Philosophy
Temperate and Not Sure of It
Critias thinks temperance requires knowing yourself. Charmides shows how someone can pay attention to himself and still hesitate to claim the virtue.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesThe boy who won’t call himself temperate asks for the charm every day. His hesitation gives Socrates something better to work with than a confident answer.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The cost of answeringCharmides fears sounding boastful if he claims temperance and making Critias look like a liar if he denies it. His first response is that he doesn’t know how to answer.
- A sense of what’s happeningSocrates suggests that having temperance would give Charmides some sense of it. That is enough to start an inquiry, even if the boy’s opinion is tentative.
- Motives can be hard to readKant says that even careful examination cannot establish with certainty that duty alone moved us. A person can take self-examination seriously and still have doubts.
- He asks to continueAt the end, Charmides still can’t say whether he has temperance. He asks for the charm anyway, showing a willingness to keep examining what he needs.
Charmides 158c, 158c–159a, 164a–d, 175e–176a, 176a–b · Apology 21d · Kant, Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals 4:407
Charmides blushes when Socrates asks whether he’s temperate. He has a reason to hesitate either way. Denying it would make Critias look like a liar and put those who believed him in an awkward spot. Claiming it would “probably seem obnoxious.” His answer is “So I don’t know what answer to give you.” Later, when Socrates imagines a doctor who could act temperately without knowing it, Critias refuses to “ever concede that a man who does not know himself is temperate.” The boy’s hesitation and the guardian’s demand give us two ways to think about what knowing yourself would take.
Socrates offers a third approach when he first questions the boy. If temperance is present in him, he says, it “must give rise to some sense,” and from that he could form an opinion about it. There is a difference between having some feel for what you do and being ready to tell everyone that you possess a virtue. Socrates asks for enough of the first to begin an inquiry. The opinion the boy comes up with can change as they go.
There’s something to be said for Critias’ demand. If temperance includes any kind of self-command, you’d expect a person exercising it to notice what he is doing. If he waits his turn because he has forgotten what he came for, he may look patient without having exercised any patience. The steersman has to be awake. That gets us as far as attention to your conduct, which seems worth asking of a temperate person. There’s still a question about how confidently you have to be able to name what you’re doing.
Kant makes the question sharper in the Groundwork. He says that even careful examination can’t tell us with complete certainty whether we did something solely from duty. Some trace of self-love may be doing work we haven’t noticed. His point is about motives, but it gives us a way of seeing the difficulty here. A person can ask quite honestly why she did a generous thing and have trouble telling how much of it came from generosity. Certainty about one’s virtue is a great deal to ask of that person.
Socrates gives his own uncertainty some credit in the Apology. After talking to a man reputed wise, he thinks he has one advantage. He doesn’t suppose he knows what he doesn’t know. The same restraint can matter when the subject is your character. If you’re sure you’ll behave well in a difficult situation, you may be slower to notice the moment when you’ve started to behave badly. Charmides’ first answer also comes from an awkward social situation, so we can’t give him a medal for blushing. What we can see is that he is willing to look into the question with Socrates.
The doctor and the boy help us keep two kinds of doubt apart. A doctor can know what she’s doing and still be uncertain whether a treatment helped. Charmides’ uncertainty is about what name he should give his own character. His difficulty is sharper by the end, when neither of the older men can give him a definition of temperance. He can recognize a need to go on even while he has doubts about what he possesses.
This gives Critias’ demand a reading it might be able to live with. Self-knowledge could start with attention to what you do and the limits of what you can say about it. You can notice that you are holding back out of fear, for instance, and still be unsure whether you’re learning courage or merely avoiding something awkward. You have some sense of yourself and a question worth pursuing. When Charmides asks to be charmed every day, he puts himself in a position to keep finding out.
My verdict is that an honest doubt about the label can go with the sort of attention temperance needs. Critias is right to ask what a person knows of himself. Socrates gives Charmides a place to start by asking him to notice what he finds and say how it seems to him. The boy can neither certify himself nor give a definition. What he can say, with a clarity he didn’t have when he blushed, is that he would like to come back tomorrow.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What distinction does the article draw between the doctor’s uncertainty and Charmides’ uncertainty?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If a person behaves patiently without recognizing what they are doing, in what sense, if any, have they exercised patience?→
- When does uncertainty about your own virtue encourage honest self-examination, and when might it become an excuse to avoid judgment or action?→
- What degree of self-knowledge should temperance require: awareness of conduct, knowledge of motives, confidence in a moral label, or something else?→