From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
- The wordNaturalism, in painting, is the close imitation of natural appearances for their own sake.
- In The RenaissanceBotticelli left behind "the simple naturalism which had grown out of" the religion of Giotto's followers, "a thing of birds and flowers only" (BOT §1).
- In this editionThe edition has no note on the word.
- A place to readBOT §1, with BOT §4 and GIO §12.
Meaning
The word is built on natura. In philosophy it named the view that explains everything by nature, without appeal to the supernatural; in the criticism of painting, the effort to set down birds, plants, rocks and faces as they appear. In Pater's own lifetime it would soon become the name of a school of French fiction. In the book it keeps its painter's sense and acquires a historian's: it is a phase of Italian art.
Use in the book
The word occurs twice, and Pater gives it a place in a sequence each time. In the Botticelli essay it follows religion. Botticelli left "the simple religion which had occupied the followers of Giotto for a century, and the simple naturalism which had grown out of it, a thing of birds and flowers only" (BOT §1; see Original sentiment). "Simple" is applied to both, and "only" limits the second: a naturalism of birds and flowers is a naturalism of details, without a mind to unite them. "Grown out of it" makes it the child of the older piety, and it can be read as the devout attention to God's creatures turned into an attention to the creatures alone.
Three paragraphs later Pater grants what Botticelli took from it. He "might have been a mere naturalist" among the naturalists of his generation, and his work keeps "that alert sense of outward things" which fills the lawns of that period's pictures with living creatures (BOT §4; see Naturalist). The alert sense remains; what changes is its use. The visionary "usurps the data" that the naturalist records (BOT §4; see Data), and the birds and reeds can be read as becoming the exponent of a mood (see Exponent).
The Giorgione essay puts the word in another sequence, as one of the burdens of Florentine art. Of the Venetian school Pater writes: "Unassisted, and therefore unperplexed, by naturalism, religious mysticism, philosophical theories, it had no Giotto, no Angelico, no Botticelli" (GIO §12). "Unassisted" and "unperplexed" give naturalism both values at once: it helped the Florentines and it troubled them, and the Venetians, without it, "seem never for a moment to have been so much as tempted" to forget that painting "must be before all things decorative" (GIO §12).
The two passages can be read as one judgement. Naturalism is a means that tempts to become an end. It is necessary, since the visionary needs data, and it is insufficient, since data are not meaning. Pater's account places Botticelli at the point where the means was mastered and refused as an end. The same judgement governs the book's account of Leonardo, whose pictures use their ostensible subject as "the starting-point of a train of sentiment" (LEO §25; see Ostensible subject), and its contrast with Wordsworth's "life in natural things" (PRE §5; see Life in natural things), where nature is never mere birds and flowers because a spirit is felt in it.
Places to read
Both paragraphs in which "naturalism" occurs, with the paragraph on Botticelli's generation of naturalists, in the order of the book.
- BOT §1Botticelli left the simple naturalism that had grown out of the religion of Giotto's followers, a thing of birds and flowers only.
- BOT §4Botticelli lived in a generation of naturalists and might have been a mere naturalist among them.
- GIO §12Venetian painting, unassisted and unperplexed by naturalism, had no Giotto, no Angelico, no Botticelli.
In this edition
The edition has no note on the word.