History, culture and the Renaissance

Liberty of the intellect

liberty of the intellect

Abelard's freedom of thought, as his age understood it

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordLiberty of the intellect is freedom of thought: the mind's right to range over every subject and follow its own reasoning.
  • In The RenaissanceThe name of Abelard "connects the expression of this liberty of heart with the free play of human intelligence around all subjects presented to it, with the liberty of the intellect, as that age understood it" (FRE §2).
  • In this editionThe edition has no note on the phrase; the note at FRE §3 introduces Abelard and his Historia calamitatum.
  • A place to readFRE §2, with FRE §§3–7 on Abelard.

Meaning

"Liberty" is the Latin libertas; "intellect", the Latin intellectus, is the power of understanding. Pater limits it at once: "as that age understood it" warns the reader not to read a modern freedom of thought back into the twelfth century.

Use in the book

The phrase is the second half of a pair. In the poetry of Provence the liberty of the heart makes itself felt, "and the name of Abelard, the great scholar and the great lover, connects the expression of this liberty of heart with the free play of human intelligence around all subjects presented to it, with the liberty of the intellect, as that age understood it" (FRE §2; see Liberty of the heart; Free play). The two liberties meet in one man, Peter Abelard, the twelfth-century philosopher and master of the Paris schools, who is both scholar and lover.

The next paragraphs show what the liberty was. The scholar who sat with Heloïse, the canon's niece and his pupil, "to refine a little further on the nature of abstract ideas" lived "in a world of something like shadows", and for one who could "assign its exact value to every abstract thought, those restraints which lie on the consciences of other men had been relaxed" (FRE §3). The intellect's freedom and the heart's are here one temptation. The historian Jules Michelet sees in Abelard's school "the whole body of scholastic philosophy" and, beyond it, "Arnold of Brescia—that is to say, the revolution" (FRE §4; see Scholastic philosophy). Arnold of Brescia, a preacher against the wealth and temporal power of the clergy, was executed at Rome in 1155. Abelard's treatises try "to find a ground of reality below the abstractions of philosophy, as one bent on trying all things by their congruity with human experience" (FRE §7; see Human experience). And his conflict with authority sets "the true child of light, the humanist", against the hireling ministers of the system (FRE §6; see Humanist).

The phrase can be read as defining the intellect's liberty by its opponent. It is not a right won in law but a temper: one man's reason, heart and senses quick against a system whose ministers' faculties were almost dead (FRE §6; see Humanist). "As that age understood it" keeps the measure honest: Abelard's freedom was to question within the faith, and he died, Pater says, on his way to Rome, his relation to the beliefs of his age left "in this uncertain twilight" (FRE §6; see Uncertain twilight). The end of the essay names what the two liberties became together: "that sinister claim for liberty of heart and thought" (FRE §32; see Antinomianism).

Places to read

The one paragraph in which the phrase occurs, with every other paragraph that names Abelard except FRE §5, on Dante's silence about him.

  1. FRE §2Abelard connects the liberty of the heart with the free play of the intelligence and the liberty of the intellect, as that age understood it.
  2. FRE §3The scholar who refines on abstract ideas with Heloïse finds the restraints on other men's consciences relaxed.
  3. FRE §4Michelet sees at Abelard's school the whole body of scholastic philosophy and, beyond it, the revolution.
  4. FRE §6Abelard, the humanist, against the hireling ministers of the system; his relation to his age left in an uncertain twilight.
  5. FRE §7Abelard tries all things by their congruity with human experience.
  6. FRE §32The antinomian element is found in the history of Abelard; that sinister claim for liberty of heart and thought.
  7. FRE §33The opposition of the defenders of a mere system to the play of mind and character was the secret of Abelard's struggle.

In this edition

The note at FRE §3 identifies Peter Abelard as "a twelfth-century philosopher and theologian", whose account of the affair with Heloïse "survives in the Historia calamitatum", and says that Pater uses the lovers' history "as a point of entry into medieval intellectual and emotional life". The note at FRE §6 says that the French proverb of wheat and acorns "reduces resistance to new intellectual resources to a choice between two staple foods".

Pater's sources

Abelard's freedom was a method as well as a temper. In his Sic et non he set the conflicting sayings of the church's authorities side by side, and wrote in its prologue that by doubting we come to inquiry, and by inquiry we perceive the truth; his teaching was condemned at the councils of Soissons (1121) and Sens (1141). Pater names none of this; his authorities for Abelard are the legend, the letters, Charles de Rémusat, whose Abélard (1845) he quotes on the songs (FRE §3; see Trouvère), and Michelet (FRE §4).1

Source note

1. Abelard, Sic et non, prologue (ed. B. Boyer and R. McKeon, Chicago, 1976–77, pp. 103–104), dubitando quippe ad inquisitionem venimus; inquirendo veritatem percipimus; the councils are recounted in the Historia calamitatum (Soissons) and in the letters of Bernard of Clairvaux (Sens).