Philosophy

So How’s Philosophy Doing?

Socrates tests what Athens’ most admired young man actually knows—and whether he is willing to learn.

A stylized portrait of a bearded philosopher in vivid blue, pink, yellow and green, with a hand against his chin.

Socrates comes home and asks after philosophy the way you’d ask after a friend who’s been sick. Athens answers by pointing at a teenager.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The SettingCharmides 153d–155a; 157d; 161b–c; 175e–176b
  • The Central QuestionWhen you get back from a long trip you ask the usual stuff, like who got married, who died, what everything costs now and what got built while you were gone.
  • A Closer LookThe phrasing is what gives it away.
  • The Wider ViewThat’s why the second question comes glued to the first.

When you get back from a long trip you ask the usual stuff, like who got married, who died, what everything costs now and what got built while you were gone. Socrates, finally done with the war Q&A, asks two questions of his own, how philosophy is doing these days and whether any of the young guys have turned out outstanding in wisdom, or in beauty, or in both. In the Greek they’re glued together with a plain “and,” as if they were one question in two parts, and honestly that’s a strange way to talk about philosophy, since nobody comes home from a deployment asking how geometry’s been holding up.

The phrasing is what gives it away. Socrates literally asks how philosophy “has it” now, which is the normal Greek way of asking how someone’s doing, the thing you’d ask a friend who’s been sick or a neighbor about his grapes. That means philosophy here has a pulse, so it can be doing well or badly, and it can take a turn for the worse while one of its regulars is away at war. Within fifty years or so Athens would have philosophy schools with buildings, heads and students, Plato’s own Academy among them, but the Charmides is set before all that, in a city where philosophy isn’t a textbook or a campus yet. It lives in people, and if you want to know how it’s doing, you have to go and look at them.

That’s why the second question comes glued to the first. If philosophy lives in people, then checking on the young is checking on philosophy, and asking who’s sharp is really asking whether the thing Socrates cares about has taken root anywhere while he was gone. The beauty part isn’t him getting sidetracked by gossip, either. Athens had a whole ideal for this, the young man who’s “beautiful and good,” the standard phrase for a real gentleman, which Critias is going to use about his ward a minute later, and when Socrates asks for wisdom “or beauty, or both,” he wants to know whether the city has produced somebody whose outside and inside actually match.

Critias only hears half of it, though, because when he looks over at the door, where a bickering crowd of admirers is filing in, he tells Socrates that “as for the beautiful ones” he’ll know in a moment, and wisdom just drops out of the answer without Plato saying a word about it. Notice what has happened here, because Socrates asked for a check-up on philosophy and Critias turned it into a viewing party. The answer to “how’s philosophy doing?” is going to be a celebrity with an entourage, and the room is ready to stare at him long before anyone thinks about listening to him.

Socrates rolls with it and then puts it to use. When Critias assures him the boy is “a philosopher and, in other people’s opinion as well as his own, quite the poet,” Socrates suddenly has his test case, because this is what philosophy looks like in Athens after its most persistent question-asker has been out of town for a while. Charmides comes from a great family, everybody adores him, he writes poetry, and according to Critias he’s “far and away the most temperate of anyone nowadays,” though none of that has ever been tested. The conversation that follows is Socrates’ question getting answered the only way it can be, since he’ll find out how philosophy is doing in Athens by finding out what its star student actually knows about the virtue everybody says he has.

The results are mixed, to put it kindly. Charmides blushes, hesitates, and then answers from his gut, saying first that temperance is a kind of quietness and then that it’s a kind of modesty, and those are honest tries that fail honestly, because they describe how the virtue looks on a well-raised kid and not what it is. His third answer is where it gets funny. “I have just remembered something I once heard someone say,” he begins, “that temperance would be doing one’s own business,” and Socrates clocks it instantly, shooting back, “You rascal! You’ve heard that from Critias here, or from one of the other wise men.” So the big philosophy scene that grew up while Socrates was away turns out to be, at least in part, smart-sounding lines handed down from guardian to ward, admired for how clever they sound and not really understood by the kid repeating them, and when the guardian jumps in to defend his line, he doesn’t do any better.

If the dialogue stopped there it would be a pretty bleak report card, but Socrates asked about a condition, and conditions change. By the end all of Critias’ fancier definitions have crashed too, nobody in the gym can say what temperance is, and Socrates calls himself “a poor inquirer.” The twist is that Charmides isn’t embarrassed but hungry for more. He says he doesn’t know whether he has temperance, since even Socrates and Critias can’t work out what it is, that he “very much” needs the charm, and that nothing’s stopping him “from being charmed by you every day, until you say it’s enough.” Remember that the charm, as Socrates explained back at the start, is made of “beautiful words,” so the kid everyone came to look at now wants to listen, and for the first time in the whole dialogue he wants something other than attention.

So the real answer to “how’s philosophy doing?” isn’t the one Critias gave at the door. Going by its most famous young fan, philosophy in Athens isn’t exactly healthy, but it’s in the exact condition where philosophy actually starts, with a reputation popped and a young guy who has figured out he doesn’t know, asking for more conversation. Plato could have set this in a lecture hall and handed us a thesis to memorize. Instead he turned the state of philosophy into a question about one kid on one afternoon, and he leaves that kid the way a good doctor leaves a patient worth watching, still in treatment.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the article treat Socrates’ questions about philosophy and outstanding young people as two parts of a single inquiry?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.