Philosophy

What Makes Words Beautiful Enough to Heal?

A compliment makes Charmides blush. The harder questions give him something to keep thinking about.

The Thracian says the soul is treated with charms, and that “these charms are beautiful words.” The dialogue is full of words of every kind, praise, jokes and hard questions, so which ones actually do the healing?

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Beauty moves into speechThe healer calls his charms beautiful words. The adjective Socrates uses can describe someone’s looks or call words fine and admirable.
  • Pleasant words can misleadCharmides blushes at Socrates’ praise. In the Gorgias, a cook wins over children by offering what tastes good, while the doctor has their health in mind.
  • An answer in his own wordsSocrates asks Charmides to look into temperance with him. The invitation gives him room to speak honestly about what he thinks.
  • Honey on the cupLucretius compares the appeal of his verse to honey on a cup of bitter medicine. Praise and jokes can help Charmides stay with questions that are hard to answer.

The definition of the charm is short and strange. The soul, the Thracian says, “is treated with certain charms, and these charms are beautiful words,” and from words like these temperance comes to be in souls. The Greek for “beautiful words” is logoi kaloi, and both halves matter, since logoi can mean words, speeches or arguments, and kalos, which can mean fine as well as beautiful, has already been used of Charmides’ looks. We hear the same adjective move from the body to speech. What would make an argument beautiful in that way?

There are four natural candidates for what makes words beautiful in this way. Words might be beautiful because they’re attractive, pleasant to hear and flattering to the listener, or because they’re true, or because they fit the person and the moment, or simply because they have a good effect, leaving the listener better than they found him. Each of these has some pull, and the dialogue gives us examples of all of them, so the best way to decide is to test each candidate against the kinds of words we actually hear Socrates use with the boy.

Attractive words come first, because there are plenty of them. Socrates pours out praise for the boy’s family, celebrated by Anacreon and Solon, and for his looks, which fall short of none of his ancestors, and it’s gorgeous, flattering talk. What we see it produce is a blush and a dilemma. Plato elsewhere gives us a way to think about words whose first aim is to please. In the Gorgias, Socrates compares cookery to a counterfeit of medicine and flattering rhetoric to a counterfeit of justice. He imagines a cook beating a doctor in front of children who know which food tastes better. Later he makes the comparison into a trial, with himself in the doctor’s place and a cook accusing him of giving the children bitter medicine.

Truth looks like a much better candidate. When Charmides offers a definition he picked up from somebody else, Socrates calls him a rascal and guesses where he got it. A moment later he agrees that what matters is whether it’s true, whoever said it. Still, a speaker can be right and leave his listener on the defensive. Socrates describes Critias growing impatient as Charmides struggles with the borrowed words. Getting to the truth takes attention to the people doing the talking.

Fit matters too, and Socrates pays close attention to it. He proposes to look into the boy’s temperance together, so that Charmides “won’t be forced to say what you don’t want to,” and he goes easier on the young man than on his guardian, explaining that “it is no wonder that he doesn’t know, at his age.” Words that are true but badly fitted to the listener tend to bounce off, and a good part of what Socrates does in this dialogue is tailoring hard truths to a particular young man on a particular afternoon. The questions stay hard. A good moment and a suitable tone give the boy room to answer.

What effect can we actually see? Charmides finishes the dialogue saying he doesn’t know whether he has temperance and wants to be charmed every day. Critias soon turns that wish into an order, so it’s hard to know how much to make of it. But the boy has said something about himself in his own words, and he’s asked to keep going. That gives us something to look for in the questions that got him there.

That suggests a picture of how the dialogue’s different kinds of words fit together. The Roman poet Lucretius, centuries later, compared his own verse to the honey a doctor smears on the rim of a cup of bitter medicine so a child will drink it. The Charmides works something like that. The praise and the jokes are the honey on the rim, making the boy willing to stay at the table, and the challenging questions are the medicine itself, which is why the beauty of the charm can’t simply be the beauty of the honey. Honey alone is just candy, and medicine alone stays in the cup.

My verdict is that words have the kind of beauty the charm asks for when they’re true and fitted to the person hearing them. Praise and jokes can get Charmides listening. The hard questions give him something to think about once he is. If the crowd came to the gym for one kind of beauty, the boy leaves with a chance to learn what another kind can do.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author reject attractiveness alone as the defining beauty of healing words?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.