Philosophy

Who Gets to Be That Doctor?

Socrates offers to treat a headache and ends up asking about character. The two tasks call for different kinds of knowledge.

The Thracian says it’s a mistake to have one doctor for health and another for temperance. A physician, an educator and a philosopher each bring something to the job, and each has limits.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • One patient, two kinds of careThe Thracian doctor objects to treating bodily health and temperance separately. The objection leaves open what qualifies someone to care for both.
  • Two ways of dividing the workThe Gorgias distinguishes arts that care for the body from arts that care for the soul. The Republic shows how physical training and music can both shape character.
  • Spotting a pretenderLater, Socrates asks whether Critias’ account of temperance can tell a real doctor from someone who only seems to know medicine. The account they are testing cannot do that by itself.
  • Socrates asks before treatingSocrates offers to look into temperance with Charmides and lets him decline. Their inquiry leaves the question of the right practitioner open while showing one way to begin.

The Thracian’s complaint is short and sharp, and it lands on the way a profession divides its work. The mistake made nowadays in treating human beings, he said, is that “some try to be doctors of the two separately, of temperance and of health.” He’s against splitting the person into two departments, one for the body and one for character, each with its own specialist. What he doesn’t tell Socrates is who should take over the combined job, and that’s a question worth pressing, because the moment you try to name the right practitioner, the problems pile up.

The first candidate is the ordinary doctor, and the doctors Socrates describes are already partway there. When someone comes in with sore eyes, they consider the head and put the whole body on a regimen. Their job already extends well beyond the place where it hurts. The harder question is what qualifies such a doctor to examine the patient’s character or say what temperance is. Taking care of the whole body leaves the Thracian’s next step to explain.

Socrates draws a different map in another dialogue. In the Gorgias, Socrates divides the care of human beings into two arts, one for the body, made up of gymnastics and medicine, and one for the soul, which he calls politics and splits into legislation and justice. The division helps him ask what real care is in each domain and what only passes for it. Put the two dialogues side by side and you can feel a tension. The Gorgias distinguishes the different kinds of work. The Thracian wants to know what happens to a patient when those kinds of care are kept apart.

The Republic gives us another way to think about the job. Talking about how the city’s guardians should be raised, Socrates says that the people who set up education in music and gymnastics aimed both arts at the soul, since physical training can shape a young person’s spirit and music can soften it. The task is to keep the two in balance. On this view the practitioner who joins body and character is the educator, the person who designs a whole upbringing. The setting of the Charmides makes that possibility easy to picture. This wrestling school turns out to be a place where souls get tested as well as bodies.

That answer brings its own danger, and it’s the danger the question was really pointing at. A practitioner who claims authority over both your body and your character has enormous power. Think of a coach who starts by telling you how to train and ends up deciding what kind of person you’re allowed to be. Connecting bodily treatment with the cultivation of character is only responsible if the person doing it knows where his knowledge stops. The more a practitioner claims to know about the whole of you, the more you need to know about the limits of what he knows.

The Charmides puts that very problem at the center of its argument. Socrates later argues that the kind of temperance Critias defines couldn’t tell “a doctor who knows the things of his craft from one who does not know them but pretends or thinks he does,” and a practitioner who wants to treat both health and temperance would need that discernment himself. Critias’ account is under examination here, and it can’t by itself certify the kind of expertise the job would require. A person who took it as a license to do both could turn out to be a quack with a much bigger territory. A specialist who overreaches can hurt your knee, but a whole-person healer who overreaches can hurt your life.

That makes Socrates’ own position in the dialogue revealing. He agrees to pass for a doctor, explains where he learned the charm, and offers the boy a way out. As he puts it, “I in turn won’t set about my doctoring without looking into things.” In the wrestling school, what he can actually offer is a shared inquiry. By the end he calls himself a poor inquirer, even as he insists that temperance is a great good. He’s willing to ask what would help, and willing to say when he hasn’t found out.

My verdict is that the dialogue leaves the job open but gives us something to look for in a candidate. Anyone who wants to care for body and character together would have to know the limits of his knowledge and ask before he treats. That sounds like a form of the very virtue the Charmides is trying to define. The scene gives us a man sitting on a bench asking the person in front of him whether he wants to look into it together. That’s a modest beginning for a very big job.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does the article characterize the tension between the Gorgias and the Thracian’s complaint?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.