Philosophy

The Family Brand

Critias vouches for his cousin’s character. Socrates asks Charmides what he can say for himself.

Asked whether the boy’s soul is well made, Critias answers with the stock Athenian phrase for a gentleman, which happens to start with the word “beautiful.” Socrates replies by praising the family to the skies and then quietly making the praise of his character conditional.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A gentleman’s complimentWhen Socrates asks about Charmides’ soul, Critias calls him beautiful and good. The familiar compliment carries the language of looks into a question about character.
  • A family recommendationCritias is Charmides’ cousin and guardian. His praise also reflects on the family he belongs to.
  • Praise with a conditionSocrates praises both sides of the family and Charmides’ looks. He makes the boy’s temperance a condition that still has to be examined.
  • An awkward questionCharmides would sound vain if he claimed to be temperate, and contradict Critias if he denied it. Socrates proposes that they investigate together.

Charmides 154e–155a, 157b–e, 157e–158c, 158c–e · Diogenes Laertius, Lives of the Eminent Philosophers 3.1 · Xenophon, Hellenica 2.4.19

The question was about the soul, and that’s what makes the answer so funny. Socrates has just said the boy would be unbeatable if he were well made where his soul is concerned, adding that he ought to be, “coming from your family,” and Critias fires back, “Oh, he’s thoroughly beautiful and good,” then adds “in that respect too.” The phrase is kalos kagathos, the standard Athenian label for a gentleman of the proper sort, and the joke is hiding in plain sight, because asked about the inside of the boy, Critias reports that he’s beautiful there as well. The conversation’s favorite adjective simply walks into the soul and sits down, which is a bit like asking whether a new hire is honest and being told he’s gorgeous inside and out.

Critias is hardly a neutral reference, either, whatever he might like Socrates to think, since he’s the boy’s cousin and guardian, and the family he’s vouching for is his own, since both of them descend from the house Socrates will soon praise as “the house of Critias son of Dropides,” an ancestor the two cousins are understood to share. When Critias calls Charmides beautiful and good, he’s also polishing a family name he carries himself, and he keeps at it, assuring Socrates a moment later that the boy “is thought to surpass those his age not only in his looks, but in the very thing you say you have the charm for.” It’s the proud uncle at the graduation party, talking up the kid in a way that also happens to talk up the uncle.

Then Socrates outdoes him, and by a wide margin. The boy’s father’s side, he says, has come down to them “celebrated by Anacreon and by Solon and by many other poets for its outstanding beauty and virtue and everything else that goes by the name of happiness,” and his mother’s side is no different, since, as the story went, nobody on the continent was thought handsomer or bigger than his uncle Pyrilampes when he went as an ambassador to Persia. “Born of such people,” Socrates concludes, “you are likely to be first in everything,” and there’s a smile in that whole speech, especially in the image of an ambassador famous for being tall and good-looking.

Now watch the turn Socrates makes next, because it’s beautifully done. As far as the boy’s visible looks go, Socrates says flatly that he falls short of none of his ancestors, and when it comes to the soul he switches to a conditional and hands the responsibility to someone else, saying, “if, as Critias here says, you are also well enough endowed for temperance and the rest, then blessed is the child, my dear Charmides,” “your mother bore,” before springing a fork on him. If temperance is already present, the boy doesn’t need any charm and should get the headache remedy right away, and if it isn’t, the charm comes first, so he asks the boy himself which it is.

The gap that opens here is the one between a credential and a quality. “Beautiful and good” is a social verdict, the kind of label a family name or a famous school or a verified checkmark gives you, and it tells the world that a person belongs among the right people. What goodness actually consists in is a different question, and the Thracian doctor had warned Socrates against exactly this shortcut, making him promise “to let no one be so rich, or so wellborn, or so beautiful, as to persuade me to do otherwise” than treat the soul first. Wealth, birth and beauty are precisely the ingredients of the gentleman’s label, so the doctor’s oath is, in effect, an oath against taking the family brand on trust. It’s the difference between a résumé and a reference check, or between a family’s reputation and the person who actually shows up to dinner.

There’s one more investor in this family’s reputation, and it’s Plato himself. Charmides was his mother’s brother, Critias was her cousin, and the famously handsome Pyrilampes later married Plato’s mother, so when Socrates praises this house, Plato is praising his own relatives through Socrates’ mouth. That makes it all the more striking that the same Plato puts the family’s two most famous members under examination, writing after Critias had joined the Thirty and Charmides had served among the Ten in Piraeus. The author doesn’t let his own family skip the test, which is about as strong a statement as a writer can make that a good name settles nothing.

The joke never disappears, which is part of the charm. Critias’ “beautiful” lands in the soul, Socrates matches his bragging with a speech so lavish it borders on parody, and then he turns all that flattery into a question the boy has to answer about himself. Charmides blushes, of course, because a compliment that big is impossible to accept without sounding vain and impossible to refuse without calling his guardian a liar, and that’s the squeeze his question puts Charmides in. Socrates offers him a way out by proposing they look into it together.

My verdict is that the dialogue treats “beautiful and good” as a claim that still needs testing. Critias’ confident compliment is where the inquiry starts, and the rest of the Charmides is the test that nobody gets to skip, not the boy, not the guardian, not the house of Critias son of Dropides, and not even the author whose family it was. The gap between the gentleman’s label and actual goodness is the gap between a reputation you inherit and a soul you have to show, and Socrates closes it the only way it can be closed, by asking.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the article treat Critias as an interested rather than neutral judge of Charmides?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.