Philosophy

Who Gets a Choice?

With a guardian and a crowd looking on, even an invitation can be hard to turn down.

Socrates sets a condition for treating Charmides’ headache, then invites him to examine his temperance together. By the end, it’s Socrates who asks whether he’ll be given a choice.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The terms of treatmentSocrates initially offers the headache remedy on condition that Charmides first agree to let him treat his soul.
  • An invitation to inquireWhen Charmides hesitates to judge his own temperance, Socrates offers to examine it together or leave the matter alone.
  • A choice in publicCharmides answers with his guardian and a crowd looking on, and he worries about contradicting Critias or sounding boastful.
  • The closing reversalAfter Critias orders Charmides to stay with Socrates, Socrates jokes that the pair will use force without giving him a hearing.

Charmides 155a, 155b–d, 157b–c, 158b–c, 158d–e, 176b–d · Xenophon, Hellenica 2.4.19

The first offer Socrates makes comes as a package deal. After explaining the Thracian’s medicine, Socrates tells the boy, “if you are willing, as the stranger instructed, to hand over your soul first to be charmed with the Thracian’s charms, I shall apply the remedy to your head. But if not, there would be nothing we could do for you, my dear Charmides.” That’s a bundled choice, like a doctor who will only prescribe the pills if you also agree to physical therapy. Under the terms of this first offer, saying no means walking away without the thing you came for.

The second offer, a page or so later, is much looser, because when Socrates proposes to look into whether the boy actually has temperance, he says they should do it together, so the boy won’t be forced to say what he doesn’t want to, and adds, “So if you’d like, I am willing to look into it with you; if not, let’s leave it.” This time Socrates offers to drop the inquiry if Charmides would rather leave it. Charmides answers, “Why, I’d like nothing better.” It’s the difference between a contract and an invitation.

Put the two gestures side by side and you can see how carefully choice is being distributed. The first one sets the terms of the treatment, and Socrates presents those terms as fixed, bound by his oath to the Thracian, so the boy can accept them or not but can’t renegotiate them. Before the second offer, Socrates says Charmides can have the remedy straightaway if he already has enough temperance. Now he gives the boy a say in whether the inquiry goes ahead. Charmides agrees and leaves the method to Socrates. Socrates even ties his own hands in the second offer, promising not to set about his doctoring without looking into things, so the examiner accepts conditions too.

Still, it’s fair to ask how free the first choice really is. The boy was told he would meet a doctor about his complaint. As Socrates first presents the offer, refusing the soul treatment means giving up the remedy, so the headache puts a thumb on the scale. On top of that his guardian, who arranged the meeting, is sitting right there, and a ring of spectators is watching, which is not the setting in which a teenager feels most free to say no to anything. Charmides spells out the difficulty when he hesitates to answer about his temperance. To deny it would make Critias look like a liar, and to claim it would sound like boasting.

Plato presents the heavy head as an everyday complaint, which keeps the stakes of the remedy fairly low. The social pressure is harder to brush off, especially after Critias has praised the boy’s temperance in public. If anything, the movement from the first offer to the second looks like a correction, as if Socrates, having set firm terms for the medicine, makes sure the actual examination is something the boy can agree to before it starts. Whether he would feel just as free to decline in front of Critias is another question.

Then the last page turns the whole question around. Charmides decides he wants to be charmed every day, Critias orders him to stick with Socrates, and when Socrates asks what the two of them are plotting, Charmides says they’ve finished plotting, and Socrates asks, “So you’ll use force,” adding, “and won’t even give me a preliminary hearing?” The word for that hearing is a legal term, an examination before a trial. Socrates jokingly complains that the pair have made up their minds before giving him a chance to be heard.

The reversal is a joke, and an affectionate one, since what the boy and his guardian are forcing on Socrates is the chance to keep teaching. But it’s a joke with a point, because it shows that the person who offered choice all afternoon ends up with none, and that the boy’s own decision comes wrapped in his guardian’s command, since Charmides says he’ll follow Socrates because “this man here gives the orders.” The careful distribution of choice in the opening gets scrambled at the end by the old structures of family and authority that were sitting on the bench all along. The freedom Socrates built so carefully gets swallowed, in the last lines, by a teenager obeying his guardian.

My verdict is that the Charmides takes consent more seriously than its playful surface suggests. Socrates sets terms for the remedy and then makes room for the boy to decline the inquiry. The guardian and the crowd lean on that choice all the same. The closing joke about force, with Socrates denied the chance to be heard, reminds us how fragile that freedom is, and readers who know what force would later mean for Critias and Charmides can hardly miss the warning folded inside the laugh, about what happens to choice when force starts making the decisions.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What is the most important difference between Socrates’ first and second offers to Charmides?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.