Philosophy
“Are You Humble?” Is a Trick Question
Charmides can praise himself or make his guardian look like a liar. Socrates gives him a way to keep talking by asking him what temperance is.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesA public question about character can make candor awkward. By asking Charmides for a definition, Socrates gives him a question he can try answering and gives the two of them something to examine together.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Both answers cost somethingCharmides says that claiming temperance would sound conceited and denying it would make Critias and his other admirers look like liars.
- Socrates takes the pressure offSocrates agrees that Charmides has a point and invites him to look into it together. He gives Charmides the choice to leave the question alone.
- From a verdict to a definitionSocrates asks what temperance seems to be. Charmides can try an answer and see whether it holds up without declaring what sort of person he is.
- Another question put in orderIn the Meno, Socrates asks what virtue is before deciding whether it can be taught. Both dialogues make room to find out what a virtue amounts to before pressing for a verdict.
Everybody knows the trick question “Are you humble?”, since a yes can sound like a boast and a no can sound like fishing for compliments. It’s the kind of question that puts your manners to the test. Charmides gets a version of that question in a crowded wrestling school, with his guardian at his elbow and a ring of admirers listening, when Socrates asks him straight out whether he agrees with Critias that he already has enough temperance or thinks he’s lacking in it.
The boy’s answer is one of the smartest things anyone says in the dialogue, because he describes the trap before choosing an answer. It’s not easy, he says, either to agree or to deny, since denying it would be “an odd thing to say such things against oneself,” and would make his guardian and many others look like liars, while saying yes and praising himself “will probably seem obnoxious.” Then he says what he can say honestly. “So I don’t know what answer to give you.” Plenty of adults faced with a question like that would bluff, and the boy instead tells the truth about the question itself.
It’s worth seeing why the trap makes honest speech so awkward. The boy has two social expectations to mind. He should avoid boasting and avoid contradicting his guardian. Whatever his character is like, either answer could be heard as a breach of one of those expectations, so the question turns a conversation about character into a performance in front of a crowd, the way “What’s your greatest weakness?” in a job interview produces a rehearsed answer instead of an honest one. The crowd turns the question into a kind of vote, and the whole room is there to hear his vote.
Socrates doesn’t press him for an answer, and that’s the first thing he gets right. “You seem to me to be talking sense, Charmides,” he says, treating the boy’s refusal to answer as a reasonable response. Then he proposes that they look into the matter together, so that the boy won’t be forced to say anything he doesn’t want to, which takes the question out of the courtroom and puts it on a workbench where two people can handle it. Pushing a cornered person for a straight answer usually just gets you a better-crafted evasion, and Socrates seems to know it.
The really important move comes next, though, and it’s easy to miss because it sounds so natural. If temperance is present in you, Socrates says, it must give rise to some sense of itself, and from that you’d have some opinion about “what it is, and what sort of thing temperance is,” so tell me what you think it is. The question has changed shape. Charmides can say what he thinks temperance is without saying whether he has it. A question about yourself has become a question about what a virtue amounts to. A word doesn’t blush.
That switch is one of Socrates’ signature moves, and Plato puts it at the heart of other dialogues too. At the start of the Meno, when a young man asks whether virtue can be taught, Socrates says he can’t even begin to answer, because if you don’t know what something is, you can’t know what qualities it has. The Charmides makes a related move, with a wrinkle. Socrates thinks that having a virtue would give Charmides some sense of what it’s like. An account of what temperance is would give them a way to make a guess about whether he has it. Either way, there’s a question they can work on before they try for a verdict.
The new question is kinder, but it isn’t easier, and that’s important too. The boy now has to come up with an account of temperance that can stand up to questioning. His first two, quietness and modesty, both run into trouble. Still, a definition can fail in a respectable way, the way a student’s first idea in class might fail. Socrates tells us, “At first he hung back,” but Charmides eventually gives it a real try. He can see what goes wrong with his examples without having to hear what the room thinks of his character.
My verdict is that the bind on the bench shows how praise and social rules can get in the way of an honest account of yourself. The change of question gives this conversation somewhere to go. By turning “Am I?” into “What is it?” Socrates gets the boy talking without asking him to boast or call his guardian a liar. It’s also a tool any reader can borrow, since when someone asks you to certify your own virtues, you can start by asking what the virtue actually is. The answer usually turns out to be hard enough to keep everyone humble, and that’s a humility nobody has to claim out loud.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does Charmides say he does not know how to answer whether he possesses temperance?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When does asking someone to assess their own virtue produce insight, and when does it mainly test their ability to manage social expectations?→
- Does changing “Do I have this virtue?” into “What is this virtue?” postpone self-knowledge, or is it a necessary step toward it? Why?→
- What makes a failed definition respectable, and how might the social setting affect a person's willingness to risk offering one?→