Philosophy
Too Shy for the Assembly
Plato’s Charmides blushes when asked whether he is temperate. Xenophon’s Charmides gives good advice in private but hesitates to speak in the Assembly.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesThe two portraits put shame to different tests. Plato asks whether modesty is always good, and Xenophon asks when it keeps a capable person from serving the city.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A blush with a reasonCharmides would slight Critias by denying his temperance and praise himself by claiming it. He explains why both answers are awkward.
- When modesty does harmSocrates cites Homer’s beggar to show that shame can keep a person from doing something necessary.
- The same hesitation in publicXenophon’s Charmides can advise politicians in private. Socrates asks why he can’t put his ability to work before the Assembly.
- What the comparison can tell usPlato and Xenophon give shame different settings and stakes. Their two portraits can illuminate one another without establishing how Charmides changed over time.
Charmides 158c–159b, 160e, 161a–b, 163b · Homer, Odyssey 17.347 · Xenophon, Memorabilia 3.7.1, 3.7.3–4, 3.7.5–6, 3.7.9 · Thucydides, History of the Peloponnesian War 2.40.2 · Xenophon, Hellenica 2.4.19
When Socrates first asks Charmides whether he has temperance, the boy blushes. Plato says “his bashfulness was becoming at his age,” and the answer that follows is a model of tact, since Charmides explains that denying it would make Critias a liar and affirming it would mean praising himself, which “will probably seem obnoxious.” A little later his second definition is that temperance “makes a person feel shame and makes him bashful, and that temperance is the same thing as modesty,” and the adjective for being bashful is the same one Socrates used to describe his blush. The young Charmides, in other words, identifies temperance with the very quality he displays. Socrates calls the bashfulness becoming, and Charmides shows real tact in explaining his predicament.
Socrates refutes that definition with a line from Homer. “Modesty is no good thing to be present with a man in need,” the line runs, and Charmides agrees that Homer is right, so modesty is sometimes not good, while temperance is always good, and the two can’t be the same. The point is a sharp one, since a quality that holds a person back when he needs to act can’t be the whole of a virtue that always makes its owner better.
Xenophon gives us a Charmides who seems to have grown up into exactly the problem Homer’s line describes. In the Memorabilia, Socrates sees Charmides, a man of real worth and far more capable than the politicians of the day, shrinking from speaking before the people and taking part in public affairs. Socrates asks what he would think of a man who could win at a major athletic contest but refused to compete, and then points out that Charmides gives excellent advice in private to men in public life, and corrects them well when they go wrong. Charmides objects that speaking in private and contending before a crowd are not the same. The scene assumes a Charmides whose political friends consult him, someone whose ability matters to people already in public life.
Socrates’ reply is the heart of the passage, pointing out that Charmides is not ashamed to speak before the wisest and most powerful men but is ashamed before the most foolish and weakest, and asking who exactly frightens him, the fullers, the shoemakers, the carpenters, the smiths, the farmers or the traders in the market, since the Assembly is made up of them. Then he adds advice that sounds like it was written for the Charmides, telling him not to be ignorant of himself, and not to make the mistake most people make of examining other people’s affairs while never turning to examine their own. The list of tradesmen is pointed, since Critias in the Charmides had sneered at cobblers, and Xenophon’s Socrates treats the same people as the citizens a good man should be willing to address.
The two portraits rhyme in a way that is hard to ignore. In Plato, Charmides proposes that temperance is modesty, and Socrates shows that modesty is no good for a person in need. In Xenophon, Charmides’ modesty keeps him out of public life when the city needs him, and Socrates tells him to overcome it. And the phrase Charmides offers for temperance right after the modesty definition, “doing one’s own business,” can suggest staying out of other people’s affairs. Set beside Xenophon’s scene, that raises the question of when staying out of affairs means staying out of public life. Xenophon may not have intended the echo, but a reader who knows both books can hardly miss it.
The Athenian background sharpens the point, since Pericles, in the funeral speech Thucydides gives him, says that Athens regards a man who takes no part in public affairs not as one who minds his own business but as useless. Charmides’ reluctance in Xenophon, and his definitions in Plato, make Pericles’ distinction tangible. A person may think he is simply minding his own affairs when his fellow citizens would say he is withholding something they need.
The differences between the portraits are real, though, and they keep us from stitching them into a single life story. Plato’s Charmides is a teenager, and Xenophon’s is a grown man. Plato’s Socrates examines definitions and reaches no conclusion, while Xenophon’s gives practical encouragement and expects results. Plato shows Charmides’ ability only in hints, a borrowed definition and a sly laugh, while Xenophon simply asserts it. And Plato writes with the oligarchy hanging over the ending, while Xenophon’s scene, in a book written to defend Socrates, shows him trying to steer the young man toward public service under the democracy. Xenophon also records Charmides’ death fighting alongside the oligarchs. The encouragement to serve the city in the Memorabilia has its own irony for a reader who knows the Hellenica.
Xenophon’s scene puts a crowd on the other side of Plato’s blush. A young man can be right to hesitate before praising himself, while someone who can help his city may need to speak despite the same discomfort. The portraits leave us with a better question about Charmides than a continuous life story would. What would it take for someone with his private judgment to use it well in public?
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the Homeric line undermine Charmides’ claim that temperance is identical to modesty?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When does modesty protect a person from arrogance, and when does it become an excuse for avoiding necessary action?→
- How should someone decide whether “doing one’s own business” is responsible self-restraint or a failure to meet obligations to the community?→
- Does private competence create a duty to participate in public life? What further considerations would be needed to answer that question?→