Philosophy
Whose Business Is It?
A father wants to keep driving. His children disagree about whether they should intervene. Socrates’ questions about minding one’s own business give the family a better place to start.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesThe maxim sounds clear until a decision affects more than one person. Plato and Mill give different ways to ask where one person’s business ends.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The family disagrees over the keysThe father wants to keep his independence. One child is worried about the danger of driving, and the other wants the decision left to him.
- The maxim leaves a question openSocrates asks what belongs to each person in a city whose people make and do things for one another. The rule depends on an answer to that question.
- Mill asks who could be harmedMill distinguishes a person’s freedom to take risks for himself from conduct that puts others at risk. Driving on public roads brings both concerns into view.
- Relationships matter tooThe father has a stake in his independence, and his family has reasons to be involved. A conversation has to weigh those reasons before the maxim can guide it.
Consider a family in which an eighty-five-year-old father insists on driving himself to the store and to church, though his eyesight is failing and he has had two minor accidents this year. His daughter wants to take his car keys, while his son says it’s Dad’s life and Dad’s decision and that the rest of them should mind their own business, and the father agrees with his son, loudly. Does the maxim settle anything here, or does it just restate the disagreement? The argument is painful because each person has something real to lose.
The Charmides would recognize the problem at once, since Charmides offers “doing one’s own business” as a definition of temperance, and Socrates shows how slippery the phrase is. Taken literally, he points out, it would mean everyone making his own cloak, his own shoes and his own oil-flask, “keeping his hands off what belongs to others,” which no sensible city would want. He concludes that whoever said it must have been speaking in riddles, “on the view that it is hard to know what on earth doing one’s own business is.” The maxim sounds clear until you ask what belongs to whom. Socrates’ point is that the phrase hides a question rather than answering it, since it tells you to keep to what is yours without telling you what is.
The family case shows exactly where the riddle bites, since in one sense the father’s driving is obviously his own business, his car, his independence and his life, but the consequences don’t stay with him. If he crashes, other drivers and pedestrians may be hurt, and his children will be the ones visiting him in hospital, arranging his care and perhaps paying for it. A decision whose costs fall on several people is not simply one person’s business, and the maxim can’t tell us how to divide it.
The philosopher John Stuart Mill tried to draw the line precisely. Interference with a person’s liberty is justified only to prevent harm to others, he argued, and over matters that concern only himself, his own body and mind, the individual is sovereign. That principle gives the son a strong argument, since a competent adult’s risky choices about his own life are his to make. But it also gives the daughter one, since driving on public roads is not a matter that concerns only oneself, and Mill’s own principle allows intervention when other people are put at risk. Mill distinguishes mature adults from people who still require others to make decisions for them. In the example, impaired eyesight gives the family a reason to discuss safety. The father’s judgment is a separate question.
So before the maxim can offer sound guidance, two things have to be settled. The first is ownership, whose decision this really is, which depends on who bears the consequences and who has a recognized right to decide. The second is obligation, what family members owe each other, since a daughter who expects to provide care may have responsibilities different from a distant relative’s. Neither question is answered by the slogan, and both have to be answered for the slogan to mean anything. Families usually work these questions out without naming them, and the arguments turn bitter when one member treats them as already settled in his favor.
Critias, in the dialogue, tries to rescue the formula by redefining what counts as one’s own. On his account, Socrates says, it is what is appropriate to one, and one’s own, that he calls good. That move is suggestive for the family case, since what belongs to a person might be understood not as whatever he happens to control but as what is fitting for him, given his relationships and responsibilities. A father’s safety is his own, but his family’s grief is theirs, and a sound decision has to fit both. Socrates goes on to show that Critias’ version has troubles of its own, but the instinct to define ownership by what fits a person rather than by what he controls is worth keeping.
The son’s concern deserves weight. Families can slide from care into control with the best of intentions. The father’s wishes, his knowledge of his own situation, and his freedom to make decisions all matter. The danger to other people also matters. The first useful conversation would give him a chance to say what he stands to lose and the others a chance to explain which risks concern them.
“Mind your own business” can help after the family has asked what is the father’s to decide and what other people have reason to care about. The Charmides makes us ask what counts as one’s own before we can apply the rule. In the family’s case, the next step in the argument is to be clear about who is affected, what they owe each other, and what the father would have to give up.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does Socrates' criticism in the Charmides weaken the maxim “do your own business” as an immediate solution to the family dispute?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When the effects of a personal choice spread to relatives or strangers, how should we decide whether it remains primarily that person's own business?→
- What questions could the family ask to distinguish genuine care for the father from an attempt to control him?→
- Should the burdens that relatives expect to bear—such as providing care—give them a greater voice in a person's decision? Why or why not?→