From the book
The Renaissance
Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026
Browse this book’s lexicon →Orientation
At a Glance
- The wordThe discipline of the body practised for the sake of the spirit: fasting, watching, chastity, the renunciation of pleasure.
- In The RenaissanceAgainst the Greek indifference to sense stands Christian asceticism, whose intoxication Winckelmann escaped (WIN §43).
- In this editionThe note at WIN §43 says that Jonathan's words supply Pater "with a figure for the religious prohibition of even a small sensory pleasure".
- A place to readWIN §43.
Meaning
The Greek askēsis was the training of the athlete before it was the discipline of the monk (see Ascêsis). The Christian ascetic took the athlete's word for a war on the body: the desert fathers, the monastic rules and the saints of the middle age made renunciation of the senses the road to the spirit. In the nineteenth century the word carried a judgement. Pater does not name them here, but for his generation, after Matthew Arnold's "Hebraism"1 and the debates over Newman and the Oxford Movement, asceticism named the side of Christianity that set the soul against the flesh, and it was the side that Jules Michelet, in his Renaissance (1855), saw the Renaissance as escaping.2
Use in the book
The phrase stands in the forty-third paragraph of the Winckelmann essay, which defines Winckelmann's serenity by what it lacked. Greek sensuousness "does not fever the conscience: it is shameless and childlike" (WIN §43). Against it Christian asceticism, "discrediting the slightest touch of sense", has from time to time provoked the artistic life into opposition (WIN §43), and Pater sets down the words of Jonathan from the Book of Samuel, who tasted a little honey and was condemned to die for it (WIN §43; see Sensuousness). The consequence is the artist's dilemma. "It has sometimes seemed hard to pursue that life without something of conscious disavowal of a spiritual world; and this imparts to genuine artistic interests a kind of intoxication. From this intoxication Winckelmann is free: he fingers those pagan marbles with unsinged hands, with no sense of shame or loss" (WIN §43).
The argument is subtle and the essay keeps it so. Asceticism does not destroy the sensuous; it inflames it. By forbidding the slightest touch of sense, it makes every touch a defiance, and the artist who loves the senses in a Christian world loves them with the excitement of a rebel. That excitement, the intoxication of the forbidden, is what the essay can be read as diagnosing in the Renaissance and in Pater's own century. Winckelmann escaped it. His hands are "unsinged" because the fire was never lit: he handled the pagan marbles as a pagan would, "with no sense of shame or loss", and that is to deal with the sensuous side of art "in the pagan manner" (WIN §43). The paradox, it can be read, is that the convert to Rome is the essay's pagan.
The ascetic returns twice more, each time as the observer of a change he cannot stop. The supreme abstraction of the Greek gods is already "a premonition of the fleshless, consumptive refinements of the pale, medieval artists", and "the ascetic interest" may be foreseen in them (WIN §45; see Shutting the eyes). Asceticism is thus not only Christianity's; it is latent in the Greek ideal itself, in the impassive and colourless form. And when the relics of the antique were restored, "in the view of the Christian ascetic it was as if an ancient plague-pit had been opened" (WIN §47; see Plague-pit), and all the world "took the contagion of the life of nature and of the senses" (WIN §47; see Contagion). The essay can be read as tracing a single history through these places: an asceticism foreshadowed in Greek art and dominant in the middle age, and a Renaissance continuous with it, since the medieval spirit, by withdrawing interest from art "and yet keeping unbroken the thread of its traditions", had let the mind rest until the ancient forms returned (WIN §47).
The book's other words for the same discipline are milder. The Preface praised the earliest phases of the Renaissance for "the charm of ascêsis, of the austere and serious girding of the loins in youth" (PRE §6; see Ascêsis), a discipline that serves art, and Pater's later writings would make that ascêsis an ideal of style.3 The Christian asceticism of the Winckelmann essay is the other kind, the discipline that serves the soul against the body, and the essay's judgement of it is not hostility but distance.
Places to read
Every paragraph in which "ascetic" or "asceticism" occurs, in the order of the book.
- WIN §43Christian asceticism, discrediting the slightest touch of sense, has provoked the artistic life into opposition.
- WIN §45The suppression of the sensuous, the ascetic interest, may be foreseen in the Greek gods' abstraction.
- WIN §47To the Christian ascetic the restoration of the antique was as if a plague-pit had been opened.
Source note
1. Matthew Arnold, Culture and Anarchy (London, 1869), ch. 4, "Hebraism and Hellenism".
2. Jules Michelet, Histoire de France au seizième siècle: Renaissance (Paris, 1855), introduction.
3. Walter Pater, "Style", in Appreciations (London, 1889): "Self-restraint, a skilful economy of means, ascêsis, that too has a beauty of its own".