Criticism and method

Æsthetic value

æsthetic value; an æsthetic as distinct from an historical value

The worth a work has as art, which the history of its age can neither give it nor take away

From the book

The Renaissance

Walter Pater · Diotimos Editions · 2026

Browse this book’s lexicon →

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The wordThe worth of a thing as a source of the pleasure proper to art, as against its worth as a record of the time that made it.
  • In The RenaissanceA poet's work, to have the highest interest, must have "an æsthetic as distinct from an historical value" (BEL §21).
  • In this editionThe Glossary defines "Aesthetic" as "Pertaining to sense, perception, or the qualities felt in art", and adds that "The exact emphasis depends on the passage."
  • A place to readBEL §§3, 21.

Meaning

Value is worth, what a thing is good for or how much it counts; "æsthetic" ties the worth to perception and the pleasure that comes through it. An æsthetic value is the worth a work has for one who looks at it or reads it now, as art. Pater sets it against two other kinds of worth that a work may have, the antiquarian and the historical, which belong to the past it records and can be real without it.

Use in the book

The phrase is first a test. In the first essay Pater grants that antiquarianism may add to the charm of an old text, but only on a condition: unless some purely artistic quality went to its making, "no merely antiquarian effort can ever give it an æsthetic value" (FRE §23; see Æsthetic charm). Æsthetic value cannot be lent by scholarship. It must have gone into the making, and the critic can only find it there.

The essay on Joachim du Bellay, the sixteenth-century French poet, applies the test twice, and the two verdicts differ. The first is given to a manner. When Pierre de Ronsard, the leading poet of the Pleiad, doubles French daintiness by Italian finesse, "nearly all the force and all the seriousness of French work disappear" (BEL §3; see Finesse), and what remains is elegance. Pater sets a value against the loss: "But this elegance, this manner, this daintiness of execution are consummate, and have an unmistakable æsthetic value" (BEL §3). The "But" turns a list of losses into a judgement of worth. A style that has lost nearly all its force and all its seriousness can still have an æsthetic value, because its execution is consummate.

The second verdict is given to a poet, and it asks more. Du Bellay's chief interest, Pater says, is that he is "a characteristic specimen of the poetical taste of that age" (BEL §21). That is an historical interest, and it is not enough: "But if his work is to have the highest sort of interest, if it is to do something more than satisfy curiosity, if it is to have an æsthetic as distinct from an historical value, it is not enough for a poet to have been the true child of his age, to have conformed to its æsthetic conditions, and by so conforming to have charmed and stimulated that age; it is necessary that there should be perceptible in his work something individual, inventive, unique, the impress there of the writer's own temper and personality" (BEL §21). The age's own "æsthetic conditions" produce only historical value; æsthetic value, in the higher sense, needs a temper of the poet's own. The French critic Sainte-Beuve found that impress in the Antiquités de Rome and the Regrets; Pater, though he thinks the critic may have exaggerated it, finds in the Regrets the intimacy of a homesick man (BEL §21; see Intimité; Home-sickness).

The two passages can be read as marking two levels. A manner may have æsthetic value of its own, as the Pleiad's elegance has; a poet has the highest value only when his own impress is on the manner. The paragraph that lets Du Bellay's poetry stand as "part of the manner of a time" (BEL §13; see À la mode) makes the same distinction from the other side: "everything that has style, that has been done as no other man or age could have done it, as it could never, for all our trying, be done again, has its true value and interest" (BEL §13; see Style). "No other man or age": the value of style can belong to a person or to a period, and the essay values both, while ranking the person higher.

The test can be read as the Preface's, carried into history. The æsthetic critic asks of each work what it is "to me" (PRE §2; see Æsthetic criticism), and of each period, "In whom did the stir, the genius, the sentiment of the period find itself?" (PRE §4). The Du Bellay essay can be read as Pater's clearest demonstration that the two interests can be told apart in the same poems. The poetry of the Pleiad has much of the historian's interest and some of the critic's; the winnower's song, which ends the essay, has "in the highest degree, the qualities, the value, of the whole Pleiad school of poetry" (BEL §28; see Pure effect), a grace of fancy nearly all the pleasure of which lies in the dexterous handling of a thing slight in itself.

Places to read

Every paragraph in which "æsthetic value" or "an æsthetic as distinct from an historical value" occurs, with BEL §§13 and 28, where the value of the Pleiad's style is named, in the order of the book.

  1. FRE §23No merely antiquarian effort can give an old work an æsthetic value unless some artistic quality went to its making.
  2. BEL §3The Pleiad's elegance, manner and daintiness of execution are consummate and have an unmistakable æsthetic value.
  3. BEL §13Everything that has style, done as no other man or age could have done it, has its true value and interest.
  4. BEL §21To have an æsthetic as distinct from an historical value, a poet's work must bear the impress of his own temper.
  5. BEL §28The winnower's song has in the highest degree the qualities and value of the whole Pleiad school.