Criticism and method

Typical standards

typical standards; typical

The qualities of the great masters as patterns by which the critic measures lesser and stranger work

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordA typical standard is a model that shows a kind in its purest form, and so serves as a measure for other instances.
  • In The RenaissanceThe qualities of the great masters are "not peculiar to them; but most often typical standards, or revealing instances of the laws by which certain æsthetic effects are produced" (MIC §21).
  • In this editionThe edition has no note on the phrase.
  • A place to readMIC §21.

Meaning

"Typical", from the Greek typos, an impression or stamp, means what has the character of a type: the representative example of a class (see Type). A "standard" was first a flag raised to rally troops, then a fixed measure kept by authority, the standard yard or pound. Joined, the words make a model that does two things: it represents its kind, and it measures other things against it.

Use in the book

The phrase stands in the first sentence of the last paragraph of the Michelangelo essay: the qualities of the great masters are "most often typical standards, or revealing instances of the laws by which certain æsthetic effects are produced" (MIC §21; see Æsthetic effect). The paragraph's third sentence gives the standard its use: "But when once we have succeeded in defining for ourselves those characteristics, and the law of their combination, we have acquired a standard or measure which helps us to put in its right place many a vagrant genius, many an unclassified talent, many precious though imperfect products of art" (MIC §21; see Vagrant genius).

The sentence describes a method in three steps. The critic first defines the characteristics of a great master, then "the law of their combination", how they "moderate, support, relieve each other"; and with that law in hand he has a measure. The measure is for the unplaced: the vagrant, the unclassified, the imperfect. Great masters are easy to admire; it is the lesser and stranger artists who need a standard, and the old masters supply one because "their characteristics are written larger, and are easier to read" (MIC §21; see Analogue). The paragraph applies the method at once: the interfusion of sweetness and strength, defined in Michelangelo, is found again in Blake and Victor Hugo (MIC §21; see Sweetness and strength).

"Typical" is a word the book uses of art at its most representative. Music is "the typical, or ideally consummate art", the object of the aspiration of all the others (GIO §4; see Anders-streben); Giorgione "is typical of that aspiration of all the arts towards music" (GIO §12); the Concert in the Pitti Palace is "the typical instance" of the Giorgionesque (GIO §19) and "is typical of everything that Giorgione, himself an admirable musician, touched with his influence" (GIO §21). In the Winckelmann essay the Mothers of Faust "mould and remould the typical forms that appear in human history" (WIN §29), and Winckelmann's insight into "the typical unity and repose of the highest sort of sculpture seems to have involved limitation in another direction" (WIN §45). The typical is the case in which a kind shows itself most clearly.

"Standard" brings with it the question of authority. The Winckelmann essay speaks of "a standard of taste, which genius confesses", fixed "in Greece, at a definite historical period" (WIN §23; see Orthodoxy), and the Giorgione essay of the "new Vasari" for whom the Pitti Concert becomes "the standard of Giorgione's genuine work" (GIO §16). Pater's typical standards are of a different kind. They are not rules imposed from Greece but qualities found by the critic in a master and carried, as measures, to other work; their authority is that of a clear example.

The Preface refuses a "universal formula" for beauty (PRE §1; see Universal formula), and the Michelangelo essay ends by allowing standards. The two can be read as consistent, since the standard is drawn from particular works and applied to particular works: the critic does not define beauty, but learns from Michelangelo what sweetness and strength look like together, and then recognises them in later men.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "typical" occurs, in the order of the book.

  1. MIC §21The qualities of the great masters are most often typical standards, and give a measure for many a vagrant genius.
  2. GIO §4Music is the typical, or ideally consummate art.
  3. GIO §12Giorgione is typical of the aspiration of all the arts towards music.
  4. GIO §19The Pitti Concert is the typical instance of the Giorgionesque.
  5. GIO §21The Concert is typical of everything Giorgione touched with his influence.
  6. WIN §29The Mothers of Faust mould the typical forms that appear in human history.
  7. WIN §45Winckelmann's insight into the typical unity and repose of sculpture involved limitation elsewhere.