Philosophy

The First Treatment Is a Question

Charmides comes in for a remedy for his head. The conversation turns when Socrates asks him to say what sort of person he is.

The Thracian says the soul must be treated first. Socrates tells Charmides he can skip the charm if he already has enough temperance. The exception changes what it means to put the soul first.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The order of treatmentThe Thracian’s rule puts care of the soul before treatment of the head. Socrates initially tells Charmides that the leaf is useless without the charm.
  • When the charm can be skippedSocrates says Charmides can have the leaf straightaway if he already has enough temperance. The charm is meant to supply something that might already be there.
  • A hard answer to giveClaiming temperance could sound like boasting. Denying it would contradict Critias, who has just told the room how temperate Charmides is thought to be.
  • A question they can shareCharmides blushes and says he doesn’t know how to answer. Socrates proposes that they look into it together and gives Charmides the choice to decline.

The Thracian’s rule sounds like a fixed order of operations. The soul “must be treated first and foremost,” he says, “if the head and the rest of the body are to be in good condition,” and Socrates says he swore to give the remedy only to someone who first agreed to hand over his soul for treatment. You could picture this as a ritual everybody has to sit through, the way every passenger has to watch the safety demonstration before takeoff whether or not they’ve flown a hundred times, with the charm as a kind of compulsory spiritual preamble to the real medicine. That would make the charm a box to tick, the same for everyone, and the soul’s priority a matter of procedure.

Then Socrates adds a detail that changes the picture completely. After praising the boy’s family to the skies, he says, “If temperance is already present in you, as Critias here says, and you are temperate enough, then you would have no further need of charms, whether of Zalmoxis or of Abaris the Hyperborean,” the legendary figure from the far north whom Herodotus mentions in a story about carrying an arrow around the world while fasting. Here Socrates names two healers whose charms are meant to sound impressive. The boy might need neither. In that case, Socrates goes on, “the remedy for the head itself should be given you straightaway,” and if the boy seems to be lacking temperance, “the charm must be sung before the remedy is given.”

Socrates is treating the charm as something for a particular need. What has to come first is the question of whether the charm is needed. Think of the eye chart at the optician’s. The first job is to find out whether you need glasses at all. In Socrates’ version, the place of the soul at the front of the queue means checking its condition before anybody hands out leaves.

That makes the very first treatment in the Charmides a question, and Socrates asks it directly. “So tell me yourself,” he says to the boy, “do you agree with Critias here, and say that you already have a sufficient share of temperance, or that you are lacking in it?” A patient who came in about a heavy head is suddenly being asked to examine his own character, and the medical framing makes that strange request perfectly logical, since what happens next depends on the answer and the patient gets the first say. It’s like a doctor who, instead of reaching for the prescription pad, asks how you’ve really been and then waits for the answer.

The condition also says something important about what temperance does in the Thracian’s scheme. If a temperate person can take the leaf without any charm, then what matters in Socrates’ account is the condition of the soul that the charm is meant to bring about. In this case, temperance is what makes it possible to treat the head on its own. If temperance is already present, there’s nothing for the charm to supply. That also explains why the dialogue can drop the leaf so easily later on, since once the question of temperance is open, the leaf has become the least interesting thing in the room.

There’s a trap in that shortcut. Critias has just told everyone that his ward is thought to be “far and away the most temperate of anyone nowadays,” so by Socrates’ own rule the boy shouldn’t need the charm at all and should get the remedy right now. But to take the shortcut, the boy would have to say out loud that he’s temperate, which might sound like boasting in front of this crowd. And as Charmides points out, denying it would make Critias look like a liar. The shortcut is open in principle and hard to take in public.

That turns the priority of the soul into something more than a medical principle. It becomes a test of honesty, since the first thing the patient must do is give an account of himself, and how he gives it is already evidence about his soul. Charmides blushes and refuses either to claim temperance or to deny it, which is a good answer in its way. Socrates says he’s talking sense and offers to look into it with him, if he wants. The blush is the first symptom the doctor gets to see, and it’s a promising one.

My verdict is that the soul comes first in the Charmides because its condition determines whether Charmides needs the charm. Socrates’ offer to skip the charm shows what that priority amounts to in practice. The genius of the arrangement is that the check starts with a question the patient has to face for himself. A boy who walked in expecting a remedy finds that the first part of his medicine is the effort to say honestly who he is, which no leaf on earth could do for him.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does Socrates’ willingness to skip the charm change the meaning of the rule that the soul must come first?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.