History, culture and the Renaissance

Convulsive energy

convulsive energy

The violent force that marks medieval art off from classical work, which some critics took for the whole of Michelangelo

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordConvulsive is seized by violent, involuntary spasms; a convulsive energy is a force that breaks out in jerks and strains rather than flowing evenly.
  • In The RenaissanceMedieval art is distinguished from classical work by "the presence of a convulsive energy in it" (MIC §2).
  • In this editionThe edition has no note on the phrase.
  • A place to readMIC §2, with MIC §1.

Meaning

The Latin convellere is to tear up or wrench, and convulsio, in the medical Latin that gave English the word, is a cramp or spasm. Convulsive things move by violent contraction: a convulsive sob, a convulsive grip. Joined to energy, which in Pater is the force of a nature or a work (see Energy of conception), the adjective names force that is not mastered, that strains against its own limits and shows the strain.

Use in the book

The phrase stands in the first sentence of the second paragraph of the Michelangelo essay, which reports the view of the critics who see only strength in him: "In this way he sums up for them the whole character of medieval art itself in that which distinguishes it most clearly from classical work, the presence of a convulsive energy in it, becoming in lower hands merely monstrous or forbidding, and felt, even in its most graceful products, as a subdued quaintness or grotesque" (MIC §2; see Grotesque; Quaintness).

The sentence is a history of art in a clause. Classical work is balanced and self-contained, as the Greek ideal of the Winckelmann essay is (see Allgemeinheit); medieval work is driven by a force that will not stay within its forms. In lesser hands that force produces the "monstrous or forbidding", the gargoyle and the demon; in the finest it remains as a trace, "a subdued quaintness or grotesque", a strangeness in the line even of a graceful thing. To the critics of strength, Michelangelo is the sum of that tradition: medieval energy at its height.

Pater can be read as accepting the history and correcting its application. The sentence is framed by "for them": it is the strength-only critics who sum Michelangelo up so. The next sentence turns: "Yet those who feel this grace or sweetness in Michelangelo might at the first moment be puzzled if they were asked wherein precisely such quality resided" (MIC §2). The essay answers it three paragraphs later, and finds the sweetness not in accessories but in "this penetrative suggestion of life" (MIC §5; see Brooding spirit of life). The energy of conception of the first paragraph, which "seems at every moment about to break through all the conditions of comely form" (MIC §1; see Energy of conception), can be read as this convulsive energy mastered: what the critics miss is that it only seems about to break through.

The phrase belongs to a view of the middle age that runs through the book. In the della Robbia essay the Tuscan system relieves the intensity that "might otherwise have stiffened into caricature" (ROB §11; see Caricature). Convulsive energy can be read as what that relief and the Greek abstraction tame. The phrase may be taken as Pater's name for the medieval inheritance that the Renaissance had to master rather than discard, the force of the Gothic that became, in Michelangelo, a strength under discipline.

Places to read

The phrase occurs once.

  1. MIC §2Medieval art is distinguished from classical work by a convulsive energy, monstrous in lower hands, a subdued grotesque in the most graceful.

Pater's sources

Pater names no source for the phrase. The nearest English account of the quality is John Ruskin's chapter "The Nature of Gothic" in The Stones of Venice (1853), which makes grotesqueness the fourth of the six characteristics of Gothic and praises "that strange disquietude of the Gothic spirit".1 Pater's adjective can be read as weighing the same quality differently: where Ruskin praised the restless energy of the Gothic, "convulsive" makes it a spasm, one that the Tuscan sculptors relieved and Michelangelo held in check.

Source note

1. John Ruskin, The Stones of Venice, vol. II (1853), ch. VI, "The Nature of Gothic", §§6, 40.