Judgment and inquiry

Contradiction

Contradiction; contredites; contrariétés; sujet de contradiction

An opposition between speakers, claims, or tendencies; these are not automatically the same kind of contradiction.

From the book

Pensées

Blaise Pascal · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordAn opposition between speakers, claims, or tendencies; these are not automatically the same kind of contradiction.
  • In the bookDisagreement cannot decide truth, while human oppositions expose the inadequacy of one-sided descriptions.
  • In this editionFragment 384 begins with ‘Being contradicted’; Fragment 434 makes humanity a ‘subject of contradiction’.
  • A place to readFragment 384 for the evidential rule; Fragment 434 for the opposed accounts of humanity.

Meaning

Contradiction may be what someone meets when contradicted, not a formal inconsistency within a proposition. Fragment 384 makes this distinction indispensable: certain things encounter denials, whereas false things can pass unchallenged. Contrariété also gathers opposed tendencies, as when humanity is both credulous and incredulous, timid and rash (Fragment 125). Such a list need not assert that the same judgment is affirmed and denied at precisely the same time and in the same respect. It asks how these different dispositions belong to one kind of creature. The inquiry concerns the relation between its capacities, conduct, aspirations, and failures.

Use in the book

The practical sting of disagreement appears in Fragment 80. A challenge to our reasoning irritates us more than a mistaken report of a headache because we are less secure about having chosen truth than about our present bodily condition. Another person may see the contrary with the same apparent assurance; a thousand mockers intensify the difficulty. Pascal explains the disturbance disagreement produces without granting either the solitary thinker or the multitude an automatic victory. Fragment 384 supplies the explicit correction: neither contradiction nor its absence is a reliable mark of truth or falsehood. The point blocks both an appeal to consensus and the romantic assumption that opposition itself proves an exceptional insight.

Elsewhere contradiction belongs to the relation between a doctrine and the person asserting it. Fragment 377 notices that a discourse on humility can serve pride, and that Pyrrhonism can be asserted dogmatically. The manner of speaking may undermine the attitude professed. Fragment 404 similarly makes the person who lowers humanity to animal status still seek human admiration and belief. The contradiction here is exposed through conduct and desire, not merely by comparing two sentences. Fragment 405 sharpens the trap: pride either conceals misery or boasts of knowing it. Even a correct recognition of a fault may become material for the fault's renewal.

The opposed schools in Fragment 394 each start from something true but reach false conclusions by failing to admit the truth of opposing principles. Fragment 416 shows the resulting circle: evidence for greatness becomes evidence for misery because the greater the original height, the more miserable the fall; awareness of misery in turn attests greatness. Fragment 420's speaker accordingly promises to contradict both boasting and self-abasement until the hearer understands the human predicament. This is a directed practice of correction, not a recommendation to oppose every claim indiscriminately. Fragment 423 gives the positive discrimination it seeks: love the capacity for good without loving baseness; acknowledge its emptiness without despising the capacity itself.

Fragment 434 unfolds the largest confrontation. Its opening states the Pyrrhonians' arguments, including doubts about origin and dreaming; these are reported strengths of a position, not an unqualified declaration that Pascal endorses every premise. The dogmatists answer that sincere doubt of natural principles is impossible. Nature prevents complete skepticism in practice, while reason prevents an unsupported claim to complete possession of truth. The successive descriptions of humanity as judge and earthworm, keeper of truth and sink of error, intensify this impasse. Pascal then turns to God's teaching and the distinction between creation or grace and corruption. This is his proposed religious explanation, not a conclusion supplied by the word contradiction itself. It keeps the two sides together by distinguishing conditions rather than announcing that incompatible propositions are true without qualification.

Places to read

  1. Fragment 80FrenchContradictory judgments trouble confidence differently from a mistaken report about bodily health.
  2. Fragment 125FrenchThe human inventory pairs contrary dispositions.
  3. Fragment 377FrenchThe manner of asserting a doctrine can contradict the attitude it professes.
  4. Fragment 384FrenchContradiction and its absence fail as sufficient tests of truth.
  5. Fragment 394FrenchTrue opposing principles can expose false one-sided conclusions.
  6. Fragment 405FrenchPride can boast of recognizing the very misery it would otherwise conceal.
  7. Fragment 416FrenchGreatness and misery become evidence for one another.
  8. Fragment 420FrenchThe inquirer is contradicted whether boasting or abasing himself.
  9. Fragment 423FrenchLove and hatred of self are discriminated through capacity and baseness.
  10. Fragment 434FrenchRival philosophical strengths lead into the account of humanity's divided condition.

Translation in this edition

Public disagreement, incompatible claims, and contrary tendencies must remain distinct. At Fragment 384 the first English sentence interprets the French noun through the passive phrase “Being contradicted”; the later sentence retains “Contradiction.” At Fragment 424 contrariétés is “contrarieties,” while the heading at Fragment 125 is “Contradictions.” These local choices do not create a single technical dialectic. Fragment 434 must be read with its reported arguments, questions, and concluding theological claims intact; extracting its skeptical opening alone reverses the movement of the passage.

French forms and English renderings

Contradiction — being contradicted; contradiction [printed form]; contredites — contradicted [printed form]; contrariétés — contrarieties [printed form]; sujet de contradiction — subject of contradiction [phrase]