Religion, myth and the sacred

Previous state of existence

previous state of existence

The former life in which, on the Platonic account, lovers first knew each other, so that love at first sight is a recognition

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordA life before this one: the soul's existence before its present birth.
  • In The Renaissance"He accounts for love at first sight by a previous state of existence—la dove io t'amai prima" (MIC §14).
  • In this editionThe note at MIC §14 renders la dove io t'amai prima "There where I loved you before", and says that "Pater reads the earlier love as taking place in a former existence".
  • A place to readMIC §14.

Meaning

The idea is Platonic: the soul, before it entered the body, saw the forms, and among them beauty itself; in this life a beautiful face recalls what it saw, and love is a kind of memory.1 From this doctrine Michelangelo, on Pater's account, drew an account of love at first sight. If the soul recognises in a face what it knew before birth, the first sight is not first but a recognition, and two souls may have known each other already.

Use in the book

The phrase stands in the last sentence of the fourteenth paragraph of the Michelangelo essay, which closes its comparison of Dante and Plato: "He accounts for love at first sight by a previous state of existence—la dove io t'amai prima" (MIC §14). The Italian, from Michelangelo's sonnet "La vita del mie amor non è 'l cor mio", the edition renders "There where I loved you before": a place, la dove (modern là dove, "there where"), as if the former life were a country the lovers had lived in.2

The sentence is the paragraph's last example of the Platonic tradition at work in Michelangelo's verse. Dante's love began in this world, "in early youth" (MIC §14; see Platonic lover; Anti-natal state); Michelangelo's, in the poem Pater quotes, began before the world. The Platonic doctrine, which the paragraph has set against Dante's belief in the resurrection of the body (see Passage of the soul; Resurrection of the body), gives the poet a way of explaining the suddenness of love: it is sudden because it is old.

"Accounts for" is Pater's word, and it is exact: the doctrine in the poem is an explanation, a way of making sense of an experience. The edition's note marks the reading as Pater's, but the sonnet bears it out. Love, it says, was given to the poet "when the soul departed from God", nel dipartir l'alma da Dio, and he turns to the beloved's eyes, which hold "all paradise", "to return there where I loved you first". The "there" is where the soul was before birth. The sonnet is the same whose first two lines Pater prints by themselves as the eleventh paragraph of the essay (MIC §11; see Amor).

The doctrine has two other places in the book, the "anti-natal state" of the tenth paragraph and Winckelmann's "phase of pre-existence" (MIC §10; WIN §19; see Anti-natal state); in all three Pater uses a single myth, for love, for beauty and for genius, and in each it explains an experience as remembrance.

Places to read

The phrase occurs once.

  1. MIC §14Michelangelo accounts for love at first sight by a previous state of existence: there where I loved you before.

In this edition

The note at MIC §14 says: "English: There where I loved you before. Italian. Pater reads the earlier love as taking place in a former existence."

Source note

1. Plato, Phaedrus 249c–251a.

2. Michelangelo, sonnet "La vita del mie amor non è 'l cor mio" (Girardi 34), lines 5–6, 12–13.