Art and its materials

Impassivity

impassivity; impassive

The stillness beneath the surface of Greek sculpture, over which passion plays without disturbing it, and which in the end has a touch of the corpse

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordThe state of being unmoved by passion or feeling; outward calm that shows no emotion.
  • In The RenaissanceThe Hellenic ideal lets passion play over the surface of the form, "losing thereby nothing of its central impassivity, its depth and repose" (WIN §38).
  • In this editionThe edition has no note on the word.
  • A place to readWIN §§38, 45.

Meaning

Impassive is formed from passive, the Latin passivus, capable of suffering (from pati, to suffer), and the negative in-: unable to suffer, unmoved. Christian theology taught that God cannot suffer change, and that the bodies of the blessed after the resurrection will be impassible, beyond the reach of harm.1 Pater does not mention either, but his word keeps something of both: impassivity in the essay is a godlike quality, and a quality of bodies that have passed beyond life.

Use in the book

The word first comes in the Botticelli essay, where it is a fault. Giotto, Masaccio and Ghirlandajo, who transcribe the outward image, are "almost impassive spectators of the action before them" (BOT §4; see Dramatic painter). Impassivity there is the indifference of the transcriber, who sees without being moved, against Botticelli's visionary sympathy.

The Winckelmann essay turns it into a virtue. Under the law of restraint, Greek sculpture keeps passion below the pitch at which it must be transitory (WIN §38; see Law of restraint). "It allows passion to play lightly over the surface of the individual form, losing thereby nothing of its central impassivity, its depth and repose" (WIN §38). The sentence can be read as an image of water: a breeze moves the surface of a deep pool and leaves its depths still. Impassivity is not the absence of passion but its place, at the surface, while the centre of the figure stays at rest. The sentence that follows names the price: to all but the highest culture the reserved faces of the gods "will ever have something of insipidity" (WIN §38; see Higher culture). Impassivity looks like dullness to an eye that has not learned to see the movement on the surface.

The forty-fifth paragraph then turns the word against the Greeks. The "supreme and colourless abstraction" of the gods, the secret of their repose, is also "a premonition" of medieval art (WIN §45; see Abstraction). "That high indifference to the outward, that impassivity, has already a touch of the corpse in it" (WIN §45), and Pater sees in it Angelico and an anonymous medieval painter he calls the Master of the Passion to come (WIN §45; see High indifference). The godlike stillness, carried one step further, becomes the stillness of death, and the Greek statue already foreshadows "the ascetic interest" of medieval art (WIN §45; see Shutting the eyes).

The two uses can be read as the essay's whole judgement on Greek sculpture in one word. Impassivity is its depth and its danger: it lets the statue hold passion without being carried away by it, and it is the first step toward the refusal of passion altogether. The essay does not resolve the double value, and can be read as wanting both kept in view. The impassive face is the perfection of the Hellenic ideal and the sign that it will pass.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "impassive" or "impassivity" occurs, in the order of the book.

  1. BOT §4Giotto, Masaccio and Ghirlandaio are dramatic, not visionary painters, almost impassive spectators of the action before them.
  2. WIN §38Passion plays lightly over the surface of the Hellenic form, which loses nothing of its central impassivity.
  3. WIN §45That high indifference to the outward, that impassivity, has already a touch of the corpse in it.

Source note

1. Thomas Aquinas, Summa theologiae I, q. 9, a. 1 (God's immutability); Supplement (compiled after his death from his commentary on the Sentences), q. 82, a. 1 (the impassibility of the bodies of the blessed).