Religion, myth and the sacred

Death in its distinction

death in its distinction; death in its high distinction

Death seen not as horror but as dignity, the Florentine tradition that Michelangelo carried to its height

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordDistinction is the quality of being set apart, and so noble or eminent; death in its distinction is death seen as a dignity rather than a degradation.
  • In The RenaissanceThe Florentine masters "came thus to see death in its distinction" (MIC §19).
  • In this editionThe edition has no note on the phrase; the note on the cardinal's epitaph at MIC §19 renders insignis formâ fui et mirabili modestiâ "I was distinguished in appearance and of remarkable modesty".
  • A place to readMIC §§15, 19.

Meaning

"Distinction" is from the Latin distinguere, to set apart, and in English it came to mean both difference and eminence: a man of distinction is one set above others. Death, the common lot, seems the opposite of distinction: it levels all ranks, as the Danse Macabre showed (see Danse Macabre). Pater's phrase gives it the other sense, a dignity that sets the dead apart from the living and from their own past selves.

Use in the book

The phrase occurs twice, first in the fifteenth paragraph of the Michelangelo essay, at the end of the account of his likeness to Dante. Michelangelo introduces "Love and Death, who dispute concerning him" (MIC §15; see Amor). "For, like Dante and all the nobler souls of Italy, he is much occupied with thoughts of the grave, and his true mistress is death,—death at first as the worst of all sorrows and disgraces, with a clod of the field for its brain; afterwards, death in its high distinction, its detachment from vulgar needs, the angry stains of life and action escaping fast" (MIC §15; see Detachment). The sentence tells a change of feeling. At first death is disgrace, the body become earth, "a clod of the field for its brain"; afterwards it is "high distinction", the release from need and from "the angry stains of life and action".

The nineteenth paragraph gives the phrase its history. All the great Florentines, it has been said, were preoccupied with death (MIC §19; see Outre-tombe), and Pater finds the seriousness of the great Florentines "partly due" to "this inherited sentiment, this practical decision that to be preoccupied with the thought of death was in itself dignifying, and a note of high quality" (MIC §19). The sentiment was "reinforced in them by the actual sorrows of their times": Simonetta borne to the grave with uncovered face, the young Cardinal of Portugal in his tomb at San Miniato, whose epitaph "dares to say" that he was "distinguished in appearance and of remarkable modesty" (MIC §19; see Sepulchral portrait). Such a preoccupation might have become "merely morbid or grotesque", as it did in the north (MIC §19; see Danse Macabre). From that result the Florentine masters were saved by their culture, "and still more by their tender pity for the thing itself" (MIC §19; see Pity).

The paragraph then reaches the phrase. "They must often have leaned over the lifeless body, when all was at length quiet and smoothed out" (MIC §19), and they saw that after death "only the abstract lines remain, in a great indifference" (MIC §19; see Abstract line). "They came thus to see death in its distinction." The distinction is the face's new dignity, the slighter dispositions gone and the lines "more simple and dignified". It is learned by looking, with pity, at the dead.

The two passages can be read as one movement, told once of a man and once of a tradition. Michelangelo's feeling about death passes from disgrace to distinction; the Florentines, by culture and pity, had made the same passage before him. He is "the inheritor" of that tradition and gives it "the final expression" in the sacristy of San Lorenzo (MIC §19; see Outre-tombe). The next sentence of the paragraph adds the limit: following death "perhaps one stage further", the Florentines "paused just in time, and abstained, with a sentiment of profound pity" (MIC §19; see New body). Death in its distinction is the last thing they let themselves see.

It is tempting to see in the phrase Pater's answer to the morbid. The northern art of death dwelt on corruption; the Florentine art dwelt on the moment before it, when the dead face is most noble. The Conclusion, written in the same years, speaks of the "awful brevity" of experience (CON §5) and of the form that "grows perfect in hand or face" for a moment only (CON §4). The face that death distinguishes is the last of those forms.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which death is seen in its distinction, in the order of the book.

  1. MIC §15Michelangelo's true mistress is death, first as disgrace, afterwards in its high distinction, its detachment from vulgar needs.
  2. MIC §19The Florentine masters, saved from the morbid by culture and pity, must often have leaned over the lifeless body, and came to see death in its distinction.

In this edition

The note at MIC §19 renders the cardinal's epitaph, insignis formâ fui et mirabili modestiâ, "I was distinguished in appearance and of remarkable modesty", and says that "Pater uses the epitaph of the Portuguese cardinal at San Miniato al Monte to illustrate how a monument could remember physical beauty alongside a virtue".