Philosophy
Why Socrates Keeps His Answer Back
Critias asks whether Socrates agrees. Socrates keeps the discussion on what Critias has proposed, which makes the answer easier to test and the examiner harder to challenge.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesSocrates puts off saying what he thinks so that Critias can explain his definition of temperance. Plato shows what this move can teach and why it can feel unfair.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Critias asks for agreementCritias asks whether Socrates shares his view that temperance consists in doing good things. Socrates asks to hear and examine Critias’ proposal first.
- Why wait to give an answer?An early endorsement might make a proposal feel settled. By withholding his answer, Socrates gives Critias a chance to say what he means and test whether it holds up.
- Why it can feel unfairThrasymachus objects in the Republic that Socrates is quick to challenge other people’s answers while withholding his own. A participant can reasonably want the examiner’s claims tested too.
- A hunch stays a hunchSocrates says he expects temperance to benefit us. That expectation guides what he asks Critias to show while leaving the definition open.
The moment is small but revealing, and it’s easy to read past. Socrates has just asked whether the man who does bad things isn’t temperate, but the one who does good things, and Critias, sensing an ally, throws the question back, “And don’t you think so, my good fellow?” Socrates won’t take the bait, though agreeing would have been the friendly thing to do. “Never mind that,” he says. “Let’s not look yet at what I think, but at what you are saying now.” A few pages later he does the same thing more emphatically, refusing to be treated as though he knew the answers or would agree with Critias “if only I want to.” It’s a refusal that sets the terms for the rest of the conversation.
The first effect of withholding his view is to keep the test on the proposal. If Socrates had simply agreed, it would have been easy to take their agreement as the end of the matter. Instead, he leaves the question with Critias, who puts his definition plainly. Temperance is doing good things. Socrates can now ask whether the definition can account for a doctor whose treatment helps without his realizing that it has.
Withholding also makes it harder for an answerer to defer to the questioner. Once you hear someone’s preferred answer, it can be tempting to work backward from it, especially if the person asking the question has a reputation for being clever. The dialogue gives us no reason to think Critias is simply trying to please Socrates here. What it does give us is a clean view of Critias’ own proposal. He has to say what he means before either of them can find out what follows from it.
This is a familiar move in teaching, and it’s harder than it looks. A teacher may ask students to work through a problem and give their reasons before she weighs in. If she announces her own conclusion too early, she may get correct answers that tell her very little about what anyone understands. Even a raised eyebrow from the person at the front of the room can change what people are willing to say. There’s a reason to hold the answer back when hearing the reasoning is the point.
But withholding has costs, and Plato knew them well. In the Republic, Thrasymachus bursts into the conversation in a fury. He accuses Socrates of asking questions and refuting answers because it’s easier than giving an answer himself. He calls Socrates’ refusal his familiar irony and takes it as a way of avoiding exposure. The complaint has some force. The person whose definition is in play has a lot more to defend, while the examiner has yet to put a definition of his own within reach. Plato gives the complaint to an angry character and still lets it land.
In the Theaetetus, Socrates likens himself to a midwife who can help other people bring forth their ideas and test them. He says he has no wisdom of his own to bring to birth. In the Charmides he does share one thing he expects of temperance. He has a “prophetic hunch that temperance is something beneficial and good.” A hunch can guide his questions while leaving room for Critias to develop his answer. In the end, Socrates’ own failure to find a satisfactory account is part of what he has to face.
What do the participants lose when an examiner refuses to supply a rival account? They lose a positive guide. They can leave a conversation with a pile of rubble, which is roughly how the Charmides ends. A pile of rubble can be the start of a better building, but only if someone stays to build. They also lose the chance to test a rival view, which might be just as weak as theirs. That asymmetry can feel unfair, as Thrasymachus’ outburst shows.
My verdict is that withholding his answer is one of the most important features of Socrates’ method. It gives Critias room to say what he means and leaves the proposal open to examination. There’s a cost in guidance and in what each man has to defend. Here Socrates does put his expectation about temperance on the table. He lets a hunch guide the test and gives Critias the chance to tell him what temperance is.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does Socrates initially withhold agreement with Critias about temperance?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When does withholding one’s own answer promote independent reasoning, and when might it become an unfair way to avoid scrutiny?→
- If an inquiry ends with the participants’ original views dismantled but no positive account in their place, what—if anything—has the inquiry accomplished?→
- How much guidance can an examiner provide before the answerer begins adapting ideas to the examiner’s expectations rather than expressing and testing an independent view?→