Criticism and method

Wholeness

wholeness

The state of a nature undivided among its aims: Goethe's word for Winckelmann, and in the Greek statues a wholeness that cannot act

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordThe condition of being whole, entire, undivided; of a person, the soundness of a nature that is not split among aims.
  • In The RenaissanceThe secret of Winckelmann's influence, Goethe tells us, is "wholeness, unity with one's self, intellectual integrity" (WIN §10).
  • In this editionThe edition has no note on the word; the note at WIN §51 says that Goethe's Ganzen means "the whole".
  • A place to readWIN §§10, 42, 51.

Meaning

Whole is the Old English hāl, which meant both entire and healthy; hale, heal and holy are of the same family. Wholeness is therefore health as well as completeness, and the double sense runs through the German tradition that Pater follows. Goethe's essay on Winckelmann (1805) imagines man's healthy nature working "as a whole", and man feeling himself in the world "as in a great, beautiful, worthy and valued whole", and calls that the condition of the ancients.1 The same ideal had its English statement in Pater's day (see Many-sided intellectual culture). Pater uses the noun twice, once of a man and once of a statue, and Goethe's im Ganzen gives the idea a third form.

Use in the book

The first use is Goethe's list (WIN §10; see Intellectual integrity). Pater doubts whether the words fit the narrow Winckelmann (see Narrow perfection), and then quotes the sentence of Goethe's that can be read as justifying the first of them. "He was thirty years old before he enjoyed a single favour of fortune: but so soon as he had attained to an adequate condition of freedom, he appears before us consummate and entire, complete in the ancient sense" (WIN §10). Winckelmann's wholeness is not breadth. It is the wholeness of a thing that has all its parts, though there are few of them. The forty-second paragraph gives its image: "We have seen how definite was the leading motive of that culture; how, like some central root-fibre, it maintained the well-rounded unity of his life through a thousand distractions" (WIN §42).

The second use turns the word on the statues. Their beauty "was a sexless beauty" (WIN §42; see Sexless beauty), and in them Pater finds "a moral sexlessness, a kind of ineffectual wholeness of nature" (WIN §42; see Moral sexlessness). Their wholeness is that of a nature with nothing outside itself to act upon (see Sexless beauty). The wholeness of the god is the wholeness of a nature that has not yet been called on to choose.

The third form of the idea is Goethe's own, and Pater gives it in German. Goethe's description of his higher life is to live resolutely "im Ganzen", in the whole, and "life in the whole" turns out to mean the life of one for whom, over and over, what was once precious has become indifferent (WIN §51; see Im Ganzen). His Hellenism is "the completeness and serenity, of a watchful, exigent intellectualism" (WIN §51; see Exigent intellectualism).

The three wholenesses can be read as the essay's argument in small. Winckelmann's is won by exclusion, the plucking out of every interest not his own; the statue's is given by indifference, since it has no interests to divide it; Goethe's is reached by passing through, taking each form of culture and leaving it behind. Pater does not rank them, but only the last can be read as open to a modern: the statue's is an image of what life lacks, and a single talent exercised directly can now end only in one-sided growth (WIN §51; see Centrality). Wholeness, which the Old English word joined to health, becomes in the essay a task rather than a state.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "wholeness" occurs, with those in the Winckelmann essay in which a life, or the intellect's demand, is called whole, complete or entire, in the order of the book.

  1. WIN §10Goethe names wholeness as the secret of Winckelmann's influence; free at last, Winckelmann appears consummate and entire, complete in the ancient sense.
  2. WIN §12The aim of culture should be to attain not only as intense but as complete a life as possible.
  3. WIN §42The leading motive of his culture maintained the well-rounded unity of his life; in the Greek statues there is a kind of ineffectual wholeness of nature.
  4. WIN §50The intellect demands completeness, centrality, not less than ever.
  5. WIN §51Goethe's higher life is life in the whole, im Ganzen; his Hellenism is the completeness and serenity of an exigent intellectualism.

Source note

1. Johann Wolfgang von Goethe, Winckelmann und sein Jahrhundert (Tübingen, 1805), "Skizzen zu einer Schilderung Winckelmanns", section "Antikes": Wenn die gesunde Natur des Menschen als ein Ganzes wirkt, wenn er sich in der Welt als in einem großen, schönen, würdigen und werten Ganzen fühlt.