Time, flux and the moment

Formlessness

formlessness; formless

The state before life and after death, into which the body relapses and from which the spirit is imagined rising

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordThe state of having no form: shapelessness, the absence of definite outline.
  • In The RenaissanceMichelangelo is the poet of "dumb inquiry over the relapse after death into the formlessness which preceded life" (MIC §20).
  • In this editionThe edition has no note on the word.
  • A place to readMIC §20.

Meaning

In Aristotle's philosophy, which Pater read at Oxford, form is what makes a thing what it is, and matter without form is mere potentiality. Formlessness is thus the condition of matter before it is shaped, and the condition to which a shaped thing returns when it dissolves. Applied to a life, it names the state before birth and after death, when the body that was a form becomes dust again.

Use in the book

The word's chief passage is the last sentence of the Michelangelo essay's account of his thoughts of death, which gathers the whole range of feeling the Medici tombs express: "And of all that range of sentiment he is the poet, a poet still alive, and in possession of our inmost thoughts—dumb inquiry over the relapse after death into the formlessness which preceded life, the change, the revolt from that change, then the correcting, hallowing, consoling rush of pity" (MIC §20; see Hallow); and at last, far off, comes the new body, a passing light "over those too rigid, or too formless faces" (MIC §20; see New body).

The sentence is a sequence of states of mind, and formlessness stands at its start. The first is "dumb inquiry": the mind asking, without words, what death is. Its object is "the relapse after death into the formlessness which preceded life", the body sinking back into the shapeless matter from which it came. "Relapse" makes death a falling back, as a patient relapses; "which preceded life" makes the formlessness the same at both ends. Then come "the change, the revolt from that change", the shock of the dissolution and the mind's refusal of it, and then pity. At the end, far off, the new body, imagined as "a passing light" over "those too rigid, or too formless faces". The dead faces are either too rigid, fixed in death, or too formless, already dissolving.

The word joins the end of the Michelangelo essay to its beginning. The essay's first subject is the creation of life "in the cold and lifeless stone" (MIC §3; see Creation of life), "always in strong contrast with the rough-hewn mass in which it is kindled" (MIC §4; see Rough-hewn mass). The formlessness that precedes life is that mass, the uncut stone; the relapse after death is the return to it. Michelangelo's art, on this reading, works at the two edges of form: the half-emergent figure rising from the block (see Half-emergent form) and the dead face sinking back. The unfinished state of so much of his sculpture can be read as the formlessness out of which and into which his figures pass.

"Formless" occurs twice elsewhere, both of earlier, ruder stages of art and religion. The old French chanson was "often, in its essence, something rude and formless" until Ronsard made it a Pindaric ode (BEL §4); around the feet of the Olympian gods "still crowd the weary shadows of an earlier, more formless, divine world" (WIN §45). In both, formlessness is what comes before, and form is the achievement of art. The Michelangelo essay adds that it is also what comes after.

The word can be read as the darkest in the book's vocabulary of time. The Conclusion describes a world in which "all melts under our feet" and every form is passing (CON §5); its counsel is to seize the form while it is perfect. The Michelangelo essay looks at the other side of that counsel: the formlessness before and after, which the art of the Medici chapel neither denies nor consoles, but contemplates, in "vague and wistful speculation" (MIC §20; see Wistful speculation).

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "formlessness" or "formless" occurs, in the order of the book.

  1. MIC §20Michelangelo is the poet of dumb inquiry over the relapse after death into the formlessness which preceded life.
  2. BEL §4The old French chanson was often something rude and formless, until Ronsard made it a Pindaric ode.
  3. WIN §45Around the Olympian family crowd the weary shadows of an earlier, more formless, divine world.