank or someone who acts generously. You hear much the same ambiguity in Socrates’ praise. The boy has given a thoughtful answer, and the narrator chooses a word that also brings family standing to mind. The same assumption survives in English whenever we call a mean act “low” and a generous one “high-minded,” as if character came with a social address.

There’s a reasonable case that this kind of praise supports the examination rather than spoiling it. High expectations can work as an invitation, the old idea that privilege brings obligation, and telling a young man that he comes from people who were first in everything is a way of telling him what he owes. Socrates also turns the praise into a question immediately, asking the boy whether he thinks he has enough temperance, so the pedigree can serve as a challenge to live up to. The question of what he is like remains open. Plenty of people have risen to a family’s expectations, and that kind of pressure isn’t always a bad thing.

The case on the other side is just as easy to make. Praising an answer as worthy of the boy’s breeding judges the person by his class, and Critias has already told the room what a reputation the boy has. The compliment can tilt the judgment toward what people expect to find. A teacher who tells a student that his essay is just what you’d expect from his family has praised the family more than the essay, and has made it a little harder for anyone to notice if the essay is actually weak. One impressive trait can color our judgment of all the others.

Plato gives us other scenes in which Socrates tests the connection between a family and its children’s character. In the Meno, Socrates runs through the greatest Athenians of the previous generation, Themistocles, Aristides, Pericles and Thucydides the son of Melesias, and points out that each of them gave his sons the finest teachers in riding, wrestling and the rest, yet asks whether they managed to pass on the excellence for which they were known. In the Protagoras he uses Pericles’ sons again, along with Alcibiades’ younger brother, to press the question of whether a good man can teach his excellence, even to the people he raises. Thucydides’ sons, Socrates notes, were among the best wrestlers in Athens, because he hired the best teachers he could find. Whether he could do anything comparable for his sons’ character is what Socrates wants to know.

The family praise has a darker sound if you know what happened later. Xenophon reports that Critias died fighting as one of the Thirty and that Charmides, one of the Ten who governed the Piraeus, died in the same battle. For readers who knew the story of the oligarchy, it would be hard to hear the praise of the family as a guarantee of what either man would become.

The conversation eventually finds a different standard. When Socrates wonders who first offered the definition about doing one’s own business, Charmides asks what difference that makes. Socrates agrees that what matters is whether it’s true. A definition either holds up or it doesn’t, no matter whose grandson offers it. There’s a nice parallel in the Theaetetus. Socrates calls his mother Phaenarete a noble midwife, using the same adjective that can mean wellborn. Here the word can carry praise for a working woman. In the wrestling school, a good argument can come from anyone willing to offer one.

My verdict is that Socrates’ talk of breeding does all three things the question suggests. It works as a courtesy that motivates, it leans on the scale in a way a careful reader should notice, and it exposes a social standard that the inquiry has to leave behind. Socrates starts by speaking the language of birth. The question he and Charmides end up agreeing to ask is whether an answer is true. It has room for a good answer from anyone.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does the article explain the potentially constructive role of Socrates’ praise of Charmides’ ancestry?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.