Philosophy

What Herodotus Actually Says About Zalmoxis

Herodotus reports that the Getae believe death takes them to Zalmoxis. Socrates introduces doctors of Zalmoxis who treat souls, a detail that changes what the old story is for.

Herodotus gives two accounts of Zalmoxis and reserves his judgment. The Charmides gives the name a new job in a story about a headache, beautiful words, and the care of the soul.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The Getae’s accountHerodotus reports that the Getae believe the dead go to Zalmoxis and that they send a messenger to him by lot.
  • The Greek story differsGreeks around the Hellespont and Pontus tell of a former slave of Pythagoras. Herodotus doubts the chronology and leaves the identity of Zalmoxis open.
  • What Socrates addsThe doctor in the Charmides says the body’s health depends on first treating the soul. Herodotus’ account supplies no such medical teaching.
  • The charm in practiceSocrates describes beautiful words and asks Charmides to entrust him with his soul. The story gives the conversation that follows the shape of a treatment.

Charmides 155d–e, 156d–157b, 157b–c, 158b, 164d–165a · Herodotus, Histories 4.36, 4.93, 4.94, 4.95, 4.96 · Strabo, Geography 7.3.5 · Phaedrus 270b–c

Socrates gives the charm an unusual pedigree. He says he learned it from “one of the Thracian doctors of Zalmoxis,” people “who are said even to make one immortal.” The Greek verb behind making immortal, apathanatizein, is a prefixed form of the verb Herodotus uses for the Getae. A reader who knew that account could hear an echo. The point of listening for it is to notice what changes when the name enters a story about a doctor and a boy with a headache.

Herodotus’ account, in the fourth book of his Histories, is vivid and carefully hedged. The Getae, a Thracian people of the lower Danube, are described as making themselves immortal, because they believe that they don’t die but go to Zalmoxis when they leave this life. At regular intervals, Herodotus reports, they choose a messenger by lot and send him to Zalmoxis by tossing him onto upturned spears, and if he dies they take it that the god is favorable. He adds that they shoot arrows at the sky during thunderstorms, threatening the god, because they recognize no god but their own. That is reported belief, the Getae’s own view as Herodotus heard it, and he passes it on without endorsing it.

Herodotus then gives a different story, from the Greeks living around the Hellespont and the Black Sea. According to them, Zalmoxis was a man, a former slave of Pythagoras on Samos, who grew rich, went home to Thrace, and taught the leading Thracians at banquets that they would live forever. Then he hid in an underground chamber for three years while they mourned him, and reappeared in the fourth year, which convinced them. Herodotus says he neither disbelieves this story nor believes it too much, that he thinks Zalmoxis lived long before Pythagoras, and that whether Zalmoxis was a man or a native god of the Getae, he will let the question go. Herodotus takes leave of the question with a form of the same Greek verb Critias later discusses as the greeting “Rejoice!”

Herodotus gives Zalmoxis no medical practice. He says nothing about doctors who serve him, charms that cure, or treating the soul before the body. Those elements belong to the story Socrates tells in the Charmides. Its attention to the whole person has a parallel in the Phaedrus, where the speakers appeal to Hippocrates, though the two passages put their medical models to different uses.

So three things need to be kept apart, beginning with reported belief, the Getae’s faith in going to Zalmoxis, which Herodotus records as their belief. Then there is historical evidence, which for Zalmoxis is very thin, a few passages in Herodotus and later writers such as Strabo, who says Zalmoxis had traveled in Egypt and became a priest and adviser to a Thracian king. And there is literary use, Plato’s use of the name and its association with immortality in a story about healing. Later writers kept embroidering the figure, which shows how easily a name with a reputation attracts stories.

The literary use makes good sense in its context. The Charmides needs a reason for Socrates to have a cure for the soul, and a doctor from the edge of the Greek world, serving a god associated with immortality, is a striking and memorable source, whose reputation gives the remedy some of its force. The name of Abaris the Hyperborean, mentioned a little later alongside Zalmoxis, does the same job. Herodotus mentions Abaris too, telling the tale that he carried an arrow around the whole earth without eating, and declining to say more, so both figures came to Plato’s readers wrapped in Herodotus’ own reserve. A reader who knows Herodotus can recognize the names and see that the story Socrates tells gives them a different purpose.

What the background can’t do is turn the medical tale into a documented initiation rite. Neither account describes Socrates being initiated into Thracian mysteries or records a ritual formula. Socrates himself admits, just before introducing the charm, that he managed somehow to answer the boy’s question about knowing a remedy when he wasn’t sure he did, and the dialogue goes on to suggest that the charm is simply conversation of the right kind, an invitation the boy can hear and consider in the middle of the wrestling school.

The name Zalmoxis brings with it stories of people who expect to live beyond death. The Charmides uses that reputation in a scene concerned with something more immediate, the state of a boy’s soul and what a conversation might do for it. Herodotus lets his own question about the god go. Socrates takes the name into the wrestling school, where the next thing he has to do is get Charmides to talk.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does the article characterize Herodotus’ position on the Greek story that Zalmoxis had once been a human being?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.