Philosophy
The Kid Learns the Trick
Charmides laughs, looks at Critias and wonders aloud whether the man behind a saying understood it himself. The young man has found a way to make his guardian take a turn.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesA well-timed joke can make someone else answer for a claim. Charmides uses a move that resembles Socrates’ own questioning, and the resemblance brings out how differently the same technique can be used.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A joke shifts the burdenWhen Socrates asks what doing one’s own business means, Charmides says he doesn’t know. He suggests its author might be just as puzzled, then laughs and looks at Critias.
- The narrator reads the roomSocrates thinks Charmides wants Critias to answer in his place. The Greek leaves open which of the two Charmides is suggesting has been refuted.
- A familiar way to turn a questionEarlier, Charmides echoed Socrates’ compliment about talking sense. The Apology describes young men who watched Socrates question people and tried it for themselves.
- Critias has to speakCritias stops holding back and takes over the defense. Charmides’ joke helps keep the inquiry going, even as it gets him out of having to explain the saying himself.
The moment is tiny and perfectly timed, and it’s easy to read past it. Socrates has just shown that “doing one’s own business” can’t mean what it sounds like, since a city where everyone wove his own cloak and cobbled his own shoes would be a mess, and he asks the boy what the phrase could mean instead. Charmides answers, “By Zeus, I don’t know,” and then adds that perhaps the man who said it didn’t know what he meant either. Socrates tells us that “he laughed slyly and looked across at Critias.” In one laugh and one glance, the burden of the whole argument changes hands, and Plato records the glance as carefully as any line of dialogue.
Humor can give a person with less power some room to speak. A kid can tell a parent something in a joke that would sound like a complaint if said straight. An employee can try the same thing in a meeting. What these all have in common is deniability, since a joke can always be withdrawn as “just a joke,” and the boy’s laugh gives him something like that room. He can suggest that his guardian didn’t understand the saying while leaving it to Critias to decide whether to take the remark personally. A joke is a way of saying something while keeping one foot outside it. The glance makes the target clear without Charmides having to name him.
Socrates gives us his reading of the boy’s strategy in the next lines. Charmides, wanting not to answer for the definition himself but to have Critias answer for it, “kept prodding him,” and “made out that he had been refuted.” The Greek leaves open whether the boy is making out that he himself was refuted or that Critias was, but either way the boy is playing a part for effect, so the ward who blushed when asked about his character is now steering the conversation from his seat. He has rearranged the responsibilities in the room without ever openly challenging anybody, which is a real piece of agency, even if it’s exercised sideways.
One place to look for the boy’s model is the man who has been questioning him. Earlier, when he described the trap of being asked whether he was temperate, Socrates told him, “You seem to me to be talking sense, Charmides,” and later, when Socrates agreed that the source of an idea doesn’t matter, the boy told him, “Now you are talking sense,” handing the teacher’s own compliment back to him with a straight face. It’s the kind of thing a student does when he recognizes a teacher’s turn of phrase and tries it out for himself. Whether or not Charmides learned it from Socrates, he knows how to turn a polite phrase into a quiet challenge.
The sly laugh is the same skill turned on a bigger target. A familiar Socratic move is to ask people who claim to know something to explain it and let them hear where their answers lead. In the Apology he says that wealthy young men followed him around because they enjoyed watching people examined and then went off to examine others themselves. Charmides already remembers Socrates from when he was a boy. Here he does something close to the imitation described in the Apology, putting pressure on an adult whose authority matters to him to show what he knows.
The resemblance is both a compliment to Socrates and a warning. It shows how easily a turn of phrase or a gesture can be picked up, the way a kid watching a comedian starts timing his own jokes. In Socrates’ account, the joke helps Charmides get out from under the saying. It also raises a question that deserves an answer. Critias can show whether he understands what he’s defending, and it’s the next exchange that will tell us how much the joke has achieved.
Still, the provocation does real work for the dialogue, whatever the boy’s motives. It brings Critias, whom Socrates expects to know because of his age and study, out from the sidelines and into the argument. The boy’s mischief, in other words, delivers the right examinee to the examiner, and the second half of the dialogue depends on it. It’s a nice example of a conversation getting somewhere because somebody wants to get out of it.
My verdict is that the sly laugh is one of the clearest moments when the boy changes the course of the inquiry. Humor lets an apparently obedient ward redistribute the burdens of a conversation without openly defying anyone, and his move would be at home in the hands of the man questioning him. The dialogue lets us enjoy the cleverness and notice its limits. It’s one thing to make someone else answer. The harder trick is to stay in your seat when it’s your turn again.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
According to the article, what does Charmides accomplish through his sly laugh and glance at Critias?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When does indirect humor create genuine agency for someone with less power, and when might its deniability weaken the challenge being made?→
- If Charmides is imitating Socrates’ methods, what responsibility might a teacher bear for how students use the conversational techniques they learn?→
- Does shifting the burden of answering count as progress toward understanding, or does it mainly allow Charmides to evade his own role in the inquiry?→