Images from nature and science

Concurrence

the concurrence

A running together of forces that will part again: the Conclusion's account of what a life is

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordA running together, a meeting of things or forces in one point, from the Latin concurrere.
  • In The RenaissanceOur life "is but the concurrence, renewed from moment to moment, of forces parting sooner or later on their ways" (CON §2).
  • In this editionThe edition has no note on the word.
  • A place to readCON §2.

Meaning

Concurrere is to run together, as soldiers run to battle or crowds to a spectacle, and concursus was both a meeting and a clash. In Cicero's dialogue on the nature of the gods the Academic Cotta mocks the atomists' claim that heaven and earth were made of tiny particles "by a certain chance concourse", concursu quodam fortuito, and the word carried that sense into the natural philosophy of the moderns: a concurrence of causes is their meeting to produce one effect.1 In English the word also kept the sense of agreement, as when judges concur. Pater's use is the physical one, with the stress on the meeting's being brief.

Use in the book

The word ends the second paragraph of the Conclusion, and with it the account of the body. Pater has shown that our physical life is a perpetual motion of natural elements, that the forces which act in us act also beyond us, and that the clear outline of face and limb is only an image under which we group them, "a design in a web" (CON §2; see Web). Then the sentence that ends the paragraph: our life is flame-like in this at least, that it is "but the concurrence, renewed from moment to moment, of forces parting sooner or later on their ways" (CON §2; see Flame-like).

The sentence gives a life three properties. It is a concurrence: not a substance but a meeting, the point at which forces from elsewhere run together. It is "renewed from moment to moment": the meeting is not made once and kept but made again in every instant, as a flame is made again by the fuel it consumes. And the forces are "parting sooner or later on their ways": each has its own way, and the meeting is a crossing of paths that will separate. The words "on their ways" return in the fifth paragraph, where we are to discriminate in those about us, "in the very brilliancy of their gifts", "some tragic dividing of forces on their ways" (CON §5; see Tragic dividing of forces). What was physics in the second paragraph can be read as tragedy in the fifth.

The word gathers the language of forces that runs through the book. The Preface regards works of art "as powers or forces producing pleasurable sensations" (PRE §3; see Powers or forces); Leonardo's women are delicate instruments through whom we become aware of "the subtler forces of nature" (LEO §23; see Clairvoyant); the Winckelmann essay ends with a network of law "bearing in it the central forces of the world" (WIN §53; see Magic web). In the Conclusion the forces are the matter of the self, and the self is their concurrence. The fourth paragraph asks how we may be present always "at the focus" (CON §4; see Focus). A concurrence that cannot last can at least be intense, and the art of life, on this account, is to be where the forces meet most.

The sentence can be read as Pater's answer to the materialism of his decade without a denial of it. He accepts that a life is made of forces that will separate. He does not ask what remains when they part, as the religious reader would, or conclude that nothing matters, as the despairing one would. He asks only how the concurrence, while it lasts, may be made as full as it can be.

Places to read

The paragraph in which "concurrence" occurs, with its 1873 text and the paragraph of the forces that divide on their ways, in the order of the book.

  1. CON §2Life is a concurrence of forces, renewed from moment to moment, that will part sooner or later.
  2. CON §5In those about us, and in the very brilliancy of their gifts, we are to discriminate some tragic dividing of forces on their ways.
  3. C73 §2In 1873 the sentence is the same.

Elsewhere in Pater

Marius the Epicurean (1885) gives the Conclusion's physics to the followers of Heraclitus and Aristippus, for whom things pass away too swiftly for any real knowledge of them (see Mid-stream).2

Source note

1. Cicero, De natura deorum I.66.

2. Walter Pater, Marius the Epicurean (London, 1885), chapter VIII, "Animula Vagula".