Philosophy
You Can’t Screenshot a Charm
A joke about taking notes opens a larger question about what a teacher can give a student.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesWhen Socrates mentions a charm, Charmides’ first instinct is to write it down. By the end he’s asking Socrates to charm him every day. What did the boy discover that a copy would leave out?
Orientation
At a Glance
- A request to copyCharmides wants to write down the charm. Socrates asks whether the boy means to persuade him to share it, and Charmides laughs and agrees to try.
- Persuasion and obedienceThe same Greek verb links the boy’s attempt to persuade Socrates with Socrates’ promise to obey the Thracian healer. The healer’s terms require the patient to agree to treatment of the soul.
- What writing can doThe Phaedrus gives writing a place as a reminder. A new question takes someone who can listen and reply.
- A daily practiceBy the end, Charmides asks Socrates to charm him every day. Critias makes the proposal into an order, giving an edge to the earlier talk about persuasion.
Charmides 155a, 155e–156b, 157a–b, 157b–c, 161b–c, 161d–162a, 162b–d, 175e–176a, 176a–d · Phaedrus 274c–e, 274e–275c, 275c–276a, 276b–e, 276e–277a
The moment Socrates explains that his headache remedy comes with a charm, Charmides knows exactly what to do. “Then I’ll copy the charm down from you,” he says, the way a student today might snap a picture of a lecture slide or save a workout plan to his phone. “If you persuade me,” Socrates answers, “or even if you don’t?” and the boy laughs and says, “If I persuade you, Socrates,” which suggests he has caught on to the game at once. He has just been asked to do something more than reach for a pen. It’s the most natural request in the world, and it’s the wrong one.
The boy’s instinct is revealing. He seems to assume the charm is a piece of text, a formula he can take home and use whenever his head hurts. On that picture wisdom is something you can own, store and carry around, like a recipe card, and the person who gave it to you is no longer needed once you’ve got the words down on paper. Critias has called Charmides a poet, so a way with words is already part of his reputation.
Socrates’ reply moves the whole transaction from copying to persuading. The charm doesn’t pass from one person to another by dictation but by agreement, and the word for persuading comes back a page later when Socrates explains his oath to the Thracian, who made him promise that no one, however rich or wellborn or beautiful, should persuade him to give the remedy without first treating the soul, and that Socrates, bound by the oath, will obey. In Greek these forms of the same verb can mean persuading someone and, in the middle voice, obeying someone. The charm lives inside a little web of persuasion and promises. The doctor’s terms require a patient willing to hand over his soul for treatment.
Then Socrates explains what the charm actually is, and the explanation settles the question of copying. The charms, he says, “are beautiful words,” and from words like these temperance comes to be in souls. The Greek word here, epōdē, can mean an incantation sung over someone. You could copy the words of a song like that and still have to find someone to sing it. And if the charm is the conversation Socrates goes on to have, the patient has a part in it, too. Charmides has to answer for himself.
Plato has a famous story about exactly this worry. In the Phaedrus, the Egyptian god Theuth presents his invention of writing to the king Thamus as a medicine for memory and wisdom, and the king answers that it will produce forgetfulness and the appearance of wisdom instead of the real thing. Socrates adds that written words are like paintings that look alive but can’t answer when you question them, saying the same thing over and over and always needing their author to come to their rescue, which is a perfect description of a charm copied down without the person who knows how to use it. Socrates does give writing a place as a reminder for someone who already knows. Plato, ironically, wrote all of this down, but he wrote it as dialogue, where the words at least pretend to answer each other.
The boy’s habit of copying shows up again later, and this time it costs him. His third definition of temperance comes straight from somebody else, as he admits, “something I once heard someone say,” and he has trouble explaining it once Socrates starts asking what it means. Socrates says that who supplied the definition makes no difference. The thing to find out is whether it’s true. A borrowed definition can get the conversation going, but its speaker still has to work out what the words are for.
By the last page the boy seems to have learned the lesson. He doesn’t ask for a copy of anything anymore. Instead he says he needs the charm and wants to be “charmed by you every day, until you say it’s enough,” which is the difference between downloading something once and signing up for a practice you have to keep showing up for. The charm turns out to be the kind of thing you can only have by doing it, regularly and with somebody, the way fluency in a language takes actually showing up and talking. Then Critias turns the proposal into an order, and Charmides jokes about using force on Socrates. There’s a sharp edge to that ending in a dialogue that began by asking who could persuade whom.
My verdict is that the boy’s request to copy the charm shows what he thought learning was, and the rest of the dialogue shows him something better. A practice whose effect depends on taking part can’t be written down and carried off, and the Charmides ends with a young man asking to go on talking. Whether it makes him temperate is still open. He has at least discovered a reason to come back.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author regard Charmides’ initial request to copy the charm as mistaken?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If learning depends on active participation and questioning, what legitimate role can written material still play in that process?→
- How does the movement from persuasion to orders and joking threats complicate the dialogue’s picture of voluntary philosophical practice?→
- What would count as evidence that the ongoing conversations have actually made Charmides temperate, and why does the article leave that outcome unresolved?→