Religion, myth and the sacred

Conventional associations

conventional associations; traditional associations

The meanings that custom gives a sacred subject, beyond which Leonardo's art carries it

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordThe ideas and feelings that a subject brings with it by long custom, as the Last Supper brings the Eucharist.
  • In The RenaissanceThe given subject "is often merely the pretext for a kind of work which carries one altogether beyond the range of its conventional associations" (LEO §25).
  • In this editionThe edition has no note on the phrase; the note at LEO §25 records the Louvre's present attribution of the Bacchus.
  • A place to readLEO §25, with LEO §27.

Meaning

"Association" was a central word of the psychology of Pater's century, which held that ideas become joined by habit, so that one calls up the other. The Scottish essayist Archibald Alison had made it the ground of taste: an object is beautiful, he argued, through the train of associated ideas it awakens in the mind.1 "Conventional" means fixed by agreement or custom (see Conventionalism). The conventional associations of a subject are thus the ideas it calls up for everyone who shares a custom: the Baptist calls up the wilderness and repentance, the Last Supper the sacrament of the altar.

Use in the book

Pater draws the phrase from one picture's history. The paragraph has followed the Saint John of the Louvre through its copies, in which the reedlike cross "becomes faint" and at last "disappears altogether", after which the original's likeness to the Bacchus that hangs near it no longer surprises (LEO §25; see Decayed gods). Pater draws the conclusion: "No one ever ruled over the mere subject in hand more entirely than Leonardo, or bent it more dexterously to purely artistic ends. And so it comes to pass that though he handles sacred subjects continually, he is the most profane of painters; the given person or subject, Saint John in the Desert, or the Virgin on the knees of Saint Anne, is often merely the pretext for a kind of work which carries one altogether beyond the range of its conventional associations" (LEO §25; see Sacred and profane). "Pretext" is a strong word, and "merely" stronger: the subject is the occasion, and the work goes elsewhere. Where it goes the paragraph has already said. The Saint John is one of those "symbolical inventions" whose subject is "the starting-point of a train of sentiment, subtle and vague as a piece of music" (LEO §25; see Symbolical invention). The associations of custom give way to a train of sentiment that belongs to the painter alone.

The phrase returns, changed, two paragraphs later, at the Last Supper: "Here was another effort to lift a given subject out of the range of its traditional associations." The effort, Pater says, was strange after "all the mystic developments of the middle age": to see the Eucharist "as one taking leave of his friends" (LEO §27; see Consecrated Host). "Traditional" weighs more than "conventional": the Eucharist carries centuries of doctrine and devotion, "the mystic developments of the middle age". And the direction differs. The Saint John is carried "beyond" his associations into a sentiment that drifts toward the pagan; the Last Supper is lifted "out of" its associations into a human scene, a farewell among friends. Pater compares the Last Supper painted at Florence "five years afterwards" by the young Raphael, "with sweet and solemn effect" but "still with all the mystical unreality of the school of Perugino" (LEO §27); that picture, then given to Raphael, is now usually given to Pietro Perugino (about 1450–1523), Raphael's master, and his workshop.2

The two passages can be read together as the essay's account of a profane art made from sacred matter. In each the subject is kept and its customary meaning set aside, and in each the result is what Pater values: a work ruled entirely by "purely artistic ends". The Giorgione essay gives the principle its general form, in which all art strives that the mere matter of a picture "should be nothing without the form, the spirit, of the handling" (GIO §5; see End in itself). The Leonardo essay shows it at work on the most heavily freighted matter there is, and the word "profane" names the cost without condemning it.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "conventional associations" or "traditional associations" occurs, in the order of the book; "associations" alone (WIN §§22, 37) is not listed.

  1. LEO §25Though Leonardo handles sacred subjects continually, the subject is often a pretext for work that goes beyond its conventional associations.
  2. LEO §27The Last Supper lifts a given subject out of its traditional associations, and sees the Eucharist as one taking leave of his friends.

Source note

1. Archibald Alison, Essays on the Nature and Principles of Taste (1790), Essay I.

2. The Last Supper in the former convent of Sant'Onofrio (the Cenacolo di Fuligno), Florence, now catalogued as the work of Perugino and his workshop.